Analysis of Ratios (Cambridge (CIE) A Level Accounting): Revision Note
Exam code: 9706
Analysis of ratios
How do I evaluate information from accounting ratios?
STEP 1
State the value of the ratioYou might have to calculate this from data
Make sure you include the correct units (%, times or days)
STEP 2
State whether the ratio has improved or worsenedYou might have to compare:
two businesses
two years for the same business
one year with the industry average
STEP 3
Give a possible reason for the changeSTEP 4
State the implication or give a recommendationYou might have to explain how the result impacts the business
Or you might have to suggest what action should be taken
Examiner Tips and Tricks
Always show your working when calculating a ratio. You can get marks for using your own figures, mark schemes refer to these marks as OF.
Worked Example
David recently inherited $50 000 and wants to invest it in ordinary shares. He is considering two companies in the same industry: Alpha plc and Beta plc.
David has two main investment objectives:
He wants to earn a steady and high regular income from his investment.
He is risk-averse and wants to invest in a company that is considered low risk.
The following information has been extracted from the financial statements of both companies for the year ended 31 December 2025.
Alpha plc ($) | Beta plc ($) | |
|---|---|---|
Ordinary share capital | 400 000 ($1 shares) | 300 000 ($0.50 shares) |
Retained earnings (after the year's profit) | 250 000 | 150 000 |
8% Debentures (2030) | 100 000 | - |
10% Debentures (2028) | - | 300 000 |
Profit for the year | 95 000 | 60 000 |
Dividends paid during the year | 19 000 | 45 000 |
The market price of one ordinary share at 31 December 2025 was $2.85 for Alpha plc and $0.80 for Beta plc.
(a) Calculate the following ratios for both Alpha plc and Beta plc for the year ended 31 December 2025:
(i) Gearing ratio (two decimal places)
(ii) Earnings per share (EPS) (two decimal places)
(iii) Price/earnings (P/E) ratio (nearest whole number)
(iv) Dividend yield (two decimal places)
(b) Advise David which company he should invest in to meet his objectives. Justify your answer using the ratios calculated in (a).
Answer:
(a)
(i) Gearing ratio:
Alpha plc:
Beta plc:
(ii) Earnings per share (EPS):
Alpha plc:
Beta plc:
(iii) Price/earnings (P/E) ratio:
Alpha plc:
Beta plc:
(iv) Dividend per share:
Alpha plc:
Beta plc:
Dividend yield:
Alpha plc:
Beta plc:
(b)
Beta plc has a significantly higher dividend yield (9.38%) compared to Alpha plc (1.67%). Therefore, Beta plc will provide David with the high regular income he is seeking. However, Beta plc distributes a very large portion of its profits as dividends ($45k out of $60k), meaning its dividend cover is low, which could threaten future dividend payouts if profits fall.
Alpha plc is much lower risk because its gearing ratio is only 13.33%, which is considered very low-geared. Beta plc has a gearing ratio of 40%, which is much closer to the 50% high-risk threshold, meaning a large portion of its profits will be consumed by fixed interest payments. Furthermore, Alpha plc has a higher P/E ratio (12) compared to Beta plc (8), indicating that the market has higher confidence in Alpha plc's future growth and stability.
David faces a conflict between his two objectives. He should invest in Beta plc if his need for immediate high income is his absolute priority, but overall, he should invest in Alpha plc because its low gearing aligns perfectly with his risk-averse nature.
What are the interrelationships between ratios?
Ratios affect each other
The table shows examples of how they interact
Change in first ratio | Change in second ratio | Reasons |
|---|---|---|
Gearing increases (due to an increase in non-current liabilities) | Interest cover decreases |
|
Gearing increases (due to shares issued) | Earnings per share usually decreases |
|
Earnings per share decreases | Price/earnings increases (if market price unchanged) |
|
Earnings per share decreases | Dividend cover decreases |
|
Net working assets to revenue increases | Working capital cycle likely increases |
|
Multiple ratios can interact
For example, suppose a business gains more debt
This raises the gearing ratio
It then has to pay more interest
This lowers the interest cover
It then has a lower profit after interest and tax
This lowers earnings per share and dividend cover
Which ratios do stakeholders look at?
Different stakeholders are interested in different ratios
Stakeholder | Most relevant ratios | Reason for the interest |
|---|---|---|
Ordinary shareholders |
|
|
Potential investors |
|
|
Lenders and banks |
|
|
Directors and management | All ratios |
|
Suppliers |
|
|
Worked Example
The directors of M plc are reviewing the company’s financial performance for the year ended 31 December 2025. They want to compare their results against their main competitor, N plc, to assess their market position.
The following ratios have been calculated for both companies for the year ended 31 December 2025:
Ratio | M plc | N plc |
|---|---|---|
Working capital cycle | 78 days | 42 days |
Gearing ratio | 62% | 25% |
Interest cover | 2.5 times | 8.2 times |
Price/earnings (PE) ratio | 6 | 15 |
Dividend yield | 9.2% | 3.5% |
Evaluate the performance and position of M plc compared to N plc in respect of:
(i) working capital management
(ii) solvency and risk
(iii) investor confidence and returns.
Answer:
(i) Working capital management
M plc takes significantly longer to convert its net working assets into cash (78 days) compared to N plc (42 days). This indicates that M plc is less efficient at managing its working capital.
It suggests that M plc may be holding too much inventory for too long, or has poor credit control leading to a longer trade receivables turnover period compared to N plc. Consequently, M plc may face tighter liquidity/cash flow problems than its competitor.
(ii) Solvency and risk
M plc is highly geared (62%), well above the 50% threshold, whereas N plc is low-geared (25%). This means M plc relies heavily on external borrowing rather than shareholder equity, making it a much higher-risk investment than N plc.
M plc has a much lower interest cover (2.5 times) than N plc (8.2 times). This shows that a large proportion of M plc's profit from operations is consumed by finance costs, making it more vulnerable if profits fall, as it may struggle to pay its interest obligations.
(iii) Investor confidence and returns
M plc has a much lower PE ratio (6) than N plc (15). This indicates that the stock market has less confidence in M plc and expects lower future earnings growth compared to N plc.
However, M plc offers a much higher dividend yield (9.2%) compared to N plc (3.5%). This suggests M plc is paying out a large proportion of its earnings to shareholders, making it attractive to investors seeking immediate regular income rather than long-term capital growth.
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?