How to Answer a 12-Mark Question (Edexcel A Level Geography): Revision Note

Exam code: 9GE0

Bridgette Barrett

Written by: Bridgette Barrett

Reviewed by: Alistair Marjot

Updated on

What is a 12-mark question?

  • The 12-mark question, often called a 12-marker, asks you to judge how important something is

  • You will answer two on each of Paper 1 and Paper 2

    • These questions carry 24 of the 105 marks on each paper (23%)

  • You have about 15 minutes for each one, usually with no figure, so your own knowledge provides the evidence

The question at a glance

Feature

Detail

Marks

12

Where it appears

Paper 1 Question 1(b) and Question 4(d), and Paper 2 Question 1(b) and Question 2(b)

Suggested time

about 15 minutes, including planning

Suggested length

about 310–340 words

Assessment objective 1

3 marks

Assessment objective 2

9 marks

Command words and assessment objectives

  • The command word is "assess", which means using evidence to decide the relative significance of something, with balanced consideration of all the factors

  • Past paper questions include:

    • “Assess the importance of community preparedness in influencing the vulnerability of people to tectonic hazards.” (Paper 1, June 2025)

    • “Assess the impact of increasing ocean acidification on people and marine ecosystems.” (Paper 1, June 2024)

    • “Assess the reasons why globalisation often increases income inequality within countries.” (Paper 2, June 2025)

    • “Assess the importance of hard power in maintaining the status of superpowers.” (Paper 2, June 2023)

  • The question tests two assessment objectives (AOs):

    • AO1 (3 marks): what you know, meaning knowledge and understanding of geographical ideas, places and processes

    • AO2 (9 marks): what you do with it, meaning applying that knowledge to make connections, interpret evidence and judge significance

Other forms of this question

  • A 12-mark question can come with figures, with the same AO split and the same levels

  • In June 2023, Paper 1 Question 4(d) told students to study Figures 4b and 4c, which showed two river catchments and their hydrographs:

  • “Assess the extent to which land use affects the shape of these storm hydrographs.” (Paper 1, June 2023)

  • In this form, compare values from the figures, such as the difference in lag time, and look for other factors that the figures show

How is a 12-mark question marked?

  • This is a levelled response question, so each point you make doesn't automatically earn a mark

  • The examiner reads your whole answer and decides which level it best fits

  • The examiner then places it within that level's mark range

  • An answer that only shows knowledge, with no application, can gain no more than 3 marks:

    • Level 1 knowledge: 1 mark

    • Level 2 knowledge: 2 marks

    • Level 3 knowledge: 3 marks

The three levels

Level 3 (9–12 marks)

  • Accurate and relevant knowledge and understanding throughout

  • Logical and relevant connections between ideas

  • A full and coherent interpretation that is relevant and supported by evidence

  • Supported judgements about the significance of factors throughout, leading to a balanced and coherent argument

Level 2 (5–8 marks)

  • Mostly relevant knowledge and understanding, which may include some inaccuracies

  • Some logical and relevant connections between ideas

  • A partial but coherent interpretation that is mostly relevant and supported by evidence

  • Judgements about the significance of some factors, in an argument that may be unbalanced or partially coherent

Level 1 (1–4 marks)

  • Isolated knowledge and understanding, some of which may be inaccurate or irrelevant

  • Limited logical connections between ideas

  • An interpretation with limited relevance or support

  • Unsupported or generic judgements about the significance of few factors, in an argument that is unbalanced or lacks coherence

What separates Level 2 from Level 3?

  • Level 2 answers make some judgements, but often describe evidence first and judge it only at the end

  • Level 3 answers judge each factor as they go, usually in the final sentence of each paragraph

  • The grid has no separate strand for a conclusion, unlike a 20-mark question, but a short closing judgement draws your assessment together

  • An answer doesn't have to be perfect to get full marks, as long as your assessment and judgement run throughout

How to answer a 12-mark question

Step 1

  • Read the question carefully and highlight the command word

"Assess the importance of governance in reducing the impacts of tectonic hazards."

  • "Assess the importance" means that you need to weigh this factor against others and say how much it matters

Step 2

  • Highlight the key words

"Assess the importance of governance in reducing the impacts of tectonic hazards."

