How to Answer 18-Mark & 24-Mark Questions (Edexcel A Level Geography): Revision Note

Exam code: 9GE0

Bridgette Barrett

Written by: Bridgette Barrett

Reviewed by: Alistair Marjot

Updated on

What are 18-mark and 24-mark questions?

  • The 18-mark and 24-mark questions, often called the 18-marker and 24-marker, are the two extended essays that end Paper 3

  • You will answer both, as Question 5 and Question 6

    • Together they carry 42 of the 70 marks on Paper 3 (60%)

  • You have about 31 minutes for Question 5 and about 41 minutes for Question 6, with the Resource Booklet and your own knowledge to work with

The questions at a glance

Feature

Question 5

Question 6

Marks

18

24

What you use

Section B of the booklet and your own knowledge

the whole booklet and your own knowledge

Suggested time

about 31 minutes, including planning

about 41 minutes, including planning

Suggested length

about 620–680 words

about 820–910 words

Assessment objective 1

3 marks

4 marks

Assessment objective 2

9 marks

12 marks

Assessment objective 3

6 marks

8 marks

Levels

3

4

Command words and assessment objectives

  • The command word is always "evaluate", which means measuring the value or success of something and ending with a balanced, substantiated judgement

  • Past paper questions include:

    • “Evaluate the view that China is more likely than India to become a global superpower by the middle of this century.” (Paper 3, June 2025)

    • “Evaluate the view that Haiti’s colonial past is the main reason for its current level of development.” (Paper 3, June 2024)

    • “Evaluate the view that the crisis of biodiversity loss is both more serious and more challenging to solve than climate change.” (Paper 3, June 2023)

    • “Evaluate the view that without significant global action to address climate change, the future of SIDS is one of decline.” (Paper 3, June 2022)

  • The first two of these are Question 5 and the others are Question 6

  • Question 6 can also open with a quoted view and end "Evaluate this view", as it did in June 2024

  • Both questions test three assessment objectives (AOs) in the same ratio:

    • AO1: what you know, meaning knowledge and understanding of geographical ideas, places and processes

    • AO2: what you do with it, meaning applying that knowledge to make connections, interpret evidence and reach a conclusion

    • AO3: what you can do with data and evidence, meaning judging its value and reliability and connecting it to ideas from across your course

  • Half of the marks are for AO2, so taking evidence from the booklet is only the start of your answer

How much should I write?

  • The suggested times and lengths take off the 15-minute read at the start of the paper

How are 18-mark and 24-mark questions marked?

  • These are levelled response questions, so each point you make doesn't automatically earn a mark

  • The examiner reads your whole essay and decides which level it best fits

  • The examiner then places it within that level's mark range

  • Unlike Papers 1 and 2, Paper 3 has no set limit on marks for an essay that only shows knowledge, but you still need every strand to reach the top level

Question 5: the three levels

Level 3 (13–18 marks)

  • Accurate and relevant knowledge and understanding throughout

  • Fully logical and relevant connections between ideas

  • A full and coherent interpretation, supported by evidence

  • A rational, substantiated conclusion, fully supported by a balanced argument that is drawn together coherently

  • Valid judgements about the value and reliability of quantitative and qualitative data and evidence throughout

  • A critical investigation of the question, with a coherent interpretation of the data and evidence, and meaningful connections to relevant ideas from across your course throughout

Level 2 (7–12 marks)

  • Knowledge and understanding that is mostly relevant but may include some inaccuracies

  • Some logical connections between ideas

  • A partial but coherent interpretation, supported by some evidence

  • A conclusion partially supported by an argument that may be unbalanced or partially coherent

  • Some valid judgements about the value and reliability of quantitative and qualitative data and evidence

  • An interpretation of the data and evidence, with some meaningful connections to ideas from across your course

Level 1 (1–6 marks)

  • Isolated elements of knowledge and understanding, some of which may be inaccurate or irrelevant

  • Limited and rarely logical connections between ideas

  • An interpretation with limited relevance or support

  • An unsupported or generic conclusion, from an argument that is unbalanced or lacks coherence

  • Superficial judgements about the value and reliability of quantitative and qualitative data and evidence

  • A limited interpretation of the data and evidence, lacking meaningful connections to ideas from across your course

Question 6: the four levels

Level 4 (19–24 marks)

  • Accurate and relevant knowledge and understanding throughout

  • Fully logical and relevant connections between ideas

  • A full and coherent interpretation, supported by evidence

  • A rational, substantiated conclusion, fully supported by a balanced argument that is drawn together coherently

  • Valid judgements about the value and reliability of quantitative and qualitative data and evidence throughout

  • A critical investigation of the question, with a coherent interpretation of the data and evidence, comprehensively making meaningful connections to relevant ideas from across your course throughout

Level 3 (13–18 marks)

  • Knowledge and understanding that is mostly relevant and accurate

  • Some logical and relevant connections between ideas

  • A partial but coherent interpretation, supported by some evidence

  • A conclusion largely supported by an argument that may be unbalanced or partially coherent

  • Mostly valid judgements about the value and reliability of quantitative and qualitative data and evidence

  • A critical investigation of the question, with a coherent interpretation of the data and evidence, and connections to relevant ideas from across your course, some of which are meaningful

Level 2 (7–12 marks)

  • Knowledge and understanding that is occasionally relevant and may include some inaccuracies

  • Limited but logical connections between ideas

  • A partial interpretation, with some evidence but limited coherence

  • A conclusion partially supported by an unbalanced argument with limited coherence

  • Some valid judgements about the value and reliability of quantitative and qualitative data and evidence

  • An interpretation of the data and evidence, with few connections to ideas from across your course, which may not be meaningful

Level 1 (1–6 marks)

  • The six strands are worded in the same way as Level 1 for Question 5

What separates the top level from the one below?

  • The level below often relies on evidence from the booklet, with little of your own knowledge or argument around it

  • The top level uses each piece of evidence as part of an argument, and qualifies it with ideas such as short term and long term, or rural and urban

  • An essay doesn't have to be flawless to get full marks, as long as it clearly meets the top-level description

How to answer 18-mark and 24-mark questions

  • The steps are the same for both questions

  • This example uses a 24-mark question, with a short Question 5 example at the end

Step 1

  • Read the question carefully and highlight the command word

"Evaluate the view that cooperation between governments is the most important factor in securing the future water supply of countries in the Nile basin."

  • "Evaluate the view" means that you need to weigh up evidence for and against the view, then reach a judgement

Step 2

  • Highlight the key words, then ask what each one means

"Evaluate the view that cooperation between governments is the most important factor in securing the future water supply of countries in the Nile basin."

  • In this example, your essay must:

    • show how cooperation affects water supply

    • compare it with other factors

    • consider what "future" means, such as the next decade or 2050

    • look for differences between countries

Step 3

  • Spend about 5 minutes writing a short plan

  • List the figures you intend to use, then decide your judgement first

  • A 24-marker structure for this question could be:

    • opening position: cooperation matters, but not in every country or over every timescale

    • argument for: dependence on upstream flow and the dam dispute

    • limit: why cooperation is hard to achieve

    • argument against: population growth

    • argument against: investment and technology

    • data judgement: what Figure 1 can and can't show

    • uncertainty: climate change

    • conclusion: a judgement that returns to "most important" and "future"

Step 4

  • Write your essay, opening with a clear position on the question

  • Give each paragraph one clear focus

  • Use the data as evidence in your argument, then judge how far you can trust it:

    • Copied from the booklet: "Ethiopia's population is projected to reach 225 million by 2050"

    • Blended with knowledge and argument: "Even a fair treaty would have to share the same river among many more people, so rising demand could outweigh the benefits of cooperation"

  • Finish with a judgement that follows from your argument

What if?

  • You have little time left for Question 6: still write an answer, using your plan as short paragraphs and ending with a judgement, because a blank answer can't gain any marks

  • The booklet seems to support only one side: use your own knowledge for the other side, and say what the booklet leaves out

  • You want to reuse a point from Question 5: take it further with new evidence or a different scale, so that it answers the new question

Worked Example

Study Figure 1 and use your own knowledge. In the exam, you would use the whole Resource Booklet.

Figure 1: Population and water use in three Nile basin countries

Country

Population, 2022 (millions)

Projected population, 2050 (millions)

Water withdrawals as a percentage of internal freshwater (%)

People with at least basic drinking water, 2022 (%)

Egypt

113

162

7,750

97

Ethiopia

125

225

9

53

Sudan

49

85

673

63

Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators, and United Nations, World Population Prospects 2024 (medium variant). Internal freshwater excludes rivers flowing in from other countries. Withdrawal figures are the same for every year from 2017 to 2022.

Evaluate the view that cooperation between governments is the most important factor in securing the future water supply of countries in the Nile basin.

[24 marks]

Model answer:

Cooperation between governments matters because the Nile crosses international borders, so no single country can secure its supply alone. [Ap] However, it is not the most important factor in every country or over every timescale, because demand, investment and climate also decide how far the water goes. [Ap]

Water security means reliable access to enough safe water. [KU] About 85% of the Nile's flow starts in the Ethiopian highlands, so downstream countries depend on what happens upstream. [KU] Figure 1 supports this, as Egypt's withdrawals are 7,750% of its internal freshwater, which is only possible because most of its water flows in from other countries. [E] Egypt's supply is therefore exposed to decisions made elsewhere, which makes cooperation vital for its future. [Ap] The 1959 agreement divided the flow between Egypt (55.5 billion m³) and Sudan (18.5 billion m³) without including Ethiopia. [KU] Ethiopia's opening of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) in 2025, without a binding agreement with Egypt, shows the risk of leaving out a key player. [Ap] This supports the view, because the dispute is about who controls the water as much as how much there is. [Ap]

Cooperation is also difficult to achieve, which limits how far it can secure supply. The Nile Basin Cooperative Framework Agreement, a water-sharing treaty led by upstream countries, came into force in 2024, but Egypt and Sudan rejected it. [KU] Power in the basin is also shifting, as Ethiopia's control of the dam challenges the stronger position that Egypt held under the older agreements, so any new deal must be negotiated between more equal players. [Ap] An agreement could reduce the risk of conflict, but it would not add any water to the river. [Ap]

Population growth could matter more in the long term. Figure 1 shows Ethiopia's population rising from 125 million to a projected 225 million by 2050, and Egypt's rising from 113 million to 162 million. [E] Even a fair treaty would have to share the same river among many more people, so rising demand could outweigh the benefits of cooperation. [Ap] These are projections based on assumptions about fertility, and conflict in Sudan since 2023 makes its figures especially uncertain. [E] The direction of change is therefore more reliable than the exact totals. [E] Demand and cooperation are also linked, because slower population growth would make any agreement easier to keep. [Ap]

Investment also shapes water supply, and for some people it matters more than cooperation. Ethiopia withdraws only 9% of its internal freshwater, yet just 53% of its people have at least basic drinking water, compared with 97% in Egypt. [E] This suggests economic water scarcity, as a lack of infrastructure limits access more than the actions of neighbouring countries. [E] A treaty would do little for a rural household with no water supply, so the view is at its weakest here. [Ap] Technology offers Egypt another route, as the Bahr El-Baqar plant, opened in 2021, can treat about 5.6 million m³ of water a day for reuse. [KU] That is about 2 billion m³ a year, which is useful but far below Egypt's 55.5 billion m³ share of the Nile, so technology reduces its dependence without removing it. [Ap] Importing food also reduces the water that Egypt has to find at home, although this exposes it to global prices, which links its water supply to globalisation. [Ap]

Figure 1 needs careful use. Its withdrawal figures are repeated for every year from 2017 to 2022, so they may not show recent demand. [E] Measuring only internal freshwater leaves out rivers flowing in from other countries, so the very high figures for Egypt and Sudan show dependence on those rivers, not total use beyond their supply. [E] National averages also hide differences between cities and rural areas. [E] The table gives no evidence on water quality or on how much water goes to farming, which is a major gap for countries that rely on irrigation. [E] It is therefore strong enough to show broad contrasts, but not to measure exactly how secure each country is. [E]

