How to Answer 3-Mark & 4-Mark Questions (Edexcel A Level Geography): Revision Note

Exam code: 9GE0

Bridgette Barrett

Written by: Bridgette Barrett

Reviewed by: Alistair Marjot

Updated on

What are 3-mark and 4-mark questions?

  • These questions, often called 3-markers and 4-markers, are short explain questions where you develop a point into a chain of reasoning

  • You have about 4 minutes for a 3-marker, working from a resource, and about 5 minutes for a 4-marker on Paper 2, working from your own knowledge

  • You will answer:

    • one 3-marker on Paper 1 and one on Paper 2

    • one 4-marker on Paper 3

    • two 4-markers on Paper 2, in each series from June 2022 to June 2025, plus a 4-mark data part

The differences at a glance

Feature

3-mark question

4-mark question

Marks

3

4

Where it appears

Paper 1 Section C, and Paper 2 Section B

Paper 2 Sections A and C, and Paper 3 Question 1

Command word

Suggest, or explain on Paper 1

Explain

What you work from

A figure in the Resource Booklet

Your own knowledge

Assessment objective 1

2 marks

4 marks

Assessment objective 2

1 mark

0 marks

Suggested time

about 4 minutes

about 5 minutes on Paper 2, about 7 minutes on Paper 3

Suggested length

about 40–60 words

about 60–100 words

Command words and assessment objectives

  • The command words are:

    • "suggest": give a reasoned explanation of how or why something may occur, for an unfamiliar scenario

    • "explain": give a reasoned explanation of how or why something occurs

  • Past paper questions include:

    • “Suggest one possible impact of the changes shown on forest ecosystems.” (Paper 1, June 2024)

    • “Suggest one way the photographs show that regeneration has taken place in Lee Bank, Birmingham.” (Paper 2, June 2024)

    • “Explain one way superpower resource demands cause environmental damage.” (Paper 2, June 2024)

    • “Explain why transnational corporations (TNCs) benefit from globalisation.” (Paper 3, June 2024)

  • The questions test two assessment objectives (AOs):

    • AO1: what you know, meaning knowledge and understanding of geographical ideas, places and processes

    • AO2: what you do with it, meaning applying that knowledge, which on a 3-marker means using the resource

Other forms of 4-mark question

  • A 4-marker can ask you to compare two ideas, such as “Explain the differences between hazards and disasters.” (Paper 3, June 2022)

  • For this form, define one idea, make a clear distinction, then extend that distinction

How are 3-mark and 4-mark questions marked?

  • These questions are point marked, so there are no levels and each valid step in your chain earns a mark

3-mark questions

  • 1 mark (AO2): using the resource to identify your reason, impact or way

  • 2 marks (AO1): expanding that point with your own knowledge

  • Use data where the resource has it, but the link doesn't have to be a direct quote and can be an idea or example that the resource prompts

4-mark questions

  • "Explain one": 1 mark for the point and up to 3 marks for developing it

    • If you add a second reason, only the higher-scoring reason counts

  • "Explain why" or "Explain how": 1 mark for each point and 1 mark for each development

    • Schemes vary by question: the June 2025 Paper 3 scheme expects two developed points, whilst the June 2025 Paper 2 "Explain how" scheme and the June 2024 Paper 3 scheme start from one point developed three times

What separates a partial answer from full marks?

  • A partial answer stops after the first link, or says the same thing again in different words

  • A full-mark answer adds something new at each step and links the last step back to the question

  • Each linked step earns a mark, so a short, well-developed answer can reach full marks

How to answer 3-mark and 4-mark questions

Step 1

  • Read the question carefully and highlight the command word and the word that sets your route

"Suggest one reason for the difference in water stress between Egypt and Brazil."

[3 marks]

  • "One" means that you need to develop a single reason, not list several

Step 2

  • Highlight the key words

"Suggest one reason for the difference in water stress between Egypt and Brazil."

  • In this example, your answer must:

    • use the resource to show the difference

    • give one reason that explains why it exists

    • stay on water stress in these two countries

Step 3

  • Plan your chain in a few words before you write:

    • Point: what the resource shows

    • Development: why that happens

    • Further development: what that leads to

  • For a "why" or "how" question, plan two short chains instead

Step 4

  • Write your answer so that the resource data is part of your first reason, then use a linking phrase such as 'so' or 'which means that' to move it on at each step:

    • Resource only: "Egypt has a water stress level of 141.2%, compared with only 1.5% in Brazil"

    • Resource and development: "Egypt has an arid climate with very little rainfall, so it has only 8.9 m³ of internal renewable freshwater per person"

What if?

