How to Answer a 20-Mark Question (Edexcel A Level Geography): Revision Note

Exam code: 9GE0

Bridgette Barrett

Written by: Bridgette Barrett

Reviewed by: Alistair Marjot

Updated on

What is a 20-mark question?

  • The 20-mark question, often called a 20-marker, is the extended essay in Sections B and C of Paper 1 and Paper 2

  • You will answer two on each paper

    • These essays carry 40 of the 105 marks on each paper (38%)

  • You have about 26 minutes to plan and write each one, with no figure to interpret, so your own knowledge and argument provide the evidence

The question at a glance

Feature

Detail

Marks

20

Where it appears

Sections B and C of Paper 1 and Paper 2

Suggested time

about 26 minutes, including planning

Suggested length

about 510–570 words

Assessment objective 1

5 marks

Assessment objective 2

15 marks

Command words and assessment objectives

  • The command word is always "evaluate", which means measuring the value or success of something and ending with a balanced, substantiated judgement

  • Past paper questions include:

    • “Evaluate the view that global agreements are essential in order to reduce further planetary warming.” (Paper 1, June 2025)

    • “Evaluate the view that the higher the level of economic development the greater the consequences of coastal flooding.” (Paper 1, June 2024)

    • “Evaluate the view that human rights are under threat in many countries.” (Paper 2, June 2025)

    • “Evaluate the extent to which past and present connections shape the economic and social characteristics of your chosen place.” (Paper 2, June 2024)

  • The question tests two assessment objectives (AOs):

    • AO1 (5 marks): what you know, meaning knowledge and understanding of geographical ideas, places and processes

    • AO2 (15 marks): what you do with it, meaning applying that knowledge to make connections, interpret evidence and reach a conclusion

  • Three-quarters of the marks are for AO2, so a learned case study can't carry the essay on its own

How much should I write?

  • Writing much more than the suggested length takes time from your other questions

  • Develop a few points fully rather than covering many points briefly

How is a 20-mark question marked?

  • This is a levelled response question, so each point you make doesn't automatically earn a mark

  • The examiner reads your whole essay and decides which level it best fits

  • The examiner then places it within that level's mark range

  • An essay that only shows knowledge, with no application, can gain no more than 5 marks

The four levels

Level 4 (16–20 marks)

  • Accurate and relevant knowledge and understanding throughout

  • Fully logical and relevant connections between ideas

  • A full and coherent interpretation, supported by evidence

  • A rational, substantiated conclusion, fully supported by a balanced argument

Level 3 (11–15 marks)

  • Mostly relevant and accurate knowledge and understanding

  • Some logical and relevant connections between ideas

  • A partial but coherent interpretation, supported by some evidence

  • A conclusion largely supported by an argument that may be unbalanced or only partly coherent

Level 2 (6–10 marks)

  • Knowledge and understanding that is occasionally relevant and may include some inaccuracies

  • Limited but logical connections between ideas

  • A partial interpretation, with some evidence but limited coherence

  • A conclusion partly supported by an unbalanced argument with limited coherence

Level 1 (1–5 marks)

  • Isolated knowledge and understanding, some of which may be inaccurate or irrelevant

  • Limited and rarely logical connections between ideas

  • An interpretation with limited coherence and little support from evidence

  • An unsupported or generic conclusion, from an argument that is unbalanced or lacks coherence

What separates Level 3 from Level 4?

  • Level 3 essays make clear points, but the interpretation is only partial and one side of the argument may dominate

  • Level 4 essays stay balanced and connect each piece of evidence to the view in the question

  • The conclusion then gives a clear judgement, with a key piece of evidence from the essay to support it

  • An essay doesn't have to be perfect to get full marks, as long as it stays coherent and relevant and keeps evaluating

How to answer a 20-mark question

Step 1

  • Read the question carefully and highlight the command word

"Evaluate the view that physical geography is the main factor affecting a country's energy security."

  • "Evaluate the view" means that you need to weigh up evidence for and against the view, then reach a judgement

Step 2

  • Highlight the key words

"Evaluate the view that physical geography is the main factor affecting a country's energy security."

  • In this example, your essay must:

    • show how physical geography affects energy security

    • compare it with at least one other factor

    • use named countries as evidence

Step 3

  • Spend about 3 minutes writing a short plan

  • Decide your judgement first, so that every paragraph can support it

  • A 20-marker structure for this question could be:

    • opening position: physical geography sets the options, but it isn't the main factor

    • argument for: the mismatch between supply and demand, using Germany

    • argument against: technology, using the USA

    • argument against: political choices, using France and Germany

    • further factor: cost and level of development

    • link back: why renewables still depend on physical geography

    • conclusion: a judgement that returns to "main factor"

Step 4

  • Write your essay, opening with a clear position on the question

  • Give each paragraph one main idea that supports or challenges your position

  • Support each point with named, specific evidence

  • Finish each paragraph by explaining what the evidence means for the question:

    • Knowledge only: "In 2019, the USA exported more energy than it imported for the first time since 1952"

    • Knowledge and argument: "The shale was already there, so technology rather than geology changed the USA's position"

  • Finish with a judgement that draws together the points you have already made

What if?

