How to Answer an 8-Mark "Analyse" Question (Edexcel IGCSE Geography): Revision Note

Exam code: 4GE1

Bridgette Barrett

Written by: Bridgette Barrett

Reviewed by: Jenna Quinn

Updated on

What is an 8-mark "analyse" question?

  • The 8-mark "analyse" question, often called an 8-marker, gives you a figure and asks you to break an issue into parts and explain how they connect

  • It is the last part of each Section A question on Paper 1 and Paper 2, so you answer two on each paper

    • On Paper 1, they are worth 16 of the 70 marks (23%)

    • On Paper 2, they are worth 16 of the 105 marks (15%)

  • You have about 8 minutes, with a figure from the Resource Booklet and your own understanding to use

  • Section B also has an 8-mark question, but it is about fieldwork and uses the command word "evaluate", so it is covered in How to Answer Fieldwork Questions

The question at a glance

Feature

Detail

Marks

8

Where it appears

Paper 1 and Paper 2, Section A, last part of each question

Suggested time

about 8 minutes, including planning

Suggested length

about 160–180 words

Assessment objective 3

4 marks

Assessment objective 4

4 marks

Command word and assessment objectives

  • The command word is "analyse", which Pearson defines as investigating an issue by breaking it into individual components and making logical, evidence-based connections about the causes and effects, or the links, between them

  • Past paper questions include:

  • Recent papers add "You must refer to the resource in your answer."

  • The question tests two assessment objectives (AOs), with 4 marks each:

    • AO3: what you do with your understanding, meaning interpreting information, making connections and reaching judgements

    • AO4: how you use the figure, meaning taking accurate information from it to support your argument

  • These are not case study questions, so the marks come from using the figure and your understanding, not from detailed examples you have learnt

How is an 8-mark question marked?

  • This is a levelled response question, so each point you make doesn't automatically earn a mark

  • The examiner reads your whole answer and decides which level it best fits, then places it within that level's mark range

  • Each level describes both AOs, so an answer that only describes the figure, or ignores it, is usually held in the lower levels

  • You can reach Level 3 without a perfect answer, so focus on linking each piece of evidence to a reason

The three levels

Level 3 (7–8 marks)

  • Logical connections between ideas throughout (AO3)

  • A balanced, well-developed argument that brings your understanding together clearly (AO3)

  • Judgements supported by evidence throughout (AO3)

  • Accurate information from the figure that supports every part of your argument (AO4)

Level 2 (4–6 marks)

  • Some logical connections between ideas (AO3)

  • An imbalanced argument that brings together mostly relevant understanding, but not always clearly (AO3)

  • Judgements supported by evidence only occasionally (AO3)

  • Accurate information from the figure that supports some parts of your argument (AO4)

Level 1 (1–3 marks)

  • An attempt to apply understanding, but the understanding and connections are flawed (AO3)

  • An unbalanced or incomplete argument that brings little understanding together (AO3)

  • Judgements supported by limited evidence (AO3)

  • Information from the figure with limited relevance or accuracy, which supports few parts of your argument (AO4)

What separates Level 2 from Level 3?

  • Level 2 answers often describe the figure first and explain it afterwards, so the evidence and the reasons sit apart

  • Level 3 answers link each piece of evidence to a reason, connect the reasons to each other and judge which matters most

  • You don't need a final concluding paragraph for an "analyse" question, as long as your judgements run through the answer

How to answer an 8-mark question

Step 1

  • Read the question carefully and highlight the command word

Analyse the importance of this dam for managing the demand and supply of water.

  • "Analyse the importance" means that you need to break the dam's effects into separate parts, explain each one and decide how important the dam is overall

Step 2

  • Highlight the key words, and study the figure before you write

Analyse the importance of this dam for managing the demand and supply of water.

