Equations with Transformed Trigonometric Functions (College Board AP® Precalculus): Revision Note

Roger B

Written by: Roger B

Reviewed by: Mark Curtis

Updated on

Equations with transformed trigonometric functions

What is a transformed trigonometric equation?

  • A transformed trigonometric equation is one in which the trigonometric function is applied to a more complex argument than just \theta

    • For example

      • sin open parentheses 2 x plus pi over 3 close parentheses equals 1 half comma    cos left parenthesis 3 x minus 1 right parenthesis equals negative 0.7 comma    tan open parentheses x over 2 close parentheses equals 1

    • The argument inside the trigonometric function is itself a function of the variable

    • Compare transformed sinusoidal functions like sin open parentheses b open parentheses theta plus c close parentheses close parentheses

  • Equations involving transformed arguments with the reciprocal trig functions (sec, csc, cot) or inverse trig functions (sin to the power of negative 1 end exponent, cos to the power of negative 1 end exponent, tan to the power of negative 1 end exponent)

    • can also be converted to this form

How can I solve a transformed trigonometric equation?

  • The most reliable approach is to

    • transform the solution interval to match the new variable

    • solve the simpler equation in the transformed interval

    • then convert all solutions back

  • Start by identifying the inner expression (the argument of the trigonometric function)

    • and setting it equal to a new variable u

      • E.g. if the equation is space sin open parentheses 2 x plus pi over 3 close parentheses equals 1 half

        • then let space u equals 2 x plus pi over 3

  • Next transform the original solution interval

    • into the corresponding interval for u

    • by applying the same operations to all parts of the inequality

      • E.g. if space sin open parentheses 2 x plus pi over 3 close parentheses equals 1 half is to be solved on the interval space 0 less or equal than x less or equal than 2 pi

        • 0 less or equal than x less or equal than 2 pi space rightwards double arrow space 0 less or equal than 2 x less or equal than 4 pi space rightwards double arrow space pi over 3 less or equal than open parentheses 2 x plus pi over 3 close parentheses less or equal than fraction numerator 13 pi over denominator 3 end fraction

        • So pi over 3 less or equal than u less or equal than fraction numerator 13 pi over denominator 3 end fraction is the transformed interval

    • Note that the transformed interval is often wider (or narrower) than the original interval

      • This is important because it determines how many solutions exist

  • Solve the simpler equation in the transformed interval

    • finding all solutions for u

      • E.g. sin u equals 1 half has the following solutions in open square brackets pi over 3 comma fraction numerator 13 pi over denominator 3 end fraction close square brackets

        • u equals fraction numerator 5 pi over denominator 6 end fraction comma space fraction numerator 13 pi over denominator 6 end fraction comma space fraction numerator 17 pi over denominator 6 end fraction comma space fraction numerator 25 pi over denominator 6 end fraction space

  • Finally, convert each solution back to a value of the original variable

    • by reversing the substitution

      • E.g. for u equals fraction numerator 5 pi over denominator 6 end fraction

        • space 2 x plus pi over 3 equals fraction numerator 5 pi over denominator 6 end fraction space rightwards double arrow space 2 x equals pi over 2 space rightwards double arrow space x equals pi over 4

      • The full set of solutions can be found by the same method of reversing the substitution

        • x equals pi over 4 comma space fraction numerator 11 pi over denominator 12 end fraction comma space fraction numerator 5 pi over denominator 4 end fraction comma space fraction numerator 23 pi over denominator 12 end fraction space

  • This method is more reliable than trying to apply trigonometric identities or guess solutions directly

    • especially when the interval is non-standard or the solutions are not exact angles

Examiner Tips and Tricks

The "transform the interval, solve, convert back" approach is the most reliable method for handling transformed arguments.

  • It works for any equation regardless of the specific values involved

A common error is to find the principal solution for the transformed variable but forget to look for additional solutions within the (often wider) transformed interval.

Another common error is forgetting to convert back to the original variable at the end.

  • Writing out the substitution clearly at the start helps avoid both mistakes

How do I write general solutions when no interval is specified?

  • If no solution interval is specified

    • a trigonometric equation has infinitely many solutions

    • because trigonometric functions are periodic

  • General solutions are written using an integer parameter (typically n or k) to represent all possible solutions

    • For solutions to bold sin bold italic u bold equals bold italic p

      • u equals u subscript 0 plus 2 pi n or u equals open parentheses pi minus u subscript 0 close parentheses plus 2 pi n

        • where u subscript 0 is the initial solution

        • and n is any integer

    • For solutions to bold cos bold italic u bold equals bold italic p

      • u equals u subscript 0 plus 2 pi n or u equals negative u subscript 0 plus 2 pi n

        • where u subscript 0 is the initial solution

        • and n is any integer

    • For solutions to bold tan bold italic u bold equals bold italic k

      • u equals u subscript 0 plus pi n

        • where u subscript 0 is the initial solution

        • and n is any integer

  • After finding the general solutions for u, you can convert each one back to the original variable by reversing the substitution

