Identifying Anions & Cations (AQA A Level Chemistry): Revision Note

Exam code: 7405

Stewart Hird

Written by: Stewart Hird

Reviewed by: Caroline Carroll

Updated on

Identifying Anions & Cations

REQUIRED PRACTICAL 4

Test Tube Reactions

  • Group 2 ions (M2+)

  • Ammonium ions (NH4+)

  • Halide ions (X-)

  • Hydroxide ions (OH-)

  • Carbonate ions (CO32-)

  • Sulfate ions (SO42-)

  • If the sample to be tested is a solid, then it must be dissolved in deionised water and made into an aqueous solution

Testing for Group 2 Metals

  • Four test tubes should be placed in a test tube rack

  • Around 10 drops of 0.1 mol dm-3 barium chloride solution should be added to the first test tube

  • Around 10 drops of dilute sodium hydroxide solution (NaOH) should be added to the same test tube

  • Swirl the test tube carefully to mix well

  • Continue to add sodium hydroxide dropwise to the test tube until it is in excess

  • This should then be repeated in the other test tubes, for calcium bromide solution, magnesium chloride solution, and strontium chloride solution

  • Any observations should be noted down in a suitable results table

  • The same test as above can also be done using ammonia solution and sulfuric acid solution

The positive results of testing for the presence of Group 2 ions 

Mg2+

Ca2+

Sr2+

Ba2+

Ammonia solution

White precipitate Mg(OH)2

No change seen

No change seen

No change seen

Excess sodium hydroxide

White precipitate Mg(OH)2

White precipitate Ca(OH)2

Slight white precipitate Sr(OH)2

No change seen

Excess sulfuric acid

Colourless solution

White precipitate CaSO4

White precipitate

SrSO4

White precipitate BaSO4

Testing for Ammonium Ions

  • About 10 drops of a solution containing ammonium ions, such as ammonium chloride, should be added to a clean test tube

  • About 10 drops of sodium hydroxide should be added using a pipette

  • The test tube should be swirled carefully to ensure that it is mixed well

  • The test tube of the solution should then be placed in a beaker of water, and the beaker of water should be placed above a Bunsen burner, so that it can become a water bath

  • As the solution is heated gently, fumes will be produced

  • A pair of tongs should be used to hold a damp piece of red litmus paper near the mouth of the test tube to test the fumes

  • The red litmus paper will change colour and become blue in the presence of ammonia gas

Laboratory setup with a beaker of water on a stand heated by a Bunsen burner, containing a test tube and litmus paper for testing for ammonia gas. The red litmus paper turns blue.
Damp red litmus paper turning blue in the presence of ammonia gas
  • The ionic equation is:

NH4+ + OH- → NH3 + H2O

Testing for Halide Ions

  • The sample being tested should be added using a pipette to a test tube

  • The test tube should be placed into a test tube rack

  • A small amount of dilute nitric acid should be added to the sample using a pipette, followed by a small amount of silver nitrate solution

  • Acidifying removes carbonate and hydroxide ions that would otherwise form their own silver precipitates and give a false positive

  • A precipitate will form, either white, cream, or yellow, if a halide ion is present in the sample

  • The ionic equations are:

Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq) AgCl(s)

Ag+(aq) + Br-(aq) AgBr(s)

Ag+(aq) + l-(aq) Agl(s)

Three test tubes with solutions show different precipitates: white in the first tube, cream in the second, and yellow in the third, each labelled underneath.
The white, cream and yellow precipitates formed when halide ions react with silver nitrate solution
  • The white precipitate will form if chloride ions are present in the sample. The white precipitate is AgCl

  • The cream precipitate will form if bromide ions are present in the sample. The cream precipitate is AgBr

  • The yellow precipitate will form if iodide ions are present in the sample. The yellow precipitate is AgI

Further Test using Ammonia

Two test tubes: left shows white AgCl precipitate in pale solution; right shows clear solution after AgCl dissolves in dilute ammonia, forming a soluble complex
Two test tubes: left shows pale cream AgBr precipitate in solution; right shows clear solution labelled that AgBr dissolves in concentrated ammonia.
Diagram of two test tubes showing yellow silver iodide precipitate unchanged, labelled “AgI precipitate” and “AgI doesn’t form a soluble complex with ammonia”.
Results of the test with ammonia to further distinguish between silver halide precipitates
  • To distinguish between the three silver halide precipitates, further tests can be carried out using ammonia solution

  • Silver chloride dissolves in dilute ammonia solution

  • Silver bromide dissolves in concentrated ammonia solution

  • Silver iodide dissolves in both

Testing for Hydroxide Ions

  • A small amount (around 1 cm3) of the solution should be added to a test tube using a pipette

  • Test the pH of the solution using red litmus paper or universal indicator paper

    • The presence of hydroxide ions will turn the red litmus paper blue, and the pH will be clearly alkaline on the universal indicator paper if hydroxide ions are present

Testing for Carbonate Ions

  • A small amount (around 1 cm3) of dilute hydrochloric acid should be added to a test tube using a pipette

  • An equal amount of sodium carbonate solution should then be added to the test tube using a clean pipette

  • As soon as the sodium carbonate solution is added, a bung with a delivery tube should be attached to the test tube

    • The delivery tube should transfer the gas that is formed into a different test tube, which contains a small amount of limewater (calcium hydroxide solution)

  • Carbonate ions will react with hydrogen ions from the acid to produce carbon dioxide gas

  • Carbon dioxide gas will turn the limewater milky

Diagram showing carbon dioxide bubbled through clear limewater, forming insoluble calcium carbonate so the solution turns cloudy or milky in the test tube.
When carbon dioxide gas is bubbled into limewater it will turn cloudy as calcium carbonate is produced

Testing for Sulfate Ions

  • Acidify the sample with dilute hydrochloric acid and then add a few drops of aqueous barium chloride

  • If a sulfate is present, then a white precipitate of barium sulfate is formed:

Ba2+ (aq) + SO42- (aq) → BaSO4 (s)

White precipitate of barium sulfate forming when acidified barium chloride is added to a sulfate solution
A white precipitate of barium sulfate is a positive result for the presence of sulfate ions

Order of Testing

  • The order in which the tests must be carried out on an unknown sample is carbonate, then sulfate, then halide

  • Carbonate gives a white precipitate with both barium chloride and silver nitrate (and silver sulfate is only sparingly soluble), so carbonate has to be removed first and sulfate tested before the halides

Related topics

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Students often forget to state that HCl is added first to remove any carbonates that may be present and would also produce a precipitate and interfere with the results.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Build on this topic

Stewart Hird

Author: Stewart Hird

Expertise: Chemistry Content Creator

Stewart has been an enthusiastic GCSE, IGCSE, A Level and IB teacher for more than 30 years in the UK as well as overseas, and has also been an examiner for IB and A Level. As a long-standing Head of Science, Stewart brings a wealth of experience to creating Topic Questions and revision materials for Save My Exams. Stewart specialises in Chemistry, but has also taught Physics and Environmental Systems and Societies.

Caroline Carroll

Reviewer: Caroline Carroll

Expertise: Head of Content Delivery

Caroline graduated from the University of Nottingham with a degree in Chemistry and Molecular Physics. She spent several years working as an Industrial Chemist in the automotive industry before retraining to teach. Caroline has over 12 years of experience teaching GCSE and A-level chemistry and physics. She is passionate about delivering high-quality resources to help students achieve their full potential.