How to Answer a 12-Mark Question (Edexcel IGCSE Geography): Revision Note
Exam code: 4GE1
What is a 12-mark "discuss the view" question?
The 12-mark question, often called a 12-marker, gives you a view and asks you to decide how far you agree with it
It is the last part of your Section C question on Paper 2, so you answer one
It is worth 12 of the 105 marks on Paper 2 (11%), more than any other part of a question
You have about 12 minutes, with two figures from the Resource Booklet and your own knowledge to use
The question at a glance
Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
Marks | 12 |
Where it appears | Paper 2, Section C, last part of Question 7, 8 or 9 |
Suggested time | about 12 minutes, including planning |
Suggested length | about 240–260 words |
Assessment objective 2 | 4 marks |
Assessment objective 3 | 4 marks |
Assessment objective 4 | 4 marks |
Command word and assessment objectives
The command word is "discuss", which Pearson defines as exploring the strengths and weaknesses of different sides of an issue, and investigating it by reasoning or argument
Every 12-mark question starts "Discuss the view:", followed by a statement in quotation marks
Past paper questions include:
Discuss the view: “The greatest impacts of climate change will be linked to sea level rise.” (Paper 2, June 2025)
Discuss the view: “Transnational corporations (TNCs) are one of the most important factors for the growth of the global economy.” (Paper 2, June 2025)
Discuss the view: “Efforts to reduce the development gap should always focus on economic improvements.” (Paper 2, June 2025)
Discuss the view: “Deforestation is the greatest threat to fragile environments.” (Paper 2, June 2024)
The question names two figures and tells you to use them with your own knowledge and understanding
Recent papers add "You must refer to the resources in your answer."
The question tests three assessment objectives (AOs), with 4 marks each:
AO2: what you understand, meaning geographical ideas and how places, environments and processes link together
AO3: what you do with it, meaning interpreting information, making connections and reaching judgements
AO4: how you use the figures, meaning taking accurate information from them to support your argument
How is a 12-mark question marked?
This is a levelled response question, so each point you make doesn't automatically earn a mark
The examiner reads your whole answer and decides which level it best fits, then places it within that level's mark range
Each level describes all three AOs, so an answer that relies on one of them, such as only describing the figures, is usually held in the lower levels
You don't need to cover everything in the figures: a few well-developed points and a clear judgement can reach Level 3
The three levels
Level 3 (9–12 marks)
Accurate understanding of geographical ideas and of how places, environments and processes link (AO2)
Logical connections between ideas throughout (AO3)
A balanced, well-developed argument that brings your understanding together clearly (AO3)
Judgements supported by evidence throughout (AO3)
Accurate information from the figures that supports every part of your argument (AO4)
Level 2 (5–8 marks)
Some understanding of geographical ideas and of how places, environments and processes link (AO2)
Some logical connections between ideas (AO3)
An imbalanced argument that brings together mostly relevant understanding, but not always clearly (AO3)
Judgements supported by evidence only occasionally (AO3)
Accurate information from the figures that supports some parts of your argument (AO4)
Level 1 (1–4 marks)
Isolated pieces of understanding of geographical ideas and links (AO2)
An attempt to apply understanding, but the understanding and connections are flawed (AO3)
An unbalanced or incomplete argument that brings little understanding together (AO3)
Judgements supported by limited evidence (AO3)
Information from the figures with limited relevance or accuracy, which supports few parts of your argument (AO4)
What separates Level 2 from Level 3?
Level 2 answers use the figures and their own knowledge, but often one at a time, and develop one side of the argument more than the other
Level 3 answers blend evidence from both figures with their own understanding, and judge the view as they go
You don't need a separate concluding paragraph, but your judgement must be clear, and a short summary at the end is often the easiest way to show it
Strong answers sometimes lose marks by not explaining the geography behind the figures
This is the AO2 strand, so add your own understanding to each point
How to answer a 12 mark question
Step 1
Read the question carefully and highlight the command word
Discuss the view: "International migration brings more benefits than costs to the countries that migrants leave."
"Discuss the view" means that you need to look at both sides of the statement and decide how far you agree
Step 2
Highlight the key words in the view and the instruction
Discuss the view: "International migration brings more benefits than costs to the countries that migrants leave."
Use Figures 1 and 2 and your own knowledge and understanding to support your answer.
