How to Answer Fieldwork Questions (Edexcel IGCSE Geography): Revision Note

Exam code: 4GE1

Bridgette Barrett

Written by: Bridgette Barrett

Reviewed by: Alistair Marjot

Updated on

What are Section B fieldwork questions?

  • Section B of each paper tests the geographical enquiries you carried out during the course

  • You answer one question from three, choosing the one that matches your own enquiry:

    • Paper 1: river environments, coastal environments or hazardous environments

    • Paper 2: economic activity and energy, rural environments or urban environments

  • Each question is worth 20 marks, which is 29% of Paper 1 and 19% of Paper 2

  • You have about 20 minutes for each question

  • If you know your own enquiries well, you have already prepared for most of the marks in this section

The question at a glance

Feature

Detail

Marks

20 on each paper

Where it appears

Paper 1 and Paper 2, Section B, Question 4, 5 or 6

Question types

about 12 marks of short parts, then one 8-mark "evaluate" question

Suggested time

about 20 minutes

Assessment objectives

AO3 and AO4

Familiar and unfamiliar contexts

  • Every Section B question uses two kinds of context:

    • Familiar: questions about your own enquiry, with a box for its title

    • Unfamiliar: questions about another student's enquiry, using figures in the Resource Booklet

  • Either the short parts or the 8-mark question can be about your own enquiry, so prepare for both

  • The title box earns no marks, but it shows the examiner which enquiry you are writing about

  • Questions can cover any stage of an enquiry, from the hypothesis and sampling to presentation, conclusions and evaluation

  • If you answer about the wrong enquiry, such as a coastal enquiry in the river question, only general points can gain credit

How to answer short fieldwork questions

  • Short parts are worth 1 to 4 marks and use command words such as "identify", "describe", "explain", "suggest" and "calculate"

  • They are point-marked, so each mark comes from a separate idea or development

    • 1 mark: a short, correct answer is enough

    • 2 marks: an idea plus a development, such as a reason or an example

    • 3 marks: one idea developed twice

    • 4 marks: usually two ideas, each developed once

  • Answers about your own enquiry need specific detail, such as the equipment, sites and values you used

  • For calculations, show your working, because a method mark can still be given if the final answer is wrong

  • When you describe a sampling strategy, say how you carried it out, not why it is good

  • To explain why a presentation method suits the data, link it to the type of data, not just "easy to read

  • Keep collection methods, presentation techniques and analysis separate: they are different stages of the enquiry

  • Make an advantage and a disadvantage two different ideas, not the same idea reversed

Worked Example

A group of students investigated how the number of pedestrians changes with distance from the central business district (CBD) of a town. They counted pedestrians for 10 minutes at five sites, every 200 m along a straight line from the CBD.

Figure 1

Pedestrian counts along a transect from the CBD

Site

Distance from the CBD (m)

Pedestrians counted in 10 minutes

1

0

142

2

200

96

3

400

61

4

600

38

5

800

17

(a) Calculate the range of the pedestrian counts. You must show your working.

[2]

(b) Suggest one reason why the students chose sites every 200 m.

[2]

(c) Suggest one way the students could make their results more reliable.

[3]

[7 marks]

Answer:

(a)

142 − 17 = 125 [2]

(b)

Equal spacing covers the whole route evenly [1], so the change from the CBD outwards is shown fairly [1].

(c)

Repeat the counts at different times of day [1], because one count may be affected by a single event [1], so an average would represent each site better [1].

Mark allocation

These are point-marked questions. Each [1] shows where a mark is earned. Every sentence in these answers earns a mark, which is why they are shorter than the suggested length

  • Part (a): a correct answer earns 2 marks, and if the answer is wrong, a correct method can still earn 1 mark, AO4

  • Part (b): the idea earns 1 mark and its development earns the second, AO3

  • Part (c): one idea is developed twice, so it earns 3 marks, AO3

How to answer an 8-mark "evaluate" question

What is it?

  • The 8-mark question at the end of Section B asks you to evaluate part of an enquiry, such as its methods, data, presentation or conclusions

  • The command word is "evaluate", which Pearson defines as measuring the value or success of something and ultimately giving a substantiated judgement or conclusion

  • Past paper questions include:

    • “Evaluate how suitable the hypothesis reached by the students is in helping to answer their enquiry question.” (Paper 1, June 2025)

    • “Evaluate the importance of qualitative data in helping you reach your conclusions.” (Paper 2, June 2025)

    • “Evaluate the student’s data presentation method and conclusions.” (Paper 2, November 2024)

    • “Evaluate the accuracy and reliability of your data collection techniques.” (Paper 1, June 2024)

How is the 8-mark "evaluate" question marked?

  • It is marked in three levels, with 4 marks for AO3 and 4 marks for AO4

  • The AO3 strand is the same as for the 8-mark "analyse" question, but on Paper 2 the AO4 strand rewards using geographical skills across the enquiry process and communicating findings with clear geographical terminology

Level 3 (7–8 marks)

  • Logical connections throughout, a balanced, well-developed argument that brings your understanding together clearly, and judgements supported by evidence throughout (AO3), with accurate information that supports every part of the argument (AO4)

  • On Paper 2: skills support all stages of the enquiry, and you communicate enquiry-specific findings clearly, using geographical terminology consistently (AO4)

Level 2 (4–6 marks)

  • Some logical connections, an imbalanced argument that brings together mostly relevant understanding but not always clearly, and judgements supported by evidence only occasionally (AO3), with accurate information that supports some parts of the argument (AO4)

  • On Paper 2: skills support some stages of the enquiry, and you communicate findings with some clarity, using geographical terminology occasionally (AO4)

Level 1 (1–3 marks)

  • Flawed understanding and connections, an unbalanced or incomplete argument that brings little understanding together, and judgements supported by limited evidence (AO3), with information of limited relevance or accuracy (AO4)

  • On Paper 2: skills support few stages of the enquiry, findings are generic and you use little geographical terminology (AO4)

How much should I write?

  • Aim for about 160–180 words in about 8 minutes

How to write the 8-mark "evaluate" answer

Step 1

  • Highlight the command word and the stage of the enquiry it asks about, such as "secondary data" or "conclusions"

Step 2

  • If the question is about your own enquiry, use real detail from it: your sites, equipment and results

  • If it uses figures, take specific information from them, rather than copying them

Step 3

  • Write about strengths and weaknesses, and link each one to whether it helped you answer the enquiry question

Step 4

  • Always end with a clear judgement, because "evaluate" needs a conclusion to reach the top level

    • Weak ending: "There were strengths and weaknesses"

    • Strong ending: "Overall, my secondary data helped me explain my results, but my conclusions depended on my primary data"

What if?

  • The figures show an enquiry unlike yours: evaluate what the figures show, using what you know about good fieldwork

Worked Example

You have carried out a geographical enquiry as part of your work on river environments.

Evaluate how useful your secondary data was in helping you reach your conclusions.

[8 marks]

Model answer:

My secondary data was useful for planning and explaining, but my conclusions depended mainly on my primary data. [Ap]

I used a topographic map to choose five sites at equal distances along the river. [S] This was useful because it spread my sites evenly from upstream to downstream, so my results could show the whole pattern of change. [Ap]

I also used rainfall data from a local weather station. [S] It showed that there was heavy rain two days before our visit, which explained why the river was deeper than expected at every site. [Ap]

However, the weather station was several kilometres from the river, so it may not have shown rainfall in the drainage basin accurately. [Ap] My main conclusion, that the river channel gets wider downstream, came from my own measurements, as width rose from 2.1 m to 6.8 m. [S]

Overall, my secondary data was useful for supporting and explaining my conclusions, but it could not replace the primary data that they were based on. [Ap]

[8 marks]

Mark allocation

This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark.

  • [Ap] shows application through interpretation, connections and judgement (AO3, 4 marks)

  • [S] shows skills in using the enquiry's methods and data (AO4, 4 marks)

Commentary

This answer reaches Level 3 because it weighs specific strengths and weaknesses and ends with a substantiated judgement:

  • Paragraph 1: gives a judgement straight away

  • Paragraphs 2 and 3: name each secondary source and say how it helped

  • Paragraph 4: gives a weakness, and shows where the conclusions really came from

  • Paragraph 5: ends with a clear judgement that answers the question

Common errors

Common errors that hold answers below the top level include:

  • Describing what was done without judging how useful it was

  • Copying information from a figure without saying what it means for the enquiry

Alternative content

The answer above is just one example of a response to this question. Other information that could be used in the answer includes:

  • Photographs or satellite images used to compare sites

  • Published river data used to check the reliability of results

  • Ways the secondary data could have been improved

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Before the exam, write one strength and one weakness for each stage of your own enquiries, with a real value or detail for each. Whatever stage the 8-mark question picks, you will have specific evidence ready.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Bridgette Barrett

Author: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.

Alistair Marjot

Reviewer: Alistair Marjot

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Alistair graduated from Oxford University with a degree in Biological Sciences. He has taught GCSE/IGCSE Biology, as well as Biology and Environmental Systems & Societies for the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme. While teaching in Oxford, Alistair completed his MA Education as Head of Department for Environmental Systems & Societies. Alistair has continued to pursue his interests in ecology and environmental science, recently gaining an MSc in Wildlife Biology & Conservation with Edinburgh Napier University.