Write about the poem The Newcomer by Brian Patten, and its effect on you.
You may wish to:
consider what the poem is about and how it is organised
consider the ideas the poet may have wanted us to think about
consider the poet’s choice of words, phrases and images and the effects they create
consider how you respond to the poem.
The Newcomer
‘There’s something new in the river,’
The fish said as it swam.
‘It’s got no scales, no fins and no gills,
And ignores the impassable dam.’
‘There’s something new in the trees.’
I heard a bloated thrush sing.
‘It’s got no beak, no claws, and no feathers,
And not even the ghost of a wing.’
‘There’s something new in the warren,’
Said the rabbit to the doe.
‘It’s got no fur, no eyes and no paws,
Yet digs further than we dare go.’
‘There’s something new in the whiteness,’
Said the snow-bright polar bear.
‘I saw its shadow on a glacier,
But it left no pawmarks there.’
Through the animal kingdom
The news was spreading fast.
No beak, no claws, no feather,
No scales, no fur, no gills,
It lives in the trees and the water,
In the soil and the snow and the hills,
And it kills and it kills and it kills.
Brian Patten
Now compare The Fish Are All Sick by Anne Stevenson, and The Newcomer by Brian Patten.
You should:
compare what the poems are about and how they are organised
compare the ideas the poets may have wanted us to think about
compare the poets’ choice of words, phrases and images and the effects they create
compare how you respond to the poems.
The Fish Are All Sick
The fish are all sick, the great whales are dead,
The villages stranded in stone on the coast,
Ornamental, like pearls on the fringe of a coat.
Sea men, who knew what the ocean did,
Turned their low houses away from the surf.
But new men who come to be rural and safe
Add big glass views and begonia beds.
Water keeps to itself.
White lip after lip
Curls to a close on the littered beach.
Something is sicker and blacker than fish.
And closing its grip, and closing its grip.
Anne Stevenson
* begonia – a type of flower
Was this exam question helpful?