  • You're running out of time: write a short judgement that answers the question, then move on so that your next essay gets its full share of time

  • You can't remember a figure: use a rounded figure you're sure of or a different accurate detail, because the top level rewards accurate knowledge

  • Your case study only partly fits: use the parts that answer the question, and add a second example for the rest (how to use case studies and place knowledge)

Worked Example

Evaluate the view that physical geography is the main factor affecting a country's energy security.

[20 marks]

Model answer:

Physical geography is the starting point for energy security because it decides which resources a country can reach, but it is not the main factor. [Ap] How far a country can use those resources, and how safely it can import what it lacks, depends more on technology and political choices. [Ap]

Energy security means having reliable, affordable access to enough energy. [KU] Conventional fossil fuels are unevenly distributed, which creates a mismatch between where they are found and where demand is highest. [KU] Germany shows the risk of this mismatch, as about 55% of its gas came from Russia before 2022, and deliveries through the Nord Stream pipeline stopped that year. [KU] Limited domestic gas reserves left Germany exposed, so physical geography does shape the risks that a country faces. [Ap] The risk came from the route as well as the source, because pipelines tied Germany to one main supplier. [Ap]

However, the USA shows that resources only matter once they can be used. Fracking and horizontal drilling opened up its shale oil and gas, and in 2019 it exported more energy than it imported for the first time since 1952. [KU] The shale was already there, so technology rather than geology changed the USA's position. [Ap] This is strong evidence against the view, because the same physical geography gave very different levels of security over time. [Ap] Yet shale is itself a physical resource, so technology worked with geography rather than replacing it. [Ap]

Political choices can also outweigh a lack of resources. France has few fossil fuels and closed its last uranium mine in 2001, yet nuclear power generates about two-thirds of its electricity after a government programme that began in the 1970s. [KU] This suggests that policy can reduce reliance on imported fossil fuels, although France still depends on imported uranium, so it has changed its dependency rather than removed it. [Ap] Germany made the opposite choice and closed its last nuclear reactors in 2023. [KU] Two neighbours that both rely on imported oil and gas therefore took different pathways, which shows the importance of public perception and government priorities. [Ap]

Cost and level of development also matter. Germany opened its first liquefied natural gas terminal at Wilhelmshaven in late 2022, replacing part of its lost pipeline supply within a year. [KU] The gas crisis therefore came from a political disruption to an energy pathway, and wealth helped Germany to respond. [Ap] A lower-income country may not be able to pay for such a rapid change, so its options are narrower even if its physical geography is similar. [Ap]

Physical geography does not disappear as countries move away from fossil fuels. Wind, solar and hydroelectric power all depend on local conditions, so it continues to influence which alternatives are realistic. [Ap] Its effect is therefore long-lasting, but it still works through decisions about investment and technology. [Ap]

Overall, physical geography is not the main factor, because the USA and France both changed their energy position without any change in their physical resources. [Ap] It sets the options and the risks, especially for countries that lack fossil fuels. [Ap] Technology and political decisions matter more because they decide which options are used, although this depends on a country being able to afford them. [Ap]

[20 marks]

Mark allocation

This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark.

  • [KU] shows knowledge and understanding (AO1, 5 marks)

  • [Ap] shows application through connections, interpretation and conclusion (AO2, 15 marks)

Commentary

This answer reaches Level 4 because it keeps one line of reasoning throughout:

  • Paragraph 1: gives a clear position on "main factor"

  • Paragraph 2: gives the strongest evidence for the view

  • Paragraphs 3 and 4: challenge the view with technology and political choices, using named countries

  • Paragraph 5: adds cost and level of development

  • Paragraph 6: shows why physical geography still matters, which keeps the argument balanced

  • Paragraph 7: reaches a qualified judgement without adding new evidence

Common errors

Common errors that hold essays below the top level include:

  • Describing a country's energy mix without linking it to "main factor"

  • Writing only about physical geography, or only about other factors

  • Forcing one learned case study onto a question it doesn't fit

  • Ignoring a key word such as "main" or "always"

  • Ending with a summary rather than a judgement

Alternative content

The answer above is just one example of a response to this question. Other information that could be used in the answer includes:

  • The role of players such as OPEC and transnational corporations

  • The UK's changing energy mix

  • Costs and benefits of unconventional fossil fuels, such as Canadian tar sands

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Absolute words such as "always" and "main" are there to be challenged, so build your essay around them. Define any key term that the argument depends on in your opening, then return to it in your conclusion.

Your conclusion should be a logical result of your argument. Back it up with one key piece of evidence that you have already used, rather than adding anything new.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Bridgette Barrett

Author: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.

Alistair Marjot

Reviewer: Alistair Marjot

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Alistair graduated from Oxford University with a degree in Biological Sciences. He has taught GCSE/IGCSE Biology, as well as Biology and Environmental Systems & Societies for the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme. While teaching in Oxford, Alistair completed his MA Education as Head of Department for Environmental Systems & Societies. Alistair has continued to pursue his interests in ecology and environmental science, recently gaining an MSc in Wildlife Biology & Conservation with Edinburgh Napier University.