    • E.g. for space sin open parentheses 2 x plus pi over 3 close parentheses equals 1 half converted to sin u equals 1 half

      • The initial solution is u subscript 0 equals pi over 6

      • So the general solution in terms of u is

        • u equals pi over 6 plus 2 pi n space or space u equals open parentheses pi minus pi over 6 close parentheses plus 2 pi n equals fraction numerator 5 pi over denominator 6 end fraction plus 2 pi n

      • To convert the first part

        • 2 x plus pi over 3 equals pi over 6 plus 2 pi n space rightwards double arrow space 2 x equals negative pi over 6 plus 2 pi n space rightwards double arrow space x equals negative pi over 12 plus pi n

      • To convert the second part

        • 2 x plus pi over 3 equals fraction numerator 5 pi over denominator 6 end fraction plus 2 pi n space rightwards double arrow space 2 x equals pi over 2 plus 2 pi n space rightwards double arrow space x equals pi over 4 plus pi n

      • So the general solution in terms of x is

        • x equals negative pi over 12 plus pi n space or space x equals pi over 4 plus pi n

Examiner Tips and Tricks

When a question asks for "all input values" without specifying an interval, the answer should be in general solution form using an integer parameter.

  • Make sure your general solution form correctly captures every solution, not just a few of them

You can use any letter you want for the integer parameter in the general solution, as long as that letter is not being used for something else in the question

  • E.g. if the variable in the equation is x, then you would lose points on the exam if you also used x as the integer parameter

How do contextual restrictions affect the solution set?

  • In trigonometric equations and inequalities arising from a contextual scenario

    • there is often a domain restriction implied by the context

  • E.g. if t represents time in hours after midnight

    • then t might be restricted to 0 less or equal than t less than 24

  • Or if h represents height above the ground

    • then values where h is negative might not make physical sense

  • These contextual restrictions can limit the number of solutions to a finite set

    • even when the underlying equation has infinitely many solutions

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Always check whether all the solutions you find make sense in the context of a question, and discard any that do not.

How are equations with composed inverse and trigonometric functions solved?

  • On the exam, some equations may involve a composition of

    • an inverse trigonometric function

    • with a trigonometric function

      • E.g. \cos^{-1}(\tan(2x)) = 0

  • The strategy is to work from the outside in

    • Start by applying the inverse of the outermost function to both sides

      • E.g. cos to the power of negative 1 end exponent left parenthesis tan left parenthesis 2 x right parenthesis right parenthesis equals 0 space rightwards double arrow space cos open parentheses cos to the power of negative 1 end exponent left parenthesis tan left parenthesis 2 x right parenthesis right parenthesis close parentheses equals cos open parentheses 0 close parentheses space rightwards double arrow space tan open parentheses 2 x close parentheses equals 1

    • This gets rid of the outer inverse trig function

      • and converts the equation into a simpler equation involving the inner trig function

    • Then you can solve the resulting trigonometric equation using the methods described above

Worked Example

The function space f is given by space f left parenthesis x right parenthesis equals cos left parenthesis 1.8 x minus 0.3 right parenthesis. The function g is given by g left parenthesis x right parenthesis equals f left parenthesis x right parenthesis minus 0.4. Find the zeros of g on the interval 0 less or equal than x less or equal than pi.

Answer:

Method 1

Start by setting space g left parenthesis x right parenthesis equals 0

table row cell g open parentheses x close parentheses end cell equals 0 row cell f open parentheses x close parentheses minus 0.4 end cell equals 0 row cell cos left parenthesis 1.8 x minus 0.3 right parenthesis minus 0.4 end cell equals 0 end table

Isolate the cosine function on one side of the equation

\cos(1.8x - 0.3) = 0.4

Define the substitution

Let u equals 1.8 x minus 0.3

  • So the equation becomes

cos u equals 0.4

  • You also need to transform the solution interval

0 less or equal than x less or equal than pi
0 less or equal than 1.8 x less or equal than 1.8 pi
minus 0.3 less or equal than 1.8 x minus 0.3 less or equal than 1.8 pi minus 0.3

negative 0.3 less or equal than u less or equal than 1.8 pi minus 0.3

Solve cos u equals 0.4 in the transformed interval

  • noting that 1.8 pi minus 0.3 almost equal to 5.355

The initial solution is

u equals cos to the power of negative 1 end exponent left parenthesis 0.4 right parenthesis equals 1.159279...

  • By the symmetry of cosine, another solution is

u equals negative 1.159279...

  • That is not in the solution interval, but adding 2 pi to it gives another solution that is

u equals negative 1.159279 plus 2 pi equals 5.123905...

