Independent groups design
- Experimental design refers to how the participant sample is used in combination with the different levels of the independent variable (IV) e.g. if there are two conditions of the IV, the participants may experience both conditions or only one
- There are three main types of experimental design
- Independent groups design
- Repeated measures design
- Matched pairs design
- In an independent groups design participants only experience one condition of the IV e.g:
- Participant A learns a poem with music playing (condition 1)
- Participant B learns the same poem in silence (condition 2)
- Participants are randomly allocated to each condition to avoid researcher bias
- Independent groups design generates unrelated data (because the two groups are separate from one another)
- The performance of the group in condition 1 is compared to the performance of the group in condition 2, e.g:
- Participant A learns a poem with music playing (condition 1) and is asked to write down as much of the poem as they can recall in 5 minutes
- Participant B learns the same poem in silence (condition 2) and is asked to write down as much of the poem as they can recall in 5 minutes
- The dependent variable (DV) is measured as the number of words correctly recalled from the poem
- The number of words correctly recalled by participants in condition 1 is compared to the number of words correctly recalled by participants in condition 2
Evaluation of independent groups design
Strengths
- As the participants take part in only one condition there is no possibility that order effects could affect their performance in the task
- Participants are less likely to succumb to demand characteristics as they take part in only one condition i.e. they don’t get a ‘second bite of the cherry’ as it were
Weaknesses
- Individual differences/participant variables may interfere with the findings e.g. in a memory test one group may have naturally better memory than the other group (which could happen when participants are randomly allocated to conditions)
- More participants are required with this design which can sometimes be problematic