How to Answer a Paper 3 8-Mark Question (Edexcel A Level Geography): Revision Note

Exam code: 9GE0

Bridgette Barrett

Written by: Bridgette Barrett

Reviewed by: Alistair Marjot

Updated on

What is a Paper 3 8-mark question?

  • The Paper 3 8-mark question, often called an 8-marker, is not the same question as the 8-mark on Papers 1 and 2

  • It asks you to analyse data and evidence from the Resource Booklet, not just explain what you know

  • You will answer two, as Question 3 and Question 4

    • Together they carry 16 of the 70 marks on Paper 3 (23%)

  • You have about 14 minutes for each one, with named figures from Section A and your own knowledge to work with

The question at a glance

Feature

Paper 3 8-mark

Papers 1 and 2 8-mark

Command word

Analyse

Explain

What you use

Figures in Section A and your own knowledge

Your own knowledge

Suggested time

about 14 minutes, including planning

about 10 minutes

Suggested length

about 270–300 words

about 210–230 words

Assessment objective 1

4 marks

8 marks

Assessment objective 3

4 marks

0 marks

Level bands

1–3, 4–6, 7–8

1–2, 3–5, 6–8

Command words and assessment objectives

  • The command word is always "analyse", which means using geographical skills to investigate an issue by breaking it down into parts and making logical, evidence-based connections between them

  • Past paper questions include:

    • “Analyse the role of global institutions in managing economic and political relations in the post-war world (1945 – present).” (Paper 3, June 2025)

    • “Analyse the evidence that the people of Haiti face greater economic and social challenges than their neighbours.” (Paper 3, June 2024)

    • “Analyse the variations in European forest coverage.” (Paper 3, June 2023)

    • “Analyse the similarities and differences in the locations and sizes of SIDS.” (Paper 3, June 2022)

  • The question tests two assessment objectives (AOs):

    • AO1 (4 marks): what you know, meaning knowledge and understanding of geographical ideas, places and processes

    • AO3 (4 marks): what you can do with data and evidence, meaning investigating the question and analysing the evidence

  • The marks are split equally, so you need the booklet and your own knowledge in almost every paragraph

How much should I write?

  • The suggested time and length take off the 15-minute read at the start of the paper

  • The number of answer lines on the paper is a useful guide to length, as it is matched to the marks

How is a Paper 3 8-mark question marked?

  • This is a levelled response question, so each point you make doesn't automatically earn a mark

  • The examiner reads your whole answer and decides which level it best fits

  • The examiner then places it within that level's mark range

The three levels

Level 3 (7–8 marks)

  • Accurate and relevant knowledge and understanding throughout

  • A critical investigation of the question, giving a coherent analysis of data and evidence, with logical connections to relevant geographical ideas

Level 2 (4–6 marks)

  • Knowledge and understanding that is mostly relevant but may include some inaccuracies

  • A critical investigation of the question, giving an analysis of data and evidence, with some logical connections to geographical ideas that are mostly relevant

Level 1 (1–3 marks)

  • Isolated elements of knowledge and understanding, some of which may be inaccurate or irrelevant

  • An investigation of the question that gives a limited analysis of data and evidence, with few connections to geographical ideas

What separates Level 2 from Level 3?

  • Level 2 answers select suitable information from the booklet, but they mostly restate it or add a comment with no support

  • Level 3 answers blend each piece of evidence with an idea from your course, so that the data helps to explain the pattern

  • Level 3 answers stay on the exact focus of the question, such as "differences" or "relationship"

  • An answer doesn't have to be flawless to get full marks, as long as it meets the Level 3 description

How to answer a Paper 3 8-mark question

Step 1

  • Read the question carefully and highlight the command word

"Study Figure 1. Analyse the differences in water security between Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan."

  • "Analyse" means that you need to break the pattern down and explain the connections, not only describe the figure

Step 2

  • Highlight the key words, then look at the figure the question names

"Analyse the differences in water security between Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan."

  • In this example, your answer must:

    • compare all three countries, using Figure 1 in the Worked Example below

    • use more than one column of the table

    • add your own knowledge, such as the difference between physical and economic water scarcity

Step 3

  • Spend about 2 minutes writing a short plan

  • Group the data into a few patterns, rather than working through the table row by row

  • A Paper 3 8-marker structure for this question could be:

    • first pattern: physical supply, with a link to trans-boundary water

    • second pattern: access to drinking water, with a link to economic water scarcity

    • limits of the data: what the figure can't show

Step 4

  • Write your answer, starting with the idea that links the patterns

  • Use your own words for the data, then show what it means:

    • Copied from the figure: "Ethiopia withdraws 9% of its internal freshwater and 53% of its people have at least basic drinking water"

    • Blended with knowledge: "Ethiopia withdraws only 9% of its internal freshwater, yet just 53% of its people have at least basic drinking water, which suggests economic water scarcity"

  • Use linking words such as "however" and "although" to show that the pattern isn't simple

What if?