  • In this example, your answer must:

    • use the figure, with values, to show what the dam does

    • explain how it affects both demand and supply, not just describe the dam

    • decide how important it is, and for whom

Step 3

  • Spend about 1 minute writing a short plan

  • An 8-marker structure for this question could be:

    • supply: the reservoirs store 74 billion cubic metres, so release can be controlled

    • demand: hydroelectric power for Ethiopia

    • downstream supply: 95% of the water consumed in Egypt comes from the Nile

    • judgement: the dam's importance depends on an agreement to share water

Step 4

  • In each paragraph, use the figure and then explain what it shows:

    • Figure only: "The reservoirs hold 74 billion cubic metres of water"

    • Figure and analysis: "The reservoirs hold 74 billion cubic metres of water, so Ethiopia can control how much is released and keep supply steady when rainfall is seasonal"

  • Make your judgement as you go, such as which reason matters most, rather than leaving it to the end

What if?

  • The figure shows a place you haven't studied: use what the figure shows and your understanding of the processes, because that is where the marks are

  • The figure seems to show only one reason: look for a value that doesn't fit, because explaining it gives your answer balance

Worked Example

Study Figure 1c.

Analyse the importance of this dam for managing the demand and supply of water.

[8 marks]

Map and fact box. The Grand Renaissance Dam is on the Blue Nile in Ethiopia, upstream of Khartoum and the Aswan Dam. It cost an estimated US$5 billion, is Africa's largest hydroelectric power project and creates reservoirs holding 74 billion cubic metres of water. 95% of water consumed in Egypt is from the Nile, and Egypt wants an agreement for water to be added from the reservoirs in a drought

Model answer:

Figure 1c shows that the Grand Renaissance Dam is on the Blue Nile in Ethiopia, upstream of Sudan and Egypt, and that its reservoirs hold 74 billion cubic metres of water. [S] Storing this much water lets Ethiopia control how much is released, so supply can stay steady even when rainfall is seasonal. [Ap]

The dam is also Africa's largest hydroelectric power project. [S] This makes it important for meeting Ethiopia's growing demand for electricity from homes and industry, so its value goes beyond water supply alone. [Ap]

However, 95% of the water consumed in Egypt comes from the Nile. [S] Because the Nile flows north, water held back in Ethiopia could reduce supply downstream, especially while the reservoirs fill or during a drought. [Ap]

Egypt wants an agreement for water to be added to the Nile from the reservoirs during droughts. [S] This suggests the dam is most important for managing supply when the water is shared by agreement, because without one it could increase water insecurity downstream. [Ap]

[8 marks]

Mark allocation

This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark.

  • [Ap] shows application through interpretation, connections and judgement (AO3, 4 marks)

  • [S] shows skills in taking accurate information from the figure (AO4, 4 marks)

Commentary

This answer reaches Level 3 because it uses the figure in every paragraph, links it to demand and supply, and judges how important the dam is:

  • Paragraph 1: uses the location and reservoir size to explain how the dam controls supply

  • Paragraph 2: adds demand, through hydroelectric power

  • Paragraph 3: shows the effect downstream, using the direction the Nile flows

  • Paragraph 4: uses Egypt's request for an agreement to reach a judgement

Common errors

Common errors that hold answers below the top level include:

  • Thinking that the Nile flows south, so that Egypt controls the water rather than Ethiopia

  • Describing the dam without linking it to the demand and supply of water

  • Copying the figure's information without explaining it

  • Writing only about Egypt, or only about Ethiopia

  • Listing effects without deciding how important the dam is

Alternative content

The answer above is just one example of a response to this question. Other information that could be used in the answer includes:

  • How controlled releases could reduce flooding downstream, or cause problems if a large release reaches smaller dams and rivers in Sudan

  • How the reservoir could reduce water insecurity in Ethiopia, where rainfall is seasonal

  • Why control of a river that crosses international borders can lead to disagreement over who manages the supply

  • How the cost of US$5 billion compares with the benefits of hydroelectric power

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Quote values with their units every time you use the figure, such as "74 billion cubic metres" or "95%". Precise values show that you have taken accurate information from the figure.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Bridgette Barrett

Author: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.

Jenna Quinn

Reviewer: Jenna Quinn

Expertise: Content Creator

Jenna studied at Cardiff University before training to become a science teacher at the University of Bath specialising in Biology (although she loves teaching all three sciences at GCSE level!). Teaching is her passion, and with 10 years experience teaching across a wide range of specifications – from GCSE and A Level Biology in the UK to IGCSE and IB Biology internationally – she knows what is required to pass those Biology exams.