How to Use Case Studies & Place Knowledge (Edexcel A Level Geography): Revision Note
Exam code: 9GE0
Why do case studies matter?
Case studies and place knowledge give you the named, specific evidence that higher-level answers need
They matter most in the 8-mark, 12-mark and 20-mark questions on Paper 1 and Paper 2
They can also lift a 6-mark explain question, and some 6-mark questions ask directly about your chosen places
You don't need to build every essay around a case study, because most of the marks on a 20-mark question are for what you do with your knowledge
Paper 3 is different, because the Resource Booklet gives you the issue and the evidence
What does the question ask for?
Check the wording of the question, because it tells you which places to use:
Wording | Past paper example | What to do |
|---|---|---|
Your chosen place | “Evaluate the extent to which past and present connections shape the economic and social characteristics of your chosen place.” (Paper 2, June 2024) | choose one of your two places, name it on the paper and stay with it |
Your two chosen places | “Explain the reasons for variation in the functions of your two chosen places.” (Paper 2, June 2023) | name your local place and your contrasting place on the paper, then use both |
One local place | “Explain the variations in the quality of the living environment within one local place you have studied.” (Paper 2, June 2022) | use your local place, and refer to specific locations within it |
Such as | “Explain how adaptation strategies, such as water conservation, may help communities cope with a changed climate.” (Paper 1, June 2023) | use the example given or any other that fits |
No place named | “Assess the importance of levels of development in understanding the impacts of tectonic hazards.” (Paper 1, June 2024) | choose the places that best answer the question, and use more than two |
Which case studies do I need?
The specification names many places, but very few of them are compulsory
Some content must be studied in a place context:
Where the specification suggests a place, you or your teacher can choose a similar suitable one instead
Some specification points that need a place context suggest no place, especially in Topic 8A, so the choice is open
Some content names a place or group directly, with no alternative offered, such as the UK in Topic 4 and the Middle East in Topic 7
You need all the compulsory topics, plus only the options that you study
Your examples should cover developed, emerging and developing economies, as questions are set across all three
Paper 1
Topic | What the specification requires | Places it suggests |
|---|---|---|
Topic 1: Tectonic Processes and Hazards (compulsory) | Contrasting locations and hazard events in developed, emerging and developing countries, profiles of earthquake, volcano and tsunami events, tectonic mega-disasters, a multiple-hazard zone | 2004 Asian tsunami, 2010 Eyjafjallajökull eruption in Iceland, 2011 Japanese tsunami, the Philippines |
Option 2A: Glaciated Landscapes and Change | Landscapes from areas inside and outside the UK, contrasting environments around the world | Tundra of northern Russia or northern Canada, Greenland Ice Sheet, Alpine valleys, Himalayan glaciers, Yosemite Valley |
Option 2B: Coastal Landscapes and Change | Landscapes from inside and outside the UK, coastal communities in developing and developed countries, policy conflicts in countries at different levels of development | Glamorgan Heritage Coast, Portland Bill to Selsey Bill, the Nile Delta or Guinea coastline or Californian coastline, Bangladesh or the Maldives, Happisburgh and Chattogram |
Topic 5: The Water Cycle and Water Insecurity (compulsory) | Water budgets by climate type, regimes from contrasting river basins, conflicts over trans-boundary water sources, integrated management of large rivers | Amazonia, tropical, temperate or polar examples, Yukon, Amazon, Indus, Sahelian or Australia drought, UK flood events 2007 or 2012, Nile or Mekong, water transfers in China, Singapore, Nile or Colorado |
Topic 6: The Carbon Cycle and Energy Security (compulsory) | National comparisons of energy access and consumption, energy pathways, unconventional fossil fuels | USA versus France, Russian gas to Europe, Canadian tar sands, USA fracking, Brazilian deep water oil, changing UK energy mix, biofuels in Brazil, Amazonian drought events, Arctic |
Paper 2
Topic | What the specification requires | Places it suggests |
|---|---|---|
Topic 3: Globalisation (compulsory) | Locations largely detached from globalisation, megacities, global hub cities and regions, deindustrialised regions in developed countries | China's 1978 Open Door Policy, North Korea or rural communities in Niger, China, India, Mumbai or Karachi, Singapore and London, UAE and Saudi Arabia, changing diets in Asia, Papua New Guinea, extreme nationalism in Europe, UK or Japan, First Nations in Canada, Transition towns, Paralympic movement, UK local authorities or Keep Britain Tidy |
Topic 7: Superpowers (compulsory) | British Empire, emerging countries including Brazil, Russia, India and China (BRIC) and other G20 members, Arctic oil and gas, China and African nations, the Middle East | China's "belt and road" policy, USA and China, South and East China Seas, Western Russia/Eastern Europe, China or India, USA and EU |
Option 4A: Regenerating Places | Your local place and one contrasting place, UK government policy, UK deindustrialised cities, a study of an urban place and a study of a rural place | Salford Quays, North Antrim coast, Palo Alto and Silicon Valley, the Rust Belt, USA, prime London real estate, London Olympics 2012, Powys Regeneration Partnership, Glasgow "Scotland with Style", "Brontë country", Kielder Forest |
Option 4B: Diverse Places | Your local place and one contrasting place, UK population and migration, a study of an urban living space and a study of a rural living space | Aik Saath in Slough, Lake District National Park Partnership, London and the south-east, the north-east of England, Victorian London, Hardy's "Wessex", Indian sub-continent and West Indies, East Europeans in Lincolnshire, Southall, Luton, Glasgow |
Option 8A: Health, Human Rights and Intervention | A comparison of an authoritarian and a democratic system, and contexts of your choice for human rights and military intervention | Sharia law or Bolivia under Evo Morales, UK or Brazil, Indigenous peoples in Australia, First Nations in Canada, Afghanistan, Australia, Bolivia, Haiti, Iraq, Oxfam or Christian Aid, oil in the Niger Delta or Dakota and Keystone XL pipeline, TNC land acquisitions in Ethiopia, Botswana or Ebola in West Africa, UN Women or UNICEF |