In this example, your answer must:
weigh benefits against costs, not just list them
focus on the countries migrants leave, not the countries they move to
use information from both figures
add your own understanding, such as why remittances matter more to some countries than others
Step 3
Spend about 2 minutes writing a short plan
Decide your judgement first, so that each paragraph can support it
A 12-marker structure for this question could be:
opening: your judgement in one sentence
benefits: remittances, using Figure 1
limit: benefits are uneven between countries, using Figure 1
costs: loss of skilled workers and rural change, using Figure 2
closing judgement: how far you agree, and for whom
Step 4
In each paragraph, use the figure and then explain what it means for the view:
Figure only: "Figure 1 shows that remittances were 47.2% of Tajikistan's GDP in 2024"
Figure and understanding: "Remittances were 47.2% of Tajikistan's GDP in 2024, so the money migrants send home is a major part of the country's income"
End with one or two sentences that make your judgement clear, without adding new evidence
What if?
Both figures seem to support only one side: use your own knowledge for the other side, because that also earns AO2 credit
You're running out of time: write one sentence that gives your judgement and the main reason for it, rather than leaving the 12-marker blank
Worked Example
Discuss the view: "International migration brings more benefits than costs to the countries that migrants leave."
Use Figures 1 and 2 and your own knowledge and understanding to support your answer.
You must refer to the resources in your answer.
Figure 1
Remittances received by selected countries, 2024
Country | Remittances received (US$ billion) | Remittances as a share of GDP (%) |
|---|---|---|
Tajikistan | 6.8 | 47.2 |
Nepal | 11.3 | 26.0 |
Honduras | 9.5 | 25.7 |
Philippines | 40.3 | 8.7 |
Bangladesh | 27.5 | 6.1 |
India | 137.7 | 3.7 |
Source: World Bank
Figure 2
Some effects of emigration on the countries that migrants leave
Money sent home by migrants pays for food, school fees and housing
Skilled workers, such as nurses and engineers, leave to work abroad
Unemployment falls as some people of working age leave
Rural areas lose young adults, leaving older people to farm the land
Families are separated, sometimes for many years
Returning migrants bring new skills and savings
[12 marks]
Model answer:
This view is only partly true, because the benefits of emigration go mainly to families, while many of the costs fall on the wider country. [Ap]
Remittances were 47.2% of Tajikistan's GDP in 2024 and about a quarter of GDP in Nepal and Honduras. [S] Remittances matter most where wages at home are low and there are few formal jobs, so many families depend on income earned abroad. [U] For these countries, remittances are a major part of national income, which supports spending on basic needs. [Ap]
However, India received the most money, US$137.7 billion, yet this was only 3.7% of its GDP. [S] Large economies earn most of their income from industry and services, so money from abroad adds relatively little. [U] The benefits of emigration are therefore uneven between countries. [Ap]
The costs can be serious. Figure 2 shows that skilled workers such as nurses leave, so health services at home can be left short of trained staff. [S] When young adults leave rural areas, fewer people are left to farm, which can reduce food production and leave older people without support. [U] Depending on remittances creates a further risk, because many migrants from Tajikistan work in Russia, so an economic downturn there reduces the money sent home. [Ap]
Overall, emigration brings more benefits than costs where remittances are a large share of GDP, as in Tajikistan and Nepal. [Ap] Even there, the money goes mainly to migrants' families, while public services and rural communities bear the costs. [Ap] Emigration therefore helps households more than the country as a whole. [Ap]
[12 marks]
Mark allocation
This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark.
[U] shows understanding of geographical ideas and links (AO2, 4 marks)
[Ap] shows application through interpretation, connections and judgement (AO3, 4 marks)
[S] shows skills in taking accurate information from the figures (AO4, 4 marks)
Commentary
This answer reaches Level 3 because it uses both figures, adds its own understanding and judges the view throughout:
Paragraph 1: gives a clear judgement straight away
Paragraph 2: uses Figure 1 data and explains why remittances matter so much to some countries
Paragraph 3: uses Figure 1 again, and explains why the benefits are uneven
Paragraph 4: uses Figure 2 and develops the costs with its own understanding
Paragraph 5: returns to the view and decides how far it is true, and for whom
Common errors
Common errors that hold answers below the top level include:
Writing about the countries migrants move to, rather than the ones they leave
Mentioning a figure without using any information from it
Using only one of the two figures
Listing benefits and costs without deciding how far you agree
Alternative content
The answer above is just one example of a response to this question. Other information that could be used in the answer includes:
New skills and savings brought back by returning migrants
Ideas and contacts that migrants pass back to their home communities
Ageing populations and labour shortages in places with high emigration
How the costs and benefits differ for forced and voluntary migrants
Examiner Tips and Tricks
Look for an extreme word in the view, such as "greatest", "always" or "most important". Showing where the view doesn't hold is often the quickest way to make your argument balanced.
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?