How to Use the Paper 3 Resource Booklet (Edexcel A Level Geography): Revision Note
Exam code: 9GE0
What is the Paper 3 Resource Booklet?
The Resource Booklet sets out one geographical issue in a place-based context, using text, maps, tables and graphs that you haven't seen before
You are advised to spend the first 15 minutes of Paper 3 reading it
The booklet gives you the detail about the issue, and your course gives you the geographical ideas to use with it, so you don't need to have studied any place it covers
Papers 1 and 2 also have a Resource Booklet, but only Paper 3 is built around a single issue from start to finish
How the sections match the questions
Question | Marks | What to use | Suggested time |
|---|---|---|---|
Reading | 0 | The whole booklet | 15 minutes |
Question 1 | 4 | Your own knowledge, as no resource is named | about 7 minutes |
Question 2 | 8 | The table on the question paper | about 14 minutes |
Question 3 | 8 | The figures it names in Section A, plus your own knowledge | about 14 minutes |
Question 4 | 8 | The Figures it names in Section A, plus your own knowledge | about 14 minutes |
Question 5 | 18 | The resources in Section B, plus your own knowledge | about 31 minutes |
Question 6 | 24 | The whole booklet including Section C, plus your own knowledge | about 41 minutes |
These times are suggestions, based on the 120 minutes left after the read
They are rounded, so they add up to 136 minutes rather than exactly 135
Questions 5 and 6 carry 42 of the 70 marks (60%), so protect their time
Ideas from Section A can still help you plan Question 5, but take your evidence from Section B, as the question directs
Question 6 should be longer than Question 5, as it has more marks and needs the whole booklet
How to use the 15-minute read
Step 1
Read Questions 3 to 6 first, so that you know what to look for
Underline the key words in each one
Step 2
Read Section A with Questions 3 and 4 in mind, and mark the figures that each question names
Slow down for any table, map or graph that has no text with it, as you will have to work out its message yourself
Check the dates, units and scale of each figure
Step 3
Read Sections B and C with Questions 5 and 6 in mind
Write short notes in the margin as you go:
course ideas that link to the figure
a place from your own studies that compares with it
any weakness in the data
points where two figures seem to disagree
Step 4
Keep ideas from your Question 3 and 4 answers in mind, as they can help in Questions 5 and 6
Check that you have read Section C before you start Question 6, as the paper tells you to
What if?
You're still reading after 15 minutes: start writing anyway, then return to the section you missed when a question needs it
A figure makes no sense to you: use a different figure for your main point, then say what the confusing one seems to show and why you are unsure
You're behind when you reach Question 5: finish it with a short judgement and move on, because Question 6 has more marks
How to judge data and use the synoptic themes
Why judging data matters
Assessment objective 3 (AO3) is what you can do with data and evidence, and it carries 30 of the 70 marks on Paper 3
At the top level of Questions 5 and 6, you must make valid judgements about the value and reliability of data throughout your essay
The booklet can't include everything, so its data is partial and selective, and pointing out gaps can earn credit
Questions to ask of any resource
When: is the data old, or does it show only one year?
Who: who collected it, and could their purpose affect what it shows?
How many: is the sample large enough to support a general claim?
Where: does an average or a group label hide differences between places and people?
What measure: is it a percentage or a total, as a smaller percentage of a much larger economy can still be the larger amount?
What's missing: what else would you need to know before reaching a firm judgement?
Be specific about any weakness you find, and link it to the question:
Vague: "This data may not be reliable"
Specific: "This survey covers the clients of one company, so it can't support a claim about the whole country"
The three synoptic themes
The specification links Paper 3 to three synoptic themes
Use them as you read to find arguments that aren't printed in the booklet:
Players: who is involved in the issue, and why do some have more influence than others?
Attitudes and actions: why do attitudes to the issue vary, and how do those attitudes shape policies and strategies?
Futures and uncertainties: which approaches could be taken, such as business as usual, more sustainable strategies or radical alternatives, and why are the outcomes uncertain?
The themes also help when you plan an essay, because a question about one place or one solution usually has several players with different priorities, and an outcome that nobody can be sure of
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?