Answering 25-Mark Justify Your Recommendation Questions (Paper 3) (AQA A Level Economics): Revision Note

Exam code: 7136

Steve Vorster

Written by: Steve Vorster

Reviewed by: Bridgette Barrett

Updated on

How Question 33 is different

  • Question 33 is the final question in the Paper 3 Investigation, worth 25 marks

    • It is marked in the same way as the 25-mark questions on Papers 1 and 2, and uses the same eight-paragraph structure

    • See the Answering 25-Mark Evaluate, Assess & Discuss Questions page for the levels and the structure

  • This page covers only what is different about Question 33

  • It almost always follows this pattern:

    • "After considering Extract D, and the original evidence in Extracts A, B and C, would you recommend that [the government / a named organisation] [takes a particular action]? Justify your recommendation."

  • The action is usually a form of government intervention

    • e.g. a subsidy, extra government spending, a spending cut, regulation, or a higher minimum wage

Papers 1 and 2 (25 marks)

Paper 3 (Question 33)

What you must reach

a judgement that answers the question

a recommendation: yes, no, or yes but only under certain conditions

Your role

writing as an economist

the economist in the scenario, advising the organisation named at the start of the Investigation

Your evidence

one set of extracts (Section A) or your own knowledge (Section B)

all four extracts in the Insert, plus your own knowledge

Range of economics

mainly micro (Paper 1) or macro (Paper 2)

synoptic: combine ideas from across the whole course

The three strands

your choice of three arguments

the case for, the case against, and an alternative policy

  • The mark scheme adds one extra rule for Question 33:

    • "An answer that does not include any evaluation or a supported recommendation must not be awarded more than 13 marks"

  • Aim for about 650 words, in about 35 minutes

Structuring a recommendation

Key: K = knowledge · Ap = application · An = analysis · Ev = evaluation · KAA = knowledge, application and analysis

  • Use the following structure to help you reach Level 5

    • [K + Ap + signpost] → ([KAA: for] → [Ev]) → ([KAA: against] → [Ev]) → ([KAA: alternative] → [Ev]) → [Ev: recommendation]: eight paragraphs

  • The structure is the same as for Papers 1 and 2, with two changes:

    • The three KAA strands are always for, against and an alternative policy

    • The final paragraph is a recommendation, not just a conclusion

  • Build each KAA paragraph as shown on the Writing a Strong KAA Paragraph page, and each evaluation paragraph as shown on the Writing Strong Evaluation page

Anatomy of a recommendation paragraph

Step

What to write

Example

1. Decision

answer the question directly

"Overall, I would recommend a subsidy, but only in a limited form."

2. Conditions

say how, for how long or for whom, with each condition based on your evaluation

"It should be temporary… and paid for each extra passenger on new routes…"

3. Justification

explain why, using the strongest evidence

"…targeted at routes serving the coastal regions, where the recovery has been weakest and the multiplier effect on jobs is greatest."

4. Final test

say what would make the policy not worth it

"Without these conditions, the £200 million cost would be hard to justify."

  • You can give your recommendation at the start, as long as you still develop and evaluate the arguments against it

  • A one-sided answer that only supports your recommendation will not reach the top levels

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Sitting on the fence is not a recommendation. "It depends" is a good start to an evaluation, but your final paragraph must say what you would advise, and why.

Using the insert

  • The question asks you to consider Extract D and the original evidence in Extracts A, B and C

  • Use all four extracts, not just Extract D

    • Extract D usually sets out arguments for and against the policy

    • Use these as a starting point, but develop each one with your own economic analysis rather than repeating it

  • Extract B contains the data

    • Use and manipulate figures to support your arguments, e.g. a percentage change or a comparison

  • Extracts A and C give the background and the economics of the issue

    • Paper 3 is synoptic, so bring in ideas from across the course

    • e.g. market failure and externalities alongside fiscal policy, the multiplier or the balance of payments

  • Put short phrases you quote from the extracts in quotation marks

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Do not repeat the analysis you wrote for Questions 31 and 32. Question 33 is about the recommendation, so use earlier points only where they support or challenge your advice.

Worked Example

The Investigation is about the tourism industry in Country Z. Extract D reports that the government is considering paying subsidies to airlines that open new routes to Country Z.

  • Supporters argue that more visitors would raise spending, jobs and tax revenue, especially in coastal regions where tourism is the main employer

  • Critics argue that the subsidy would cost £200 million a year, that airlines might have added some routes anyway, that extra flights would increase carbon emissions, and that visitor numbers depend more on exchange rates and the world economy

After considering Extract D, and the original evidence in Extracts A, B and C, would you recommend that the government of Country Z subsidise airlines to open new routes to the country? Justify your recommendation.

[25 marks]

Essay plan

Paragraph

Content

Evaluation

Introduction

define a subsidy; use Extract B to show that visitors are still about 9% below 2019; three issues

Strand 1: for

more visitors → more spending → multiplier effects in coastal regions → jobs and tax revenue.

evaluate: leakages, and airlines might have added routes anyway (deadweight)

Strand 2: against

£200 million opportunity cost; negative externality of extra flights.

evaluate: the cost is partly offset by tax revenue; the size of the externality depends on the number of extra flights

Strand 3: alternatives

tourism marketing, lower visa costs, improved local transport.

evaluate: cheaper, but slower or less certain

Recommendation

yes, but only as a temporary subsidy, paid per extra passenger, for routes to the coastal regions with the lowest recovery

Why this plan would reach Level 5

  • The introduction uses the data in Extract B, not only Extract D

    • Each strand is followed by its own evaluation, so evaluation runs throughout the answer

    • Strand 1 develops a synoptic chain, from tourist spending to the multiplier and regional jobs

    • The recommendation is clear and conditional, and each condition follows from the evaluation in the strands

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Steve Vorster

Author: Steve Vorster

Expertise: Content Creator

Steve has taught A Level, GCSE, IGCSE Business and Economics - as well as IBDP Economics and Business Management. He is an IBDP Examiner and IGCSE textbook author. His students regularly achieve 90-100% in their final exams. Steve has been the Assistant Head of Sixth Form for a school in Devon, and Head of Economics at the world's largest International school in Singapore. He loves to create resources which speed up student learning and are easily accessible by all.

Bridgette Barrett

Reviewer: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.