  • You've thought of a second reason on a "one" question: choose the reason you can explain furthest, and put your time into developing it

  • The resource is a photo and you aren't sure what it shows: pick one thing you can see, then link it to the idea in the question

  • Your chain runs out early: ask "so what?" about your last sentence, and write the effect that follows

Worked Example

Table 1: Water stress and freshwater resources in Egypt and Brazil, 2022

Country

Level of water stress: freshwater withdrawal as a proportion of available freshwater resources (%)

Renewable internal freshwater resources per person (m³)

Egypt

141.2

8.9

Brazil

1.5

26,917.9

Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators, using Food and Agriculture Organization data

(a) Study Table 1. Suggest one reason for the difference in water stress between Egypt and Brazil.

[3]

(b) Explain one reason why containerisation has increased global trade.

[4]

(c) Explain why superpowers are competing for influence in the Arctic.

[4]

[11 marks]

Answer:

(a)

Egypt has very little renewable freshwater of its own, only 8.9 m³ per person compared with 26,917.9 m³ in Brazil [1]. This is because Egypt has an arid climate with very little rainfall, so rainfall replaces very little water within the country each year [1]. Its farms, industries and growing cities therefore depend on the River Nile, which rises outside Egypt, and they use even more water than this supply provides by reusing drainage water and pumping groundwater, so water stress reaches 141.2% [1].

(b)

Containerisation has made it much quicker to move goods between countries [1]. Standard containers can be lifted directly between ships, trains and lorries, so ports can handle cargo faster with less labour [1]. This has helped to lower shipping costs, so it is cheaper for companies to make goods in one country and sell them in another [1]. This makes it profitable to split production across countries, so more components and finished goods cross borders [1].

(c)

The Arctic contains large reserves of oil and gas, and ownership of some areas is disputed [1]. Superpowers want to control these resources to secure their future energy supplies, especially as other reserves run down [1]. Retreating sea ice is also opening up new shipping routes [1]. These routes shorten journeys between Asia and Europe, so controlling them would give a country trade and military advantages [1].

Mark allocation

These are point-marked questions. Each [1] shows where a mark is earned.

  • Part (a): the first mark is AO2, for using data from Table 1 to identify a reason, and the other two marks are AO1

  • Parts (b) and (c): all 4 marks are AO1

Commentary

  • Part (a): the first sentence uses data from Table 1 to identify a reason, Egypt’s small freshwater resources, and the rest of the answer develops it. Quoting the two water stress figures on their own wouldn’t earn the AO2 mark, because it describes the table without giving a reason

  • Part (b): "one reason" means one chain, so each sentence builds on the one before and the last sentence returns to global trade

  • Part (c): "why" allows more than one reason, so this answer makes two points, resources and shipping routes, and develops each one once

Common errors

Common errors that hold answers back include:

  • Describing the resource without connecting it to the question

  • Ignoring the resource in a 3-marker

  • Writing general facts about the topic rather than answering the question's key word

  • Drifting into what happens next, when this no longer explains your first point

Alternative content

The answers above are just one example of a response to each part. Other information that could be used in the answers includes:

  • Part (a): Brazil's high rainfall and large river systems, or Egypt's high demand for irrigation water

  • Part (b): larger ships and the economies of scale they bring

  • Part (c): military presence in the Arctic, or disputes over who controls Arctic waters

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Choose a broad starting point, because it gives you more to develop. "Lower transport costs" leads to several linked ideas, while a single detail can leave you stuck after one sentence.

Don't rewrite the question or define every term first. Start with your point, so that your time goes on the steps that earn marks.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Bridgette Barrett

Author: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.

Alistair Marjot

Reviewer: Alistair Marjot

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Alistair graduated from Oxford University with a degree in Biological Sciences. He has taught GCSE/IGCSE Biology, as well as Biology and Environmental Systems & Societies for the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme. While teaching in Oxford, Alistair completed his MA Education as Head of Department for Environmental Systems & Societies. Alistair has continued to pursue his interests in ecology and environmental science, recently gaining an MSc in Wildlife Biology & Conservation with Edinburgh Napier University.