Option 8B: Migration, Identity and Sovereignty | Regional groupings such as the EU, and the US and UK operating independently of the UN | China, EU-Schengen, Singapore or Japan or Australia, migrants crossing the Mediterranean, regional movements in the UK, Mexico-US border, Iceland compared to Singapore, Iraq or Rwanda, Ukraine/Russia, Taiwan, British Raj in India, 1960s "wind of change" in Africa, Viet-Nam or Sudan, Bolivia or Ecuador, Iran, Congo, Jamaica, NAFTA/SEATO, Montreal Protocol, CITES, UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, Helsinki Water Convention, Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, Antarctic Treaty System, the English Countryside, EDF or Jaguar Land Rover, property in London, Catalonia or Scotland, Somalia |
Your local place and contrasting place
Shaping Places (Topic 4) is the one topic where you must study places of your own:
Local place: the place where you live or study
Contrasting place: one further place that clearly differs from it
Both should be a locality, a neighbourhood or a small community, either urban or rural
Whole cities and countries are usually too broad, and places that are too similar make differences hard to explain
For both places, learn:
how their characteristics and functions have changed
how past and present connections have shaped them
how they are represented in different forms
how continuity and change have influenced people's lives
The specification points on using evidence to judge the need for regeneration (Option 4A), or people's image of a place (Option 4B), apply to your chosen local place
How to use a case study well
Step 1
Build a case study bank before the exam, with more than two examples for each topic
A familiar pair, such as Haiti 2010 and Tohoku 2011, can't answer every tectonic question, so include volcanic events too
For each case study, learn:
the name and location
a few accurate figures, with dates
the processes or causes involved
the players and groups affected
one way in which it supports an argument, and one way in which it challenges it
Step 2
Choose your evidence to fit the question
"Evaluate the view that national and local decisions have been more important than global influences in changing your chosen place."
In this example, you need only the parts of your place study that show these influences
Leave a case study out if it doesn't fit, because a poor match pulls your answer away from the question
Step 3
Be specific about the place:
General: "The docks closed and the area later became offices"
Specific: "The docks closed in 1982, and the BBC began moving staff to MediaCityUK in 2011"
Step 4
Link every fact back to the question:
Fact only: "The docks closed in 1982"
Fact linked to the question: "The docks closed in 1982 because ships had outgrown the canal, which shows that global trade removed the area's main function"
Use words such as "therefore" or "this suggests" to show what the evidence means
Judge your evidence as you go, not only in your conclusion
What if?
You've forgotten a figure: use a rounded figure you're sure of or a different accurate detail
Your case study only partly fits: use the relevant parts, then add a second example or a general point for the rest
You've been retelling the history of a place: stop and add a sentence that says what the evidence means for the question
Worked Example
Evaluate the view that national and local decisions have been more important than global influences in changing your chosen place.
[20 marks]
Model paragraph:
Global influences started the change at Salford Quays, but national and local decisions shaped what replaced the docks. [Ap] Containerisation demanded larger ships than the Manchester Ship Canal could take, and the docks closed in 1982 with the loss of about 3,000 jobs. [KU] This shows that global trade removed the area's main function. [Ap] Salford City Council then bought most of the site within a year, and the BBC began moving staff to MediaCityUK in 2011. [KU] These decisions created a new media function, which suggests that they mattered more than global trade in deciding what the place became. [Ap] However, early reports suggested that few of the BBC's new jobs went to local people. [KU] Residents of neighbouring Ordsall may therefore have gained less than the new skyline suggests, so the importance of these decisions depends on whose experience is measured. [Ap]
Mark allocation
This is a levelled response question. Each valid point made in the answer does not automatically earn a mark. This paragraph is one part of a full essay, so it isn't marked on its own.
[KU] shows knowledge and understanding (assessment objective 1, AO1)
[Ap] shows application through connections, interpretation and conclusion (assessment objective 2, AO2)
Commentary
This paragraph shows how to use place knowledge at the top level:
Named detail: it names specific places, dates and organisations rather than "the docks" or "the government"
Link to the question: it sorts each change into global, national or local influences
Different groups: it asks who gained from the change
Evaluation: it judges the view within the paragraph rather than leaving it to the end
Common errors
Common errors when using case studies include:
Writing out everything you know about a place, whatever the question asks
Evaluating a regeneration scheme when the question is about connections
Using both of your chosen places when the question asks about only one
Stating your chosen places, then saying little about what makes them different
Alternative content
The paragraph above is just one example, as your place study will depend on what your class has studied. Other evidence that could be used in a similar paragraph includes:
Census data on employment or ethnicity
Index of Multiple Deprivation data
Oral accounts, social media and photographs that show how people experience and represent the place
Examiner Tips and Tricks
Name your place on the paper, then refer to specific streets, neighbourhoods or employers within it. This shows that you know the place, and it gives your points detail that a general answer can't match.
The strongest place answers often come from the area you know best, so make use of what you have seen and collected in your local place.
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?