Inquiry 3: Concluding and Evaluating in Biology (DP IB Biology: HL): Exam Questions

1 hour9 questions
1a
1 mark

Scientists compared the amino acid sequence of one protein in the domestic horse (Equus caballus) with the sequence of the same protein in six other species of hoofed mammal.

Table 1

Species

Number of amino acid differences compared with the domestic horse

Equus przewalskii

0

Equus asinus

1

Equus quagga

1

Tapirus indicus

4

Ceratotherium simum

6

Diceros bicornis

6

Identify the number of different genera in the first column of Table 1.

1b
2 marks

Deduce whether the data in Table 1 show that Ceratotherium simum and Diceros bicornis are more closely related to each other than either species is to the domestic horse.

1c
4 marks

The domestic horse has 64 chromosomes, but Przewalski's horse (Equus przewalskii) has 66 chromosomes. Scientists compared chromosome 5 of the domestic horse with chromosomes 23 and 24 of Przewalski's horse. Table 2 summarises their findings.

Table 2

Feature

Domestic horse chromosome 5

Przewalski's horse chromosome 23

Przewalski's horse chromosome 24

Length / µm

5.9

3.1

2.8

Number of centromere-type DNA sequences

2

1

1

Number of telomere-type DNA sequences

3 (one at each end and one near the middle)

2 (one at each end)

2 (one at each end)

Banding pattern

Bands on one side of the middle match chromosome 23; bands on the other side match chromosome 24

Matches part of chromosome 5

Matches part of chromosome 5

Using evidence from Table 2, justify the hypothesis that chromosome 5 in the domestic horse formed by the fusion of two chromosomes that match chromosomes 23 and 24 in Przewalski's horse.

1d
1 mark

Hendra virus is carried by fruit bats. It can infect horses, and infected horses have passed the virus to humans.

State one structural feature that is common to all viruses.

1e
1 mark

State the term for an infectious disease, such as Hendra virus infection, that can be transmitted from other species to humans.

2a
1 mark

Three students investigated how quickly their pulse rate returned to normal after exercise. Each student measured their resting pulse rate by counting the beats felt at the radial pulse in the wrist for 15 seconds and multiplying by four. Each student then did step-ups for 3 minutes and measured their pulse rate again 1, 3 and 5 minutes after stopping.

Table 1

Time

Pulse rate of student A / beats min−1

Pulse rate of student B / beats min−1

Pulse rate of student C / beats min−1

At rest

68

74

80

1 minute after exercise

120

132

128

3 minutes after exercise

92

104

136

5 minutes after exercise

70

82

96

Calculate the increase in pulse rate of student B between rest and 1 minute after exercise.

2b
1 mark

State one conclusion about the recovery of pulse rate after exercise that is supported by Table 1.

2c
2 marks

Identify the outlier in Table 1 and suggest one reason for it.

2d
1 mark

Suggest one improvement to the method that would make the conclusions more reliable.

3a
1 mark

A student used a ruler-drop test to find out whether practice improves reaction time. A partner held a 30 cm ruler vertically, with the zero mark level with the top of the student's thumb, and dropped it without warning. The student caught the ruler as quickly as possible and the distance the ruler fell before it was caught was recorded. The student did 20 attempts in a row. The results were grouped into sets of five attempts.

Table 1

Attempts

Mean distance ruler fell / cm

Range of distances / cm

1 to 5

18.4

14 to 23

6 to 10

15.2

12 to 19

11 to 15

13.0

10 to 17

16 to 20

12.6

9 to 16

State why the distance the ruler fell can be used as a measure of reaction time.

3b
2 marks

Deduce a conclusion from the data in Table 1, using values to support your answer.

3c
1 mark

Identify one source of random error in this investigation.

3d
1 mark

Suggest one improvement to the method that would make the conclusion more valid.

4a
1 mark

Students investigated whether seed mass affects germination success in broad beans, Vicia faba. They weighed 80 seeds and sorted them into four mass groups of 20 seeds. All the seeds were planted in the same type of compost, kept at the same temperature and watered equally. After 14 days the number of seeds that had germinated in each group was counted.

Table 1

Seed mass / g

Number of seeds planted

Number of seeds germinated

0.8 to 1.2

20

11

1.3 to 1.7

20

14

1.8 to 2.2

20

17

2.3 to 2.7

20

18

Calculate the percentage of seeds that germinated in the 0.8 to 1.2 g group.

4b
1 mark

Deduce the conclusion that can be drawn from Table 1.

4c
2 marks

A student wrote: "Having a greater mass causes seeds to germinate more successfully."

Explain why the data do not prove this.

4d
1 mark

Suggest why using only 20 seeds in each group reduces confidence in the conclusion.

5a
1 mark

Marine biologists surveyed six reef sites at the end of a hot summer. At each site, divers recorded whether each coral colony along fixed transects was bleached. The maximum monthly mean sea surface temperature (SST) at each site was obtained from satellite data. The satellite SST values have an uncertainty of ±0.5 °C.

Table 1

Site

Maximum monthly mean SST / °C

Number of coral colonies surveyed

Colonies bleached / %

A

28.6

210

4

B

29.1

185

9

C

29.8

240

22

D

30.2

160

40

E

30.4

35

17

F

31.0

205

60

State the relationship between SST and the percentage of colonies bleached.

5b
2 marks

Suggest two reasons why the result for site E does not fit the trend shown by the other sites.

5c
2 marks

Explain the impact of the uncertainty in SST on the conclusions that can be drawn from Table 1.

