Evaluating the Mass Flow Hypothesis (AQA A Level Biology): Revision Note
Exam code: 7402
The mass flow hypothesis: evaluating evidence
While the mass flow hypothesis is widely accepted among biologists, it is a theory for which evidence is still being collected
There is evidence both for and against the mass flow hypothesis:
Evidence for the mass flow hypothesis
Observation | How this supports the hypothesis |
|---|---|
When the phloem sieve tube is punctured phloem sap oozes out | The contents of the phloem exert pressure on the phloem walls |
Phloem sap extracted near a source has a higher sucrose concentration than sap extracted near a sink | Water would move into the phloem by osmosis near a source and out of the phloem by osmosis near a sink |
Metabolic inhibitors stop translocation | ATP is required for mass flow to occur; it is an active process |
Removal of a ring of bark from trees results in a bulge above the ring, and fluid from the bulging region has a higher sugar concentration than fluid from below the ring | Removal of the phloem tissue (which is just below the bark) prevents the passage of sugars |
Evidence against the mass flow hypothesis
Observation | How this contradicts the hypothesis |
|---|---|
Amino acids appear to travel more slowly than sucrose in the phloem | The mass flow hypothesis states should be flowing at the same rate |
Experiments have detected different substances, within the same sieve tube, moving in opposite directions | The mass flow hypothesis states everything should be flowing in one direction |
Sieve plates are present in the phloem | These create a barrier to mass flow, so there is no reason for them to have evolved |
Examiner Tips and Tricks
Questions on the mass flow hypothesis often use the command word evaluate. Many students miss marks by describing only supporting evidence; be sure to also include evidence that challenges the hypothesis, such as different solutes moving at different rates or in opposite directions.
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?
Build on this topic