Paper 2 Question 5: Letter Model Answer (AQA GCSE English Language) : Revision Note

Sam Evans

Written by: Sam Evans

Reviewed by: Kate Lee

Updated on

On this page we’ve included a fully annotated sample letter answer to a real past paper Question 5 from Paper 2 of the AQA English Language GCSE. Underneath the example answer, we show you how to structure a full-mark answer, and include some expert tips on how to get to that top grade.

Paper 2 Question 5 Grade 9 letter model answer

If you want to achieve a Grade 9, you should be aiming for a Level 4 across two assessment objectives: AO5 and AO6. Here is a past paper question and an example of a full-length Level 4 model answer.

Worked Example

‘It is people who have extraordinary skill, courage and determination who deserve to be famous, not those who have good looks or lots of money or behave badly.’

Write a letter to the editor of a newspaper in which you argue your point of view in response to this statement.

[24 marks for content and organisation

16 marks for technical accuracy]

[Total: 40 marks]

Answer

Dear Sir/Madam,

I am writing in response to your front-page article from last week (“Gareth Bell’s Rehab Hell”). I was appalled, but unfortunately not at all shocked, that you decided to give more space and time to this so-called “footballer” in your newspaper. It is high time that we, as a society, looked at ourselves in the mirror and decided not to celebrate these “celebrities”: only those who have extraordinary skill, courage and determination deserve to be famous.

I can’t be the only one to believe that those who currently have fame don’t deserve to be role models. Flick through a gossip magazine, or scroll down your own newspaper’s website, and all you’ll be presented with is a pool of talentless Love Island-types, or former sportspeople getting arrested for driving under the influence or tax evasion. Look at Gareth Bell: a third-tier footballer who retired at 27 to pursue a life as an influencer. In your front-page story, you include details about his sex life and his abuse of drink and drugs. Does he deserve to be rich and famous? Does he deserve so much publicity in your paper? Should you be shining a spotlight on him for his actions? Gareth Bell is a terrible role model, but you have given him the limelight — so the responsibility for his fame ultimately lies with you. This has to stop.

My belief is that fame should be given to those who contribute meaningfully to society: the inventors; the pioneers; those who overcome obstacles with dignity and grace. Instead of littering your pages with images of drunk YouTubers behaving badly on holiday, why not dedicate some of your newspaper to stories of people who represent hope? Like Paralympian Rina Leung, who not only excels in her chosen field of athletics, but has started a foundation for children with cerebral palsy? Or Sir Robert Edwards, whose pioneering scientific work has given families the greatest gift of all: new life. Fame should be reserved for this type of role model, and it’s high time your newspaper celebrated these real heroes.

I can already hear your complaints: “My readers just want some light relief from their hard lives!” “I’m only selling what people want to read!” But inspirational stories of heroes like these offer welcome hope in tough times. You have the ultimate decision over what ends up in your paper: try showing people the best of humanity, not the worst. 

Yours faithfully,

Lily Ahmed 

Why would this letter achieve top marks?

  • The answer convincingly matches the required purpose and audience:

    • It uses the correct salutation (greeting) and sign-off

    • Its tone is lively and suitable for a letter to a newspaper editor

  • Sustained crafting:

    • It is very clearly planned, its structure is easy to follow yet sophisticated

    • The introduction puts across the writer’s point of view clearly

    • The argument is also balanced, introducing a counter-argument, but this is well challenged

    • Sentences are varied throughout for effect

  • A wide range of ambitious vocabulary and punctuation is used throughout:

    • These choices are accurately used and always add meaning or impact

  • A range of linguistic devices are confidently used for effect:

Writing a GCSE English Language letter

For top marks, you’ll need to carefully consider: 

  • The tone:

    • The sound of the writer’s “voice”

  • The register:

    • The vocabulary and phrasing

  • The style of the writing:

    • The sentence structure and overall structure

All of these should be appropriate for the form, audience and purpose of the piece of writing. For example, your register would need to be more formal for a letter written to an MP than an article in a travel magazine.

