Inquiry 3: Concluding and Evaluating in Biology (DP IB Biology: SL): Exam Questions

1 hour9 questions
1a
3 marks

Cabomba caroliniana is an aquatic plant. A student placed a shoot of Cabomba in a boiling tube of sodium hydrogencarbonate solution, which supplies carbon dioxide. A lamp was placed at different distances from the tube and a light meter was used to measure the light intensity at the tube. After five minutes at each distance, the student counted the number of oxygen bubbles released from the cut end of the shoot in one minute. This was repeated three times at each distance.

The student's hypothesis was: "The rate of photosynthesis increases as light intensity increases."

Table 1

Distance of lamp from tube / cm

Light intensity / lux

Bubbles per minute: trial 1

Bubbles per minute: trial 2

Bubbles per minute: trial 3

Mean bubbles per minute

10

8200

41

38

29

36

20

2100

33

35

34

34

30

930

22

25

21

23

40

520

14

12

16

14

50

330

9

7

8

8

Evaluate the student's hypothesis using the data in Table 1.

1b
2 marks

One result in Table 1 is an outlier.

Identify the outlier and explain how it affects the conclusions that can be drawn from the investigation.

1c
2 marks

The lamp also gives out heat.

Explain how this could affect the validity of the conclusions.

1d
2 marks

Explain one realistic improvement to the method that would give a more accurate measurement of the rate of photosynthesis.

2a
1 mark

Students estimated the population size of the grove snail, Cepaea nemoralis, in a hedgerow. On day 1 they collected snails by hand for 30 minutes, marked each shell with a small dot of non-toxic paint and released the snails where they were found. Two days later, they collected snails again for 30 minutes and counted how many were marked. The students repeated the whole method one week later.

Table 1

Estimate

Snails caught and marked on day 1

Snails caught on day 3

Marked snails caught on day 3

Week 1

48

52

12

Week 2

60

45

9

Calculate the estimated population size for week 1 using the Lincoln index.

2b
2 marks

The estimate for week 2 is 300.

One student concluded that the snail population had increased between week 1 and week 2.

Evaluate this conclusion.

2c
3 marks

The Lincoln index relies on several assumptions.

Discuss how failure to meet these assumptions could have affected the estimates in this investigation.

2d
2 marks

Suggest two improvements to the method that would increase confidence in the estimates of population size.

3a
2 marks

A student used a simple respirometer to investigate the effect of temperature on the rate of cell respiration in germinating mung beans (Vigna radiata). The beans were placed above soda lime, which absorbs carbon dioxide, in a sealed tube attached to a capillary tube containing a drop of coloured liquid. As the beans took in oxygen, the drop moved towards the tube. The respirometer was placed in a water bath at 15 °C, 25 °C or 35 °C and the distance moved by the drop in 10 minutes was recorded. Each temperature was tested three times.

The student's hypothesis was: "The rate of respiration doubles with every 10 °C rise in temperature."

Table 1

Temperature / °C

Distance moved in 10 minutes: trial 1 / mm

Distance moved in 10 minutes: trial 2 / mm

Distance moved in 10 minutes: trial 3 / mm

Mean distance moved in 10 minutes / mm

15

6

7

5

6.0

25

13

11

12

12.0

35

21

25

20

22.0

Evaluate the student's hypothesis using the data in Table 1.

3b
2 marks

The student also set up a control respirometer at 35 °C, containing glass beads instead of beans. In this tube the drop moved 2 mm towards the tube in 10 minutes.

Explain how this result should be used and how it affects the conclusion about the hypothesis.

3c
2 marks

Identify one source of random error and one source of systematic error in this investigation.

3d
2 marks

Explain one realistic improvement to this investigation.

4a
1 mark

Wood sorrel, Oxalis acetosella, is a small plant that grows on woodland floors. Students ran a transect from a meadow into a woodland. At six points along the transect they estimated the percentage cover of wood sorrel in a 1 m2 quadrat. They measured light intensity at ground level once at each quadrat, using a light sensor, at midday.

Table 1

Distance from meadow edge / m

Light intensity / lux

Percentage cover of wood sorrel / %

Field notes

0

52 000

0

Tall meadow grasses

8

31 000

2

Woodland edge

16

9800

18

Under oak trees

24

4100

41

Under oak trees

32

2600

46

Under oak trees

40

2300

12

Thick layer of fallen leaves

Deduce the range of light intensity at which wood sorrel was found along this transect.

4b
3 marks

One student concluded that light intensity is the only abiotic factor that affects the distribution of wood sorrel.

Evaluate this conclusion.

4c
2 marks

Discuss the impact on the conclusion of measuring light intensity only once at each quadrat.

4d
2 marks

Explain one improvement to the sampling method that would make the conclusions more reliable.

5a
1 mark

Students tested the hypothesis that regular swimming training increases vital capacity.

Define vital capacity.

