Cross Elasticity of Demand (XED) (Cambridge (CIE) A Level Economics): Revision Note
Exam code: 9708
Defining and calculating XED
Changes in the prices of complementary goods and substitutes affect the demand for related products
Cross price elasticity of demand (XED) reveals how responsive the change in quantity demanded for good A is to a change in price of good B
The responsiveness is different for different types of products
XED can be calculated using the following formula:
Worked Example
Leading into the release of FIFA 22 Ultimate, EA Sports discounted the price of FIFA 21 from £90 to £60. A game store in Winchester saw an increase in sales of their PlayStation 5 consoles. Prior to the discount, they were selling 50 units a week, and after the discount this increased to 80 units.
Calculate the XED and explain the relationship between the two products
Step 1: Calculate the % change in QDA
Step 2: Calculate the % change in PB
Step 3: Insert the above values in the XED formula
Step 4: Explain the relationship between the two products
The negative sign indicates that these two products are complements and the high value suggests they are strong complements
Worked Example
The price of good Y, a substitute for X, rises from £50 to £60. As a result, the quantity demanded of good X rises from 2 units to 3 units per month.
What is the value of the cross elasticity of demand for good X with respect to Y?
A: +0.4
B: -0.4
C: +2.5
D:-2.5
Step 1: Calculate % change in QDA using formula
Step 2: Calculate % change in PB using formula
Step 3: Insert the above values in the XED formula
The positive sign indicates that these two products are substitutes and the high value suggests they are strong substitutes
Interpreting the XED coefficient
Economists use the concept of Cross Elasticity of Demand (XED) to measure how the demand for one product responds when the price of another changes.
The sign and size of XED reveal whether goods are substitutes, complements, or unrelated
Identifying complements, substitutes, and unrelated goods
|
|
|---|---|
XED < 0 Complementary goods |
|
XED > 0 Substitutes |
|
XED = 0 Unrelated goods |
|
Substitutes (XED is positive)
Substitute goods are alternatives that serve similar purposes. When the price of one rises, consumers tend to switch to the other, increasing its demand
A positive XED indicates this relationship
Examples:
If the price of Coca-Cola increases, demand for Pepsi may rise as a comparable alternative
A rise in the price of Spotify Premium could lead some consumers to choose Apple Music or YouTube Music instead
In a school cafeteria, if burgers become more expensive, students might opt for pizza
Examiner Tips and Tricks
Consumer behaviour assumes rational decision-making. Your personal preferences may override price sensitivity. For instance, a student who only enjoys burgers may not switch to pizza even if prices change
Complements (XED is negative)
Complementary goods are typically consumed together
When the price of one increases, demand for the other tends to fall. A negative XED reflects this joint relationship
These goods rely on each other to deliver full value, so pricing decisions in one area can directly affect demand in another
Examples:
An increase in the price of cinema tickets might reduce demand for popcorn, as fewer people attend
If mobile data plans become more expensive, usage of streaming apps may decline
A price hike on gaming consoles could lead to lower sales of video games and controllers
Unrelated goods (XED = zero)
Unrelated goods have no meaningful connection. A change in the price of one does not influence demand for the other
Examples:
A rise in the price of beef has no impact on a vegan’s demand for tofu
If football boots become more expensive, it won’t affect how many paintbrushes art students buy
An increase in the price of concert tickets will not influence demand for mathematics revision guides
Using XED in decision-making
Knowledge of XED is important to firms as they seek to maximise their revenue
It can help them adjust pricing strategies for substitute and complementary products
It can help them understand the likely impact of competitors' pricing strategies on their sales
Businesses often monitor how changes in competitors’ prices affect demand for their own products
1. Substitutes: Positive XED
When two products are substitutes, a price increase in one tends to boost demand for the other
For example, if the price of Netflix rises, more consumers might switch to Disney+ or Amazon Prime Video. In such cases, firms are highly interdependent, and a competitor’s price cut could significantly reduce their own sales
If a company discovers that its product has an XED of +1.5 with a rival’s offering, it means that a 10% drop in the competitor’s price could lead to a 15% fall in demand for its own product
The higher the XED, the stronger the substitution effect
2. Complements: Negative XED
Complementary goods are jointly demanded, so a price increase in one can reduce demand for the other
For instance, if the price of mobile phones goes up, fewer people may buy phone cases or screen protectors. Similarly, if gym memberships become more expensive, demand for fitness clothing might decline
Companies often aim to sell bundles of complementary products—like gaming consoles with exclusive games - and use XED to design pricing strategies that maximize overall revenue
Strategic pricing and consumer Behaviour
Families might spend more at theme parks when entry tickets are discounted, even if the price elasticity of the tickets themselves is low
Lower ticket prices encourage spending on snacks, souvenirs, or rides, which are products with strong complementary relationships
In such cases, firms may need to rethink pricing across their entire product range rather than focusing on one item alone
Examiner Tips and Tricks
You can evaluate XED by explaining why calculating accurate elasticity values is complex
If a drop in demand for electric scooters follows a price increase, was this due to cost or changing consumer preferences, weather conditions, or new regulations?
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?