Breaking down the task

To work about what to include and how to write your answer, first perform a GAP analysis (what/who/why):

Genre (what)

A letter to the editor of a newspaper

Audience (who)

Newspaper readers (adults) interested in debate/points of view

Purpose (why)

To argue your point of view

  • This task asks you to write a formal letter as it is to the editor of a newspaper:

    • Letters will be formal if they are to people you do not know well

    • This means the register will be sophisticated

  • As the task asks you to argue your point of view, you will need to sound convincing:

    • It will be necessary to use persuasive techniques

    • However, ensure you maintain a calm and controlled tone and a balanced argument

Expected features of a letter

These are the basic features of a letter the examiner would expect to see:

  • A date

  • An appropriate mode of address or greeting:

    • An informal letter will name the recipient, e.g., “Dear Joe,”

    • A formal letter will address the recipient using the surname or appropriate address, e.g., “Dear Sir/Madam,” or “Dear Mr Jones,”

  • An appropriate mode of signing off:

    • Yours sincerely (for someone you know the name of)

    • Yours faithfully (for “Dear Sir/Madam” or “Dear Editor”; someone you don’t know the name of)

You may wish to write addresses, but this is definitely optional because it can waste time. For more on the expected features of a letter, check out our page on how to write a letter for GCSE.

Examiner Tips and Tricks

For top marks, you should be aiming to write a piece of non-fiction that is convincing.

This means your writing should feel natural and confident. So avoid beginning with “I’m writing this because”: just get straight to the point. And If you are writing to a friend or family member, you can use personal references, because this is what someone would do in real life.

Structuring your letter

Planning your GCSE letter

Once you are sure of the form you should write in, and you have considered your audience and the tone you wish to adopt in your writing, you should 10 minutes planning the content (and the order of your content) of your response:

  • Mind-map or write a list of points and techniques to use:

    • It can also be helpful to number your ideas to structure your answer in a specific order

    • You can use the ideas you read in the texts in Section A, as well as your own experiences

    • Try to include what persuasive techniques you will use for each point of your argument

  • Your letter should be structured into 5–6 paragraphs:

    • Each paragraph does not have to be the same length

    • Better answers vary the lengths of their paragraphs for effect

    • Develop separate ideas or points in each paragraph

Examiner Tips and Tricks

It is up to you whether you choose to argue for or against the statement, as long as you plan your argument, develop it thoroughly and sustain it throughout. 

The examiner is not grading you on how much you know about the given topic, as it is impossible to predict what subject matter will be on the paper. You are marked on your ability to construct a convincing argument, so feel free to make up facts and anecdotes as long as they sound realistic.

GCSE English Language letter layout

This letter template includes:

  • The date

  • A greeting

  • A sign-off:

    • This letter is signed off using the appropriate sign-off for a letter to someone you don’t know the name of

    • If you choose to start the letter with “Dear Mr Peters,” for example, you should sign off with “Yours sincerely,” 

4 June 2019


Dear Editor,

Introduction

Main arguments

Concluding paragraph

Yours faithfully,


Kathryn Thornley 

Step-by-step guide to structuring your letter

  1. Directly address the reader:

    1. Introduce your argument — what you are writing about, why you are writing and what your opinion is

    2. Consider your use of pronouns, e.g., “you” or “we” 

  2. Offer a fact or some research to support your opinion:

    1. This will gain you credibility and prove you are knowledgeable about the topic

    2. These can be made up, but make sure they are plausible

  3. Engage the reader on a personal level using a counter-argument:

    1. This suggests you understand your reader and have already considered their concerns

  4. Provide an anecdote to offer an example which proves your argument:

    1. This builds rapport with your reader by engaging with them on a personal leve

  5. Offer more research or studies in the form of:

    1. Statistics

    2. A witness statement

    3. A poll

    4. A quote from an expert

  6. End your letter with an emotive plea or solution to the issue:

    1. Use emotive language to engage your reader

    2. Ending your letter on a single sentence, perhaps using a triplet, is an effective conclusion

  7. Sign off your letter in the correct way

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Always write with your intended audience in mind

Address them directly throughout your writing, mention their specific concerns and ensure you develop your points in a way which would convince your specific reader. 