  • In this example, your answer must:

    • define governance

    • judge how far governance reduces impacts

    • compare it with at least one other factor

    • use more than one type of tectonic hazard, if you can

Step 3

  • Spend about 2 minutes writing a short plan

  • Decide your overall judgement first, so that each paragraph can support it

  • A 12-marker structure for this question could be:

    • opening: a definition and your position

    • evidence for: building codes, using Chile and Haiti

    • evidence for: enforcement, using Türkiye

    • evidence for: forecasting and evacuation, using Mount Pinatubo

    • limit: scale of the event, using Japan

    • closing judgement: how important, and when

Step 4

  • Open with your definition and position

  • Finish each paragraph by saying what the evidence means for the question:

    • Knowledge only: "In 2010, Chile experienced a magnitude 8.8 earthquake that killed about 500 people"

    • Knowledge and assessment: "Chile's much stronger earthquake (8.8 magnitude) caused far fewer deaths (500 people), which suggests that enforced building codes reduced the impact"

  • End with one or two sentences that make your judgement clear, without adding new evidence

What if?

  • Your examples are all earthquakes, but the question is on volcanoes: use a framework such as the hazard management cycle, and apply it to what you know about eruptions

  • You're running out of time: write one sentence that says which factor matters most and why, then move on

Worked Example

Assess the importance of governance in reducing the impacts of tectonic hazards.

[12 marks]

Model answer:

Governance means how well governments make and enforce decisions, including building codes and evacuation plans. [KU] It is the most important factor that people can control, although the physical event limits what it can achieve. [Ap]

Building codes show its importance clearly. In 2010, a magnitude 8.8 earthquake in Chile killed about 500 people, while a magnitude 7.0 earthquake in Haiti killed well over 100,000. [KU] Chile's much stronger earthquake caused far fewer deaths, which suggests that enforced building codes reduced the impact. [Ap] The comparison is not perfect, because Haiti's earthquake was shallow and close to its capital, so physical factors also played a part. [Ap]

Rules only help if they are enforced. Türkiye had modern codes before the magnitude 7.8 earthquake of 2023, which killed over 50,000 people there, but amnesties had allowed builders to pay fines instead of meeting them. [KU] This is strong evidence for the importance of governance, because a middle-income country remained vulnerable when regulation failed. [Ap] It also suggests that wealth alone does not reduce impacts. [Ap]

Governance can also save lives where hazards can be forecast. Before Mount Pinatubo erupted in the Philippines in 1991, scientists and officials organised evacuations that saved at least 5,000 lives. [KU] The effect depends on the hazard type, however, because earthquakes cannot be forecast in this way, so building standards matter more for them. [Ap]

Governance has limits in the largest events. Japan is among the best-prepared countries, yet in 2011 the tsunami overtopped seawalls and about 18,000 people died or went missing. [KU] Magnitude and tsunami height exceeded what planning had allowed for, so governance reduced the impacts rather than preventing them. [Ap]

Overall, governance is highly important, because Chile, Türkiye and the Philippines all show that decisions change how many people die. [Ap] It matters most in moderate events, or where a warning is possible. [Ap] In the largest events, the scale of the hazard becomes the more significant factor, however good the planning. [Ap]

[12 marks]

Mark allocation

This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark.

  • [KU] shows knowledge and understanding (AO1, 3 marks)

  • [Ap] shows application through connections, interpretation and judgement (AO2, 9 marks)

Commentary

This answer reaches Level 3 because it judges significance throughout:

  • Paragraph 1: defines the key term and gives a clear position

  • Paragraph 2: compares two earthquakes, and questions its own comparison

  • Paragraph 3: shows that enforcement matters, and links it to development

  • Paragraph 4: widens the evidence to a volcanic hazard

  • Paragraph 5: gives the main limit, which keeps the argument balanced

  • Paragraph 6: draws the judgements together, without adding new evidence

Common errors

Common errors that hold answers below the top level include:

  • Learning two case studies and fitting them to any question

  • Describing a problem, such as low wages, without linking it to the factor in the question

  • Writing about only one side of the argument

  • Taking a key word such as "preparedness" no further than one obvious example

Alternative content

The answer above is just one example of a response to this question. Other information that could be used in the answer includes:

  • Corruption and its effect on emergency response

  • Land-use zoning and hazard-resistant design

  • The role of communities, non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and insurers

  • Other factors, such as population density and level of development

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Use the question's key words again in your final judgement. It keeps your whole answer focused on the question, and it shows that you have assessed the term that was set.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Bridgette Barrett

Author: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.

Alistair Marjot

Reviewer: Alistair Marjot

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Alistair graduated from Oxford University with a degree in Biological Sciences. He has taught GCSE/IGCSE Biology, as well as Biology and Environmental Systems & Societies for the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme. While teaching in Oxford, Alistair completed his MA Education as Head of Department for Environmental Systems & Societies. Alistair has continued to pursue his interests in ecology and environmental science, recently gaining an MSc in Wildlife Biology & Conservation with Edinburgh Napier University.