Testing for Halide Ions (AQA A Level Chemistry): Revision Note

Exam code: 7405

Stewart Hird

Written by: Stewart Hird

Reviewed by: Caroline Carroll

Updated on

Testing for Halides

Silver ions and ammonia

  • Halide ions can be identified in an unknown solution by dissolving the solution in nitric acid and then adding silver nitrate solution dropwise

  • The nitric acid is used to prevent any false positive results from carbonate ions precipitating out with silver ions

  • The halide ions will react with the silver nitrate solution as shown in the following ionic equation:

Ag+ (aq) + X- (aq) → AgX (s)

Where X- is the halide ion

  • The state symbols are key in this equation

  • If the unknown solution contains halide ions, a precipitate of the silver halide will be formed (AgX)

Examiner Tips and Tricks

The acidifying reagent must be dilute nitric acid, not hydrochloric acid, since HCl would introduce interfering chloride ions.

Diagram showing silver nitrate added to an unknown halide in dilute nitric acid, forming a visible precipitate of solid silver halide in a test tube
A silver halide precipitate is formed upon addition of silver nitrate solution to halide ion solution
  • Silver chloride (AgCl) is a white precipitate

  • Silver bromide (AgBr) is a cream precipitate

  • Silver iodide (AgI) is a yellow precipitate

Diagram of three test tubes in a rack showing blue solutions forming white, cream, and yellow silver halide precipitates, each labelled beneath with its precipitate colour.
The silver halide precipitates are dense and characteristically coloured

Adding ammonia

  • Because the white, cream, and yellow precipitates could look very similar in colour, ammonia is often used as a follow-up test to determine which halide ion is present

  • Dilute followed by concentrated ammonia is added to the silver halide solution to identify the halide ion

  • If the precipitate dissolves in dilute ammonia solution, the unknown halide is chloride

  • If the precipitate does not dissolve in dilute ammonia, but does dissolve in concentrated ammonia, the unknown halide is bromide

  • If the precipitate does not dissolve in dilute or concentrated ammonia, then the unknown halide is iodide

Diagram of two test tubes showing yellow AgI precipitate that remains undissolved, labelled that silver iodide does not form a soluble complex with ammonia
Silver chloride and silver bromide precipitates dissolve on addition of ammonia solution whereas silver iodide is insoluble in ammonia

Reaction of Halide Ions with Silver Nitrate & Ammonia Solutions

Halide ion

Colour of Silver Halide Solution

Effect of adding dil. NH3

Effect of adding conc. NH3

Cl- (aq)

White

Dissolves

Dissolves

Br- (aq)

Cream

Insoluble

Dissolves

I- (aq)

Pale yellow

Insoluble

Insoluble

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Examiners often penalise students for writing that the "solution" or "ions" dissolve in ammonia rather than the "precipitate."

Students must use precise wording for observations, since mark schemes are strict: "white/cream/pale yellow precipitate".

Concentrated sulfuric acid

  • Chloride, bromide, and iodide ions react with concentrated sulfuric acid to produce toxic gases

  • These reactions should therefore be carried out in a fume cupboard

  • The general reaction of the halide ions with concentrated sulfuric acid is:

H2SO4(l) + X-(aq) → HX(g) + HSO4-(aq)

(general equation)

where X is the halide ion

Reaction of chloride ions with concentrated sulfuric Acid

  • Concentrated sulfuric acid is added dropwise to sodium chloride crystals to produce hydrogen chloride gas

Laboratory setup showing preparation of dry hydrogen chloride gas from heated NaCl and conc. sulphuric acid, drying through conc. H₂SO₄ and collection in a gas jar
Apparatus set up for the preparation of hydrogen chloride gas from sodium chloride with concentrated sulfuric acid
  • The reaction that takes place is:

H2SO4 (l) + NaCl (s) → HCl (g) + NaHSO4 (s)      

