Paper 1 Question 5: Mark Scheme (AQA GCSE English Language) : Revision Note

Sam Evans

Written by: Sam Evans

Reviewed by: Kate Lee

Updated on

  • Question 5 is the creative writing question

  • You will be asked to write either a narrative or a description

  • You will be given a picture prompt for one of these tasks

  • To get top marks, you must construct a well-crafted response appropriate to the task

The Question 5 mark scheme

For Question 5, you are assessed on two assessment objectives (AOs). These are:

Name

Description

Number of marks awarded

AO5

Content and communication

Writing in a clear, creative and engaging way:

  • Choosing the right tone and style for the type of writing, your purpose, and who you're writing for

  • Organising your ideas so your writing flows smoothly and your ideas link together clearly

24

AO6

Technical accuracy

Writing accurately:

  • Ensuring your spelling, punctuation and grammar is correct

  • Using a variety of vocabulary to make your writing clear and interesting

  • Using different sentence types to suit your purpose and create effect

16

If you want to achieve a Grade 9, you should be aiming for a Level 4 response for Question 5 for both AO5 and AO6. Below are simplified versions of both AQA mark schemes for this question.

Student-friendly mark scheme

AO5: Content and communication

Level 1

Level 2

Level 3

Level 4

Writing links to the task but ideas may be limited. Few language techniques are used

Writing shows an understanding of the form and stays on task throughout. Some language techniques are used in clear paragraphs

Writing is clear and consistent, with well-organised ideas. Tone is controlled, and language techniques are used effectively in developed paragraphs

Writing is engaging and convincing, with a thoughtfully constructed tone. Complex ideas are used clearly and confidently

AO6: Technical accuracy

Level 1

Level 2

Level 3

Level 4

Evidence of capital letters and full-stops, and generally accurate spelling of simple words

Evidence of varied sentence lengths or structures, more interesting word choices and generally accurate grammar 

Evidence of a tone of voice being constructed, with relevant vocabulary chosen for effect and mostly accurate spelling and grammar 

A consistently accurate use of a variety of sentence structures for impact, as well as a strong grasp of sophisticated vocabulary


Marks for technical accuracy are rewarded for the correct use of grammar, accurate spelling and punctuation. However, the best answers use a range of vocabulary and sentence structures in order to construct a tone of voice which is credible as well as relevant to the task

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Writing can be very subjective and the mark scheme for Question 5 reflects this. Examiners are required to start at the lowest level of the mark scheme and use it as a ladder to see whether your response meets the descriptors for that level. If your answer meets the lowest level, then the examiner will go on to the next one, and so on.

It is therefore essential to understand the mark scheme really well yourself; if you understand exactly what you are being assessed on, you understand how to improve.

How to get full marks on Paper 1 Question 5

To get the highest marks for your creative writing, it’s really important to understand what examiners are looking for.

Examiner tips for a Grade 9

  • Plan your response:

    • This is essential to reach the highest levels for AO5

    • However, you can also plan to use certain sentence types or punctuation marks throughout your answer too

  • Before you start writing, have a clear idea of:

    • The overall structure of your narrative or description: how will it begin and end?

    • Your setting

    • Your perspective

    • Your characters

    • Your intended tone

    • Any shifts in tone/perspective/setting you intend to make

  • Check your answer for mistakes:

    • Leave at least five minutes to check for spelling, punctuation and grammar errors

    • Also consider the logical flow of your writing: can you make any edits to help it flow better?

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Try to use a range of punctuation accurately. 

To create a more dynamic rhythm, include semi-colons to break down a long sentence, use short sentences for impact and use questions or exclamation marks to create a tone of voice. 

Levelling up your Question 5 answer

To get a Grade 9, you will have to reach Level 4 for both AO5 and AO6. 