5b
3 marks

The students measured the vital capacity of eight members of a school swimming team and eight students who did not swim regularly. Each person blew one maximum breath out into a balloon. The diameter of the balloon was measured and its volume calculated, assuming the balloon was a sphere.

Table 1

Group

Number of students

Mean vital capacity / dm3

Standard deviation / dm3

Swimmers

8

4.6

0.5

Non-swimmers

8

4.1

0.6

Evaluate the hypothesis using the data in Table 1.

5c
2 marks

Outline two weaknesses in the method used to measure vital capacity.

5d
2 marks

Suggest two ways the investigation could be improved to give a valid test of the hypothesis.

6a
1 mark

A student cut five cylinders of potato tissue of the same length and diameter. Each cylinder was blotted dry, weighed and placed in a different sucrose solution for one hour. The cylinders were then blotted dry again and reweighed, and the percentage change in mass was calculated. One cylinder was used for each concentration.

Table 1

Sucrose concentration / mol dm−3

Percentage change in mass / %

0.0

+18.2

0.2

+7.5

0.4

−2.1

0.6

+4.0

0.8

−16.4

Identify the outlier in Table 1.

6b
2 marks

Using the data in Table 1, outline a conclusion about the effect of sucrose concentration on the mass of the potato cylinders.

6c
1 mark

Deduce the sucrose concentration that is isotonic with the potato tissue.

6d
1 mark

Suggest one improvement to the method that would make the conclusion more reliable.

7a
1 mark

Greater plantain, Plantago major, is a low-growing plant with a rosette of leaves. Students investigated whether trampling affects the population density of plantain in a school field. They placed ten 0.25 m2 quadrats at random positions along the edge of a footpath across the field and ten quadrats at random positions in the centre of the field, away from the path. They counted the number of plantain plants in each quadrat.

Table 1

Area

Number of quadrats

Mean number of plants per quadrat

Standard deviation

Path edge

10

8.4

2.1

Field centre

10

2.6

1.8

State why the quadrats were placed at random positions.

7b
1 mark

Calculate the population density of plantain at the path edge in plants per m2.

7c
2 marks

Deduce, with a reason, the conclusion that can be drawn from the data in Table 1.

7d
1 mark

Suggest one factor, other than trampling, that could explain the difference between the two areas.

8a
1 mark

Students investigated whether there is an association between the distributions of two plants on a heathland: heather, Calluna vulgaris, and wavy hair-grass, Deschampsia flexuosa. They marked out a 50 m × 50 m area, used random numbers to generate coordinates and placed 40 quadrats, each 1 m2. They recorded whether each species was present or absent in each quadrat.

Table 1

Wavy hair-grass present

Wavy hair-grass absent

Total

Heather present

6

16

22

Heather absent

13

5

18

Total

19

21

40

Calculate the expected number of quadrats containing both species if the two species were distributed independently.

8b
1 mark

State the null hypothesis for a chi-squared test on these data.

8c
2 marks

The calculated value of chi-squared was 8.02. There is 1 degree of freedom and the critical value at p = 0.05 is 3.84.

Deduce, with a reason, what the result of the test shows about the two species.

8d
3 marks

One student concluded that heather outcompetes wavy hair-grass on this heathland.

Evaluate this conclusion.

8e
2 marks

Outline two limitations of the sampling method used in this investigation.

8f
2 marks

Suggest two ways the investigation could be extended to provide stronger evidence for or against interspecific competition.

9a
3 marks

Beetroot cells contain a red pigment stored in the vacuole. A student investigated the effect of temperature on the permeability of beetroot membranes. Pieces of beetroot of the same size were cut with a cork borer and rinsed in distilled water. Each piece was placed in 10 cm3 of distilled water in a water bath at one temperature for 30 minutes. The piece was then removed and the absorbance of the water was measured with a colorimeter. A higher absorbance shows that more pigment has leaked out of the cells. There were three trials at each temperature.

The student's hypothesis was: "Membrane permeability increases steadily as temperature increases."

Table 1

Temperature / °C

Absorbance: trial 1

Absorbance: trial 2

Absorbance: trial 3

Mean absorbance

20

0.08

0.10

0.09

0.09

30

0.11

0.13

0.12

0.12

40

0.16

0.15

0.20

0.17

50

0.42

0.47

0.44

0.44

60

0.95

0.88

0.93

0.92

70

1.12

1.18

1.15

1.15

Evaluate the student's hypothesis using the data in Table 1.

9b
3 marks

Explain the results between 40 °C and 70 °C with reference to membrane structure.

9c
2 marks

Identify one source of random error and one source of systematic error, other than calibration of the colorimeter, in this investigation.

9d
2 marks

Before taking any readings, the student should calibrate the colorimeter using a cuvette containing distilled water.

Explain why this is important and how a failure to do this would affect the conclusions.

9e
2 marks

Explain one realistic improvement to this investigation.