Putting your letter ideas into a paragraph

Let’s look at how you might turn your ideas into paragraphs that hit the highest levels of the mark scheme for both assessment objectives (AOs) for this question. 

The AOs are:

Name

Description

AO5

Content and communication

Writing in a clear, creative and engaging way:

  • Choosing the right tone and style for the type of writing, your purpose, and who you're writing for

  • Organising your ideas so your writing flows smoothly and your ideas link together clearly

AO6

Technical accuracy

Writing accurately:

  • Ensuring your spelling, punctuation and grammar is correct

  • Using a variety of vocabulary to make your writing clear and interesting

  • Using different sentence types to suit your purpose and create effect

The following is reflective of a full-mark answer for both AO5 and AO6. Below it, we’ve included an explanation of the types of things you need to include to reach this mark:

Worked Example

Why can you not publish articles about the triumphs of our local heroes? They are the real

celebrities in my eyes; not some drug-riddled, entitled and idle pop star who’s had far too much lip filler.

You are taking advantage of people who believe that they have got a chance at “stardom” by replicating the lifestyle of their favourite celebrity. It is quite simply scandalous. I saw a recent survey that stated 42% of teenagers aged 13-17 said that they would forgo a place at university in favour of going on Love Island

Lastly, here is a case study for you. I recently witnessed a lady collapsing in the road. A doctor who happened to be passing by ran over, and began to assist her immediately. But guess what? Despite his bravery, determination and skill, he’s nameless and faceless in our current society.

Point from the mark scheme

Method used and why it’s effective

Creative and engaging ideas (AO5)

A triple of negative ideas placed together (“drug-riddled, entitled and idle”) establishes a strong viewpoint from the outset

Matched to purpose (AO5)

The initial rhetorical question directly engages the reader with a challenge

A personal anecdote creates a personal connection, and seeks to engage the reader emotionally

Organisation of ideas (AO5)

Discourse markers (“Lastly”) develop the argument fluently and cohesively 

Ambitious vocabulary (AO6)

Use of formal vocabulary such as “assist” rather than “help”, and “witnessed” rather than “saw” adds authority and credibility

Sentences and punctuation for effect (AO6)

A short sentence (“It is quite simply scandalous”) next to a longer sentence draws attention to it and adds dramatic impact by changing tone

Learn more and test yourself

For more great tips and tricks, check out our dedicated revision notes on how to write a letter for GCSE and our student-friendly Paper 2 Question 5 mark scheme.

You can also test yourself on Paper 2 Question 5 by building your writing skills with our Paper 2 Question 5 multiple-choice questions and by writing your own letter and getting it marked by Smart Mark, our AI model created by English Language experts.

You've read 0 of your 5 free revision notes this week

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Did this page help you?

Sam Evans

Author: Sam Evans

Expertise: English Content Creator

Sam is a graduate in English Language and Literature, specialising in journalism and the history and varieties of English. Before teaching, Sam had a career in tourism in South Africa and Europe. After training to become a teacher, Sam taught English Language and Literature and Communication and Culture in three outstanding secondary schools across England. Her teaching experience began in nursery schools, where she achieved a qualification in Early Years Foundation education. Sam went on to train in the SEN department of a secondary school, working closely with visually impaired students. From there, she went on to manage KS3 and GCSE English language and literature, as well as leading the Sixth Form curriculum. During this time, Sam trained as an examiner in AQA and iGCSE and has marked GCSE English examinations across a range of specifications. She went on to tutor Business English, English as a Second Language and international GCSE English to students around the world, as well as tutoring A level, GCSE and KS3 students for educational provisions in England. Sam freelances as a ghostwriter on novels, business articles and reports, academic resources and non-fiction books.

Kate Lee

Reviewer: Kate Lee

Expertise: English Content Creator

Kate has over 12 years of teaching experience as a Head of English and as a private tutor. Having also worked at the exam board AQA and in educational publishing, she's been writing educational resources to support learners in their exams throughout her career. She's passionate about helping students achieve their potential by developing their literacy and exam skills.

Download notes on Paper 2 Question 5: Letter Model Answer