5d
3 marks

The biologists concluded that high sea temperatures caused the bleaching on these reefs.

Evaluate this conclusion.

6a
1 mark

A population of ground finches lives on a small island. The finches feed on seeds. During a drought year, most plants that produce small, soft seeds died, leaving mainly large, hard seeds. Researchers caught birds in nets, measured their beak depth and released them. They measured birds before the drought, birds that survived the drought and the offspring of the survivors born the following year.

The researchers' hypothesis was: "During the drought, natural selection favoured finches with deeper beaks."

Table 1

Group of finches

Number of birds measured

Mean beak depth / mm

Standard deviation / mm

Before the drought

480

9.42

0.92

Survivors after the drought

72

10.05

0.88

Offspring of survivors

150

9.80

0.95

Calculate the percentage change in mean beak depth between the birds measured before the drought and the survivors.

6b
3 marks

Evaluate the researchers' hypothesis using the data in Table 1.

6c
2 marks

Outline two ways in which the sampling method could limit the conclusions that can be drawn.

6d
2 marks

Explain why the data for the offspring are needed to conclude that the population evolved.

7a
1 mark

In a university laboratory, researchers grew two lines of a non-pathogenic strain of the bacterium Escherichia coli in liquid broth for 400 generations. One line was grown with a low concentration of an antibiotic in the broth (exposed line). The other line was grown without the antibiotic (unexposed line). Both lines started from the same culture.

Every 100 generations, a sample of each line was diluted, and 0.1 cm3 of the same dilution was spread on two agar plates: one plain agar plate and one agar plate containing a high concentration of the antibiotic. The concentration of antibiotic in this agar is high enough to stop non-resistant bacteria from growing.

Table 1

Generation

Exposed line: colonies on plain agar

Exposed line: colonies on antibiotic agar

Unexposed line: colonies on plain agar

Unexposed line: colonies on antibiotic agar

0

212

0

198

0

100

205

9

220

0

200

188

47

201

1

300

196

118

214

0

400

203

171

190

2

Calculate the percentage of bacteria that were resistant in the exposed line at generation 400.

7b
2 marks

Calculate the mean rate of increase in the percentage of resistant bacteria in the exposed line between generation 100 and generation 400. Give your answer in percentage points per 100 generations.

7c
3 marks

Explain the change in the percentage of resistant bacteria in the exposed line with reference to natural selection.

7d
3 marks

A student concluded that exposure to the antibiotic caused the mutations that made the bacteria resistant.

Evaluate this conclusion using the data in Table 1.

7e
2 marks

State two assumptions made when using the colony counts to calculate the percentage of resistant bacteria.

7f
2 marks

It was later found that the antibiotic in all the antibiotic agar plates had partly broken down.

Explain the effect of this systematic error on the results and conclusions.

8a
2 marks

Samples of blood from a healthy volunteer were placed in sealed chambers at 37 °C. Each sample was exposed to a different partial pressure of oxygen (pO2) at one of two partial pressures of carbon dioxide (pCO2). The percentage saturation of haemoglobin with oxygen was measured using an oximeter. Each reading has an uncertainty of ±3%.

A pCO2 of 5.3 kPa is similar to blood in the lungs. A pCO2 of 9.3 kPa is similar to blood in actively respiring muscle.

Table 1

pO2 / kPa

Saturation of haemoglobin at pCO2 = 5.3 kPa / %

Saturation of haemoglobin at pCO2 = 9.3 kPa / %

1

10

6

2

25

16

3

45

32

4

62

48

6

83

72

8

92

86

10

96

93

13

98

97

Blood leaves the lungs at a pO2 of 13 kPa and a pCO2 of 5.3 kPa. In active muscle the pO2 is 4 kPa.

Calculate the percentage increase in the amount of oxygen unloaded in active muscle when the pCO2 rises to 9.3 kPa, compared with unloading at a pCO2 of 5.3 kPa.

8b
1 mark

State the effect of increasing pCO2 on the affinity of haemoglobin for oxygen shown in Table 1.

8c
3 marks

Explain how the data in Table 1 support the accepted scientific explanation of the Bohr shift and its benefit to the body.

8d
3 marks

Explain the impact of the ±3% uncertainty in each saturation reading on the conclusions that can be drawn from Table 1.

8e
2 marks

Evaluate the extent to which these results can be applied to blood in the muscles of a person during strenuous exercise.

9a
1 mark

The blue tit, Cyanistes caeruleus, is a small bird that nests in holes in trees and in nest boxes. Ecologists compared the clutch size (number of eggs laid) of blue tits nesting in a deciduous woodland with those nesting in an urban park 15 km away. Nest boxes were put up at both sites. Each box was checked every three days in spring and the final number of eggs in each nest was recorded.

Table 1

Habitat

Number of nests

Mean clutch size

Standard deviation

Woodland

24

9.2

1.6

Urban park

18

7.1

1.9

A t-test was carried out on the data. The calculated value of t was 3.88. The critical value of t at p = 0.05 with 40 degrees of freedom is 2.02.

State the null hypothesis for this t-test.

9b
2 marks

Deduce, with a reason, what the result of the t-test shows.

9c
3 marks

The ecologists concluded that living in an urban habitat causes blue tits to lay smaller clutches.

Evaluate this conclusion.

9d
2 marks

The difference in clutch size could be due to phenotypic plasticity or to genetic differences between the two populations.

Suggest how the ecologists could find out which explanation is correct.

9e
3 marks

Outline three limitations of the design of this study.