Making & Shaping Law (Edexcel GCSE Citizenship Studies): Revision Note

Exam code: 1CS0

Michael Mitchell

Written by: Michael Mitchell

Reviewed by: Lisa Eades

Updated on

From Bill to Act

Types of legislation

  • A bill is a proposed law that is debated in Parliament

    • If it is approved by both the House of Commons and the House of Lords and then given Royal Assent, it becomes an Act of Parliament

Types of Bill

Diagram showing types of bills. Central red circle labelled "Types of Bill" connected to four yellow ovals: Private Members’ Bills, Public Bills, Private Bills, and Hybrid Bills.

Type of Bill

Explanation

Public Bills

  • The most common type of Bill, proposed by the government

  • They apply to the whole country and deal with major national issues

  • These bills take up most of Parliament’s time because the government controls the timetable

  • Examples of Public Bills include

    • Budget and Finance Bills, which set out tax and public spending plans

    • Laws on areas such as education, health, crime or immigration

Private Members’ Bills

  • Introduced by MPs or members of the House of Lords who are not government ministers

  • They allow individual parliamentarians to raise issues that matter to them or their constituents

  • They are important because they can raise awareness and influence future government legislation

  • Very few become law because:

    • There is limited parliamentary time set aside for them

    • The government may oppose them

  • Some Private Members’ Bills have been successful

    • For example, the Smoking Ban in public places began as a Private Members’ Bill

Private Bills

  • Sponsored and paid for by outside organisations

  • They apply to specific individuals, companies or local areas, rather than the whole country

  • Common sponsors include:

    • Local councils

    • Transport authorities

    • Harbour boards

  • A recent real example is the City of London (Various Powers) Act 2023

    • This law was requested and paid for by the City of London Corporation

    • It only applies to the City of London, not the whole country

    • It gives the local council extra powers over things like traffic and street trading

Hybrid Bills

  • Combine features of Public Bills and Private Bills

  • They affect the general public but also have a direct impact on specific groups or areas and go through extra scrutiny

  • A recent example is the Holocaust Memorial Bill

    • It is a government bill but affects a specific site and local community

  • Other examples include bills related to major infrastructure projects, such as high-speed rail

Examiner Tips and Tricks

  • A common mistake is saying all bills are proposed by the government

    • Remember: Public Bills = government, Private Members’ Bills = backbench MPs or Lords, Private Bills = organisations

  • In exam answers, name the bill type before explaining it to show clear understanding and secure method marks early

  • The legislative process in the UK can begin in either the House of Commons or the House of Lords

  • Most important government bills start in the House of Commons because it is the elected chamber

Legislative stages

Stage

Explanation

First Reading

  • The First Reading is the formal introduction of a new bill to Parliament where its title is read out

  • There is no debate or vote, and the bill is printed in full so MPs or Lords can study it

Second Reading

  • The Second Reading is the first major debate on the bill

  • Members discuss the main ideas and purpose of the proposed law and then vote on whether the bill should continue or be rejected

Committee Stage

  • During the Committee Stage, a smaller group of MPs called a Public Bill Committee examines the bill in detail line by line

  • The Committee proposes amendments and votes on changes

Report Stage

  • At the Report Stage, the whole House considers the bill again

  • They discuss the committee’s amendments, and can suggest and vote on further changes

Third Reading

  • The Third Reading is the final debate in the House where the bill started

  • It is focused on the final version of the bill, followed by a final vote on whether it should move to the other House

Consideration by the other House

  • Once approved by one House, the bill goes to the other House where it passes through the same stages

  • Any changes must be agreed by both Houses, with disagreements sometimes leading to parliamentary ping-pong

Royal assent

  • Royal Assent is the final stage of the law-making process in the UK Parliament

    • It happens after a bill has been debated and approved by both the House of Commons and the House of Lords

  • Royal Assent involves the monarch formally agreeing to the Bill

    • This agreement is given on the advice of the government, not as a personal decision by the monarch

Elderly man in a suit and tie signing a document at a table, wearing a gold watch and a purple flower pinned to his lapel.
King Charles grants Royal assent to a government Bill
  • Once Royal Assent is granted, the bill officially becomes an Act of Parliament

    • The law can then come into force, either immediately or on a specified future date

  • Royal Assent is largely a formality

    • No bill has been refused Royal Assent in modern times, as Parliament is sovereign

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Michael Mitchell

Author: Michael Mitchell

Expertise: Content Writer

Michael Mitchell is a pioneer of Citizenship education and a former Chief Examiner and Chief Moderator across all qualification levels. Michael's aim is to enable students to participate and become active citizens and not just passive members of society. He designed national specifications and, later, trained the next generation of teachers as the PGCE Subject Leader at the University of Plymouth, where he also ran a national Master's-level CPD program.

Lisa Eades

Reviewer: Lisa Eades

Expertise: Business Content Creator

Lisa has taught A Level, GCSE, BTEC and IBDP Business for over 20 years and is a senior Examiner for Edexcel. Lisa has been a successful Head of Department in Kent and has offered private Business tuition to students across the UK. Lisa loves to create imaginative and accessible resources which engage learners and build their passion for the subject.