Understanding the different levels: AO5

To reach Level 4 for AO5 on Question 5, your response should be “compelling and convincing” rather than just “consistent and clear”. The image below shows what an examiner would expect to see in a Level 3 versus a Level 4 response:

Venn diagram comparing Level 3 and Level 4 writing skills, highlighting clear expression and organisation for AQA GCSE English Language
Paper 1 Question 5 mark scheme (AO5)

Understanding the different levels: AO6

To reach Level 4 for AO6 on Question 5, your writing should be “consistently” rather than just “mostly” accurate. The image below shows what an examiner would expect to see in a Level 3 versus a Level 4 response:

Venn diagram comparing Level 3 (mostly accurate writing) and Level 4 (consistently accurate writing)  for AQA GCSE English Language
Paper 1 Question 5 mark scheme (AO6)

Examiner Tips and Tricks

The best responses are those where the student has considered the order of information

This means focusing each paragraph on a different idea to move the reader through a “journey” of plot and character development. It is also more successful to describe a small event than construct an intricate plot with lots of characters and twists and turns.

Moving from a Level 3 to a Level 4 response

Below is an example of a couple of paragraphs for a Level 3 response, and a sample answer that’s reflective of a Level 4. It is based on the June 2019 AQA GCSE English Language Paper 1 past paper question below:

AQA GCSE English Language writing task using an image of a busy market scene with people shopping for fruits, vegetables, and meats.
Paper 1 Question 5 descripive writing task

We’ve included annotations to show why each would be awarded each level.

Level 3 response

Level 4 response

Around me all I could see were people pushing, shoving and shouting. The heat was intense, unless you were in the shade. Squeezing myself down the narrow path, I was stuck, surrounded by the smell of hot people, fruit and fish! The aroma of fresh fish fizzed in my nose while the spices and fragrance of apples wafted in the air. 

There were several stalls, all decorated beautifully and in a myriad of colours, with flags and banners dancing above us. Blues and greens, reds and purples everywhere. The market was crowded and noisy with animals, carts, fruit, vegetables and anything else you could imagine. 

The Market

The market roared with rage, for it now was awake from its peaceful slumber. The shops were stuffed and vendors made the street extremely narrow, forcing people to walk in a straight line like soldiers going to battle.

Shops of all different species stood on either side of the street obediently. None of them had doors, for the shopkeepers knew very well that the doors would not last long against the might, impatience and violence of the customers. Herds of people climbed on top of each other at the counter of each shop yelling wildly like screeching birds in a jungle.


Large tattered wagons decorated with a collage of vegetables were parked beside the street, and their owners stood beside them screaming prices like auctioneers; instead of a hammer, they had a carrot which they would use to wave off the flies pointlessly dancing around the fresh produce.

Learn more and test yourself

For more great tips and tricks, check out our dedicated revision notes on how to answer the narrative writing question and how to write the descriptive writing question and our fully annotated narrative writing model answer and our descriptive writing model answer. 

You can also test yourself on Paper 1 Question 5 by building your writing skills with our Paper 1 Question 5 multiple-choice questions and by writing your own narrative or descriptive writing and getting it marked by Smart Mark, our AI model created by English Language experts.

You've read 0 of your 5 free revision notes this week

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Did this page help you?

Sam Evans

Author: Sam Evans

Expertise: English Content Creator

Sam is a graduate in English Language and Literature, specialising in journalism and the history and varieties of English. Before teaching, Sam had a career in tourism in South Africa and Europe. After training to become a teacher, Sam taught English Language and Literature and Communication and Culture in three outstanding secondary schools across England. Her teaching experience began in nursery schools, where she achieved a qualification in Early Years Foundation education. Sam went on to train in the SEN department of a secondary school, working closely with visually impaired students. From there, she went on to manage KS3 and GCSE English language and literature, as well as leading the Sixth Form curriculum. During this time, Sam trained as an examiner in AQA and iGCSE and has marked GCSE English examinations across a range of specifications. She went on to tutor Business English, English as a Second Language and international GCSE English to students around the world, as well as tutoring A level, GCSE and KS3 students for educational provisions in England. Sam freelances as a ghostwriter on novels, business articles and reports, academic resources and non-fiction books.

Kate Lee

Reviewer: Kate Lee

Expertise: English Content Creator

Kate has over 12 years of teaching experience as a Head of English and as a private tutor. Having also worked at the exam board AQA and in educational publishing, she's been writing educational resources to support learners in their exams throughout her career. She's passionate about helping students achieve their potential by developing their literacy and exam skills.