Writing Strong Evaluation (AQA A Level Economics): Revision Note
Exam code: 7136
What is evaluation?
Evaluation [Ev] (AO4) means judging how strong an argument is, and reaching a supported conclusion
It is more than giving "the other side": you explain how far, when and for whom an argument holds
Evaluation is only rewarded in:
the 25-mark questions on all three papers
the 10-mark data question on Paper 3
It earns no marks in the 9-mark or 15-mark questions, so do not include it there
AQA's Level 5 descriptor for 25-mark questions asks for "supported evaluation throughout the response and in a final conclusion"
Supported: every judgement is backed by economic reasoning or evidence
Throughout: evaluate as you go, not only at the end
Question | Where evaluation goes |
|---|---|
10-mark data question (Paper 3) | inside each data paragraph [Ap + An + Ev], including at least one limitation of the data, then a supported final judgement [Ev] |
25-mark Evaluate / Assess / Discuss | in its own paragraph after each knowledge, application and analysis (KAA) paragraph, then a conclusion |
25-mark Justify your recommendation (Paper 3) | as above, ending with a recommendation |
An evaluation paragraph judges the KAA paragraph before it, so build a strong KAA paragraph first
See the Writing a Strong KAA Paragraph page
Anatomy of an evaluation paragraph
Key: Ap = application · An = analysis · Ev = evaluation
Step | What to write | Example |
|---|---|---|
1. Judge (Ev) | make a judgement about the argument you have just made | "The size of this effect depends on the wage elasticity of demand for labour." |
2. Support (An) | explain why, with a short chain of reasoning | "If demand is inelastic, for example where labour cannot easily be replaced by machines, few jobs are lost." |
3. Evidence or exception (Ap, Ev) | add evidence, an exception or a different context | "In a monopsony labour market… a minimum wage can raise both wages and employment." |
4. Mini-conclusion (Ev) | say how far the argument holds | "…although the risk is likely to grow as the minimum wage rises closer to median pay." |
AQA's Level 5 asks for "supported evaluation", so an evaluation paragraph needs reasoning, not just "however" followed by a new point
Evaluation is rewarded "throughout the response", so a short evaluative phrase inside a KAA paragraph is also good practice
In Section A, use the extracts throughout; in Section B, use real-world examples and data from your own knowledge
Writing good evaluation
Evaluation means judging the strength of an argument, not just giving the other side
Use these questions to evaluate each strand:
Ask yourself… | Example phrase |
|---|---|
How big is the effect? | "The impact is likely to be small because demand is price inelastic…" |
When will it happen: short run or long run? | "In the short run… but in the long run…" |
What does it depend on? | "This depends on whether the economy has spare capacity…" |
Who is affected, and does it differ between groups? | "Low-income households are hit hardest, as…" |
How likely is it, and what assumptions does it rely on? | "This assumes firms pass the cost on to consumers…" |
Could it cause unintended consequences or government failure? | "The government may lack the information to set the tax at the right level…" |
Is there a better alternative? | "A subsidy for healthier alternatives may be more effective because…" |
Weak and strong evaluation
Weak: "However, there are also disadvantages to a minimum wage."
This only says that another side exists
Strong: "However, a minimum wage only helps households where someone is in work, so it does little for pensioners or the unemployed, who make up a large share of those in poverty."
This explains why the argument is limited and who it fails to reach
Examiner Tips and Tricks
Do not save all your evaluation for the conclusion. Finish every strand with a sentence that judges it, starting with a phrase such as "However, this depends on…" or "The significance of this is limited because…".
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?