  • Both u almost equal to 1.159 and u almost equal to 5.124 are within the transformed interval

Convert the solutions back to x

u equals 1.8 x minus 0.3 space rightwards double arrow space 1.8 x equals u plus 0.3 space rightwards double arrow space x equals fraction numerator u plus 0.3 over denominator 1.8 end fraction

  • Therefore

x subscript 1 equals fraction numerator 1.159279... plus 0.3 over denominator 1.8 end fraction equals 0.810710...

x subscript 2 equals fraction numerator 5.123905... plus 0.3 over denominator 1.8 end fraction equals 3.013281...

Round the answers to 3 decimal places

x equals 0.811 comma space 3.013 space space open parentheses 3 space straight d. straight p. close parentheses

Method 2

If you do not need to show your working to earn full marks (e.g. if a question like this were presented instead as a multiple choice question), you can also solve this sort of equation using your graphing calculator

  • Graph the function space g left parenthesis x right parenthesis equals cos left parenthesis 1.8 x minus 0.3 right parenthesis minus 0.4

  • And identify the x-axis crossings in the interval 0 less or equal than x less or equal than pi

Graph of a transformed cosine wave with points marked at (0.81071,0) and (3.01328,0) on a grid, showing peaks and troughs.

Round the answers to 3 decimal places

x equals 0.811 comma space 3.013 space space open parentheses 3 space straight d. straight p. close parentheses

Worked Example

The function h is given by h left parenthesis x right parenthesis equals 2 cos left parenthesis 3 x right parenthesis plus 1. Find all input values in the domain of h that yield an output value of 0.

Answer:

Set h(x) = 0 and rearrange to isolate the cosine function

2\cos(3x) + 1 = 0

\cos(3x) = -\frac{1}{2}

Define the substitution

Let u equals 3 x

  • So the equation becomes

cos u equals negative 1 half

  • Since no interval is specified, you need to find the general solution for u

Find the initial solution

u equals cos to the power of negative 1 end exponent open parentheses negative 1 half close parentheses equals fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 3 end fraction

  • And by the symmetry of the cosine function, another solution is

u equals negative fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 3 end fraction

Cosine has a period of 2 pi

  • so adding integer multiples of 2 pi to those two solutions gives all the other solutions

u equals fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 3 end fraction plus 2 pi n space space or space space u equals negative fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 3 end fraction plus 2 pi n

Finally, space u equals 3 x space rightwards double arrow space x equals u over 3

  • So you can convert the solution back to x by dividing each expression by 3

x equals fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 9 end fraction plus open parentheses fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 3 end fraction close parentheses n space space or space space x equals negative fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 9 end fraction plus open parentheses fraction numerator 2 pi over denominator 3 end fraction close parentheses n

Worked Example

The function m is given by m left parenthesis x right parenthesis equals sin to the power of negative 1 end exponent left parenthesis cos left parenthesis 2 x right parenthesis right parenthesis. Find all input values in the domain of m that yield an output value of 0.

Answer:

Set m left parenthesis x right parenthesis equals 0

\sin^{-1}(\cos(2x)) = 0

Apply the sine function to both sides

sin open parentheses sin to the power of negative 1 end exponent left parenthesis cos left parenthesis 2 x right parenthesis right parenthesis close parentheses equals sin open parentheses 0 close parentheses

cos left parenthesis 2 x right parenthesis equals 0

Now solve cos left parenthesis 2 x right parenthesis equals 0 for all real x

  • sin to the power of negative 1 end exponent has a domain of open square brackets negative 1 comma space 1 close square brackets

    • But cos 2 x only outputs values in open square brackets negative 1 comma space 1 close square brackets

    • So any real number is a valid input for m open parentheses x close parentheses

  • I.e. the domain for m open parentheses x close parentheses is all real numbers

Define the substitution

Let u = 2x

  • So the equation becomes

cos u equals 0

  • The domain is all real numbers, so you need to find the general solution for u

Find the initial solution

u equals cos to the power of negative 1 end exponent open parentheses 0 close parentheses equals pi over 2

  • And by the symmetry of the cosine function, another solution is

u equals negative pi over 2

Cosine has a period of 2 pi

  • so adding integer multiples of 2 pi to those two solutions gives all the other solutions

u equals pi over 2 plus 2 pi n space space or space space u equals negative pi over 2 plus 2 pi n

Finally, space u equals 2 x space rightwards double arrow space x equals u over 2

  • So you can convert the solution back to x by dividing each expression by 2

x equals pi over 4 plus pi n space space or space space x equals negative pi over 4 plus pi n

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Roger B

Author: Roger B

Expertise: Maths Content Creator

Roger's teaching experience stretches all the way back to 1992, and in that time he has taught students at all levels between Year 7 and university undergraduate. Having conducted and published postgraduate research into the mathematical theory behind quantum computing, he is more than confident in dealing with mathematics at any level the exam boards might throw at you.

Mark Curtis

Reviewer: Mark Curtