Disproof by Counter Example (DP IB Analysis & Approaches (AA)): Revision Note

Did this video help you?

Disproof by Counter Example

What is disproof by counter-example?

  • Disproving a result involves finding a value that does not work in the result

  • That value is called a counter-example

 

How do I disprove a result?

  • You only need to find one value that does not work

  • Look out for the set of numbers for which the statement is made, it will often be just integers or natural numbers

  • Numbers that have unusual results are often involved

    • It is often a good idea to try the values 0 and 1 first as they often behave in different ways to other numbers

    • The number 2 also behaves differently to other even numbers

      • It is the only even prime number

      • It is the only number that satisfies n plus n blank equals blank n to the power of n

    • If it is the set of real numbers consider how rational and irrational numbers behave differently

    • Think about how positive and negative numbers behave differently

      • Particularly when working with inequalities

1.1.4-Disproof-by-Counter-example-Notes-Diagram-1024x680

Examiner Tips and Tricks

  • Read the question carefully, looking out for the set of numbers for which you need to prove the result

Worked Example

For each of the following statements, show that they are false by giving a counterexample:

 

a) Given n element of straight integer numbers to the power of plus, if n squared is a multiple of 4, then n is also a multiple of 4.

1-4-1-ib-aa-hl-disproof-by-counter-example-we-i

b) Given x element of straight integer numbers then 3 x is always greater than 2 x.

1-4-1-ib-aa-hl-disproof-by-counter-example-we-ii

You've read 0 of your 5 free revision notes this week

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Did this page help you?

Amber

Author: Amber

Expertise: Maths Content Creator

Amber gained a first class degree in Mathematics & Meteorology from the University of Reading before training to become a teacher. She is passionate about teaching, having spent 8 years teaching GCSE and A Level Mathematics both in the UK and internationally. Amber loves creating bright and informative resources to help students reach their potential.