  • The HCl gas produced is seen as white fumes

Reaction of bromide ions with concentrated sulfuric acid

  • The reaction of sodium bromide and concentrated sulfuric acid is:

H2SO4 (l) + NaBr (s) → HBr (g) + NaHSO4 (s)     

  • The concentrated sulfuric acid oxidises HBr, which decomposes into bromine and hydrogen gas, and sulfuric acid itself is reduced to sulfur dioxide gas:

2HBr (g) + H2SO4 (l) → Br2 (g) + SO2 (g) + 2H2O (l)

  • The bromine is seen as orange-brown fumes/gas

Reaction of iodide ions with concentrated sulfuric acid

  • The reaction of sodium iodide and concentrated sulfuric acid is:

H2SO4 (l) + NaI (s) → HI (g) + NaHSO4 (s)          

  • Hydrogen iodide decomposes readily

  • Sulfuric acid oxidises the hydrogen iodide to form several products:

  • The concentrated sulfuric acid oxidises HI and is itself reduced to sulfur dioxide gas:

2HI (g) + H2SO4 (l) → I2 (s) + SO2 (g) + 2H2O (l)

  • Iodine is seen as a brown solution or black solid

  • The concentrated sulfuric acid oxidises HI and is itself reduced to sulfur:

6HI (g) + H2SO4 (l) → 3I2 (g) + S (s) + 4H2O (l)

  • Sulfur is seen as a yellow solid

  • The concentrated sulfuric acid oxidises HI and is itself reduced to hydrogen sulfide:

8HI (g) + H2SO4 (l) → 4I2 (g) + H2S (s) + 4H2O (l)

  • Hydrogen sulfide has a strong smell of rotten eggs

Summary of the Halide Ion Reactions with Concentrated Sulfuric Acid 

Halide Ion Reactions with Concentrated Sulfuric Acid Table

Halide ion

Reaction with conc H2SO4

Observations

Cl- (aq)

H2​SO4​ (l) + NaCl (s) → HCl (g) + NaHSO4​ (s)

Misty fumes of HCl gas

Br- (aq)

H2​SO4​ (l) + NaBr (s) → HBr (g) + NaHSO4​ (s)

H2​SO4​ (l) + 2HBr (g) → Br2 (g) + SO2 (g) + 2H2O (l)

Misty fumes of HBr gas

Choking gas of SO2 and reddish-brown gas of Br2

I- (aq)

H2SO4 (l) + NaI (s) → HI (g) + NaHSO4 (s)

H2​SO4​ (l) + 2HI (g) → I2 (s) + SO2 (g) + 2H2O (l)

H2​SO4​ (l) + 6HI (g) → 3I2 (s) + S (s) + 4H2O (l)

H2​SO4​ (l) + 8HI (g) → 4I2 (s) + H2S (g) + 4H2O (l)

Misty fumes of HI gas

Choking gas of SO2 and purple vapour of I2

Yellow solid of S (s)

Strong, bad egg smell of

H2S (g)

Related topics

Examiner Tips and Tricks

It gets easier to oxidise the hydrogen halides as you go down Group 7: the halides become stronger reducing agents.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Build on this topic

Stewart Hird

Author: Stewart Hird

Expertise: Chemistry Content Creator

Stewart has been an enthusiastic GCSE, IGCSE, A Level and IB teacher for more than 30 years in the UK as well as overseas, and has also been an examiner for IB and A Level. As a long-standing Head of Science, Stewart brings a wealth of experience to creating Topic Questions and revision materials for Save My Exams. Stewart specialises in Chemistry, but has also taught Physics and Environmental Systems and Societies.

Caroline Carroll

Reviewer: Caroline Carroll

Expertise: Head of Content Delivery

Caroline graduated from the University of Nottingham with a degree in Chemistry and Molecular Physics. She spent several years working as an Industrial Chemist in the automotive industry before retraining to teach. Caroline has over 12 years of experience teaching GCSE and A-level chemistry and physics. She is passionate about delivering high-quality resources to help students achieve their full potential.