Climate change adds further uncertainty, as projections for future Nile flow disagree, although greater variation from year to year is expected. [KU] This strengthens the case for cooperation, because agreed rules for releasing water from the GERD would matter most during droughts. [Ap] However, it also means that no agreement can promise a fixed supply, so any treaty may need to share risk rather than set volumes. [Ap]

Overall, cooperation is the most important factor for Egypt and Sudan in the short term, because no other option can replace upstream flow at this scale. [Ap] By 2050, population growth could matter just as much, and in Ethiopia investment already matters more. [Ap] The view is therefore only partly correct, because cooperation is necessary for shared water security but it is not enough on its own. [Ap] This judgement is limited by data that is dated and national in scale, so recent local evidence could change the weight given to each factor. [E]

[24 marks]

Mark allocation

This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark.

  • [KU] shows knowledge and understanding (AO1, 4 marks)

  • [Ap] shows application through connections, interpretation and conclusion (AO2, 12 marks)

  • [E] shows judgement of data and evidence, and connections to ideas from across the course (AO3, 8 marks)

Commentary

This answer reaches Level 4 because it keeps one line of reasoning and keeps judging its evidence:

  • Paragraph 1: gives a clear position on "most important factor"

  • Paragraph 2: gives the strongest evidence for the view

  • Paragraph 3: shows the limits of cooperation, using players and their attitudes

  • Paragraphs 4 and 5: challenge the view with population growth, investment and technology, and qualify the evidence

  • Paragraph 6: judges the value and reliability of Figure 1

  • Paragraph 7: links to climate change and shows that the future is uncertain

  • Paragraph 8: reaches a qualified judgement that varies by country and timescale

Common errors

Common errors that hold essays below the top level include:

  • Misreading a table, such as treating one year's data as a long-term trend

  • Evaluating each strategy or factor in turn, without answering the view

  • Treating every country in the question as if it faces the same problem

  • Leaving out judgements on the data, because this strand is easy to forget

Alternative content

The answer above is just one example of a response to this question. Other information that could be used in the answer includes:

  • Water sharing frameworks such as the UN Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) Water Convention

  • Recycling and desalination in Singapore

  • The Mekong as a comparison for managing a trans-boundary river

  • The role of outside players such as the World Bank

Step 5: applying the steps to Question 5

  • Question 5 has the same structure, with less time and a narrower set of resources

  • This paragraph uses Figure 1 to answer an 18-mark question: "Evaluate the view that physical water scarcity is the main cause of water insecurity in the Nile basin."

Worked Example

Evaluate the view that physical water scarcity is the main cause of water insecurity in the Nile basin.

[18 marks]

Model paragraph:

Figure 1 shows that Sudan's withdrawals are 673% of its internal freshwater, but only 63% of its people have at least basic drinking water. [E] Physical scarcity alone cannot explain this, because Egypt's withdrawals are far higher and 97% of its people have this access. [Ap] Sudan's lower access suggests that economic water scarcity also plays a large part, as water can only reach people where there is money for infrastructure. [KU] The view is therefore too narrow, although the 2022 data comes from before the conflict that began in 2023, so it may overstate access today. [E]

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Make sure that every word in the question gets some attention. Terms such as "future" and "sustainable" can be read in several ways, so say which meaning you are using.

Leave time for a conclusion that returns to the question. Your first and last paragraphs together should show the direction of your argument and where it ended up.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Bridgette Barrett

Author: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.

Alistair Marjot

Reviewer: Alistair Marjot

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Alistair graduated from Oxford University with a degree in Biological Sciences. He has taught GCSE/IGCSE Biology, as well as Biology and Environmental Systems & Societies for the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme. While teaching in Oxford, Alistair completed his MA Education as Head of Department for Environmental Systems & Societies. Alistair has continued to pursue his interests in ecology and environmental science, recently gaining an MSc in Wildlife Biology & Conservation with Edinburgh Napier University.