  • You know little about the place: use the figure for the detail and bring in an idea from your course, as you aren't expected to have studied the place

  • Your answer has turned into a list of data: add a sentence starting "This suggests that" and link it to a course idea

  • One country doesn't fit the pattern: say so, as a clear exception is part of analysing the data

Worked Example

Study Figure 1.

Figure 1: Water in three Nile basin countries, 2022

Country

Population (millions)

Renewable internal freshwater per person (m³)

Water withdrawals as a percentage of internal freshwater (%)

People with at least basic drinking water (%)

Egypt

113

9

7,750

97

Ethiopia

125

973

9

53

Sudan

49

81

673

63

Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators. Internal freshwater excludes rivers flowing in from other countries. Withdrawal figures are the same for every year from 2017 to 2022.

Analyse the differences in water security between Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan.

[8 marks]

Model answer:

Water security means reliable access to enough safe water, and Figure 1 suggests that the three countries face different kinds of insecurity. [KU] Egypt has only 9 m³ of renewable internal freshwater per person, compared with 81 m³ in Sudan and 973 m³ in Ethiopia. [E] All three are below the water scarcity threshold of 1,000 m³ per person per year, but the comparison is misleading because it leaves out rivers flowing in from other countries. [KU] Egypt's withdrawals are 7,750% of its internal freshwater, which shows that it depends heavily on water from upstream. [E] Most of the Nile's flow starts in the Ethiopian highlands, so Egypt's scarcity is also a trans-boundary risk. [KU]

Access to drinking water shows a different pattern. Egypt has the highest access at 97%, despite having the smallest internal supply. [E] This may reflect its long investment in irrigation and water treatment along the Nile. [KU] Ethiopia withdraws only 9% of its internal freshwater, yet just 53% of its people have at least basic drinking water, which suggests economic water scarcity, where water exists but money and infrastructure limit access. [KU] Sudan shows parts of both problems, with withdrawals of 673% and access of 63%. [E] Conflict can also damage water infrastructure, so access depends on stability as well as supply. [KU]

However, these national figures hide important differences. Access to water is often lower in rural areas than in cities, so Ethiopia's 53% is unlikely to apply evenly across the country. [KU] The withdrawal figures are repeated from 2017 to 2022, so they may not reflect recent demand. [E] The table also shows nothing about water quality or reliability. [E] Overall, Egypt's insecurity comes mainly from dependence on an outside source and Ethiopia's from lack of access, while Sudan faces both, although the data can only show broad differences. [E]

[8 marks]

Mark allocation

This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark.

  • [KU] shows knowledge and understanding (AO1, 4 marks)

  • [E] shows analysis of data and evidence (AO3, 4 marks)

Commentary

This answer reaches Level 3 because the data and the course ideas support each other throughout:

  • Paragraph 1: breaks down physical supply and questions what the measure leaves out

  • Paragraph 2: finds a second pattern in the data, then explains it with economic water scarcity

  • Paragraph 3: identifies the limits of the data and pulls the differences together

Common errors

Common errors that hold answers below the top level include:

  • Telling the story of the figures in the order they appear

  • Writing about each country separately, with no comparison

  • Writing a general answer on water scarcity with little use of the data

  • Treating all the countries as if they share one problem

Alternative content

The answer above is just one example of a response to this question. Other information that could be used in the answer includes:

  • Reasons for rapid population growth and rising demand

  • The impact of climate variability on rainfall in the Ethiopian highlands

  • The role of water treatment and reuse in Egypt

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Don't copy out the question, as this uses up your 14 minutes without gaining anything. Start with your first point, using the key words from the question so that your focus is clear.

Add at least one example of your own to the material in the booklet. A short, relevant place example shows that you are using your wider course rather than relying only on the figures.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Bridgette Barrett

Author: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.

Alistair Marjot

Reviewer: Alistair Marjot

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Alistair graduated from Oxford University with a degree in Biological Sciences. He has taught GCSE/IGCSE Biology, as well as Biology and Environmental Systems & Societies for the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme. While teaching in Oxford, Alistair completed his MA Education as Head of Department for Environmental Systems & Societies. Alistair has continued to pursue his interests in ecology and environmental science, recently gaining an MSc in Wildlife Biology & Conservation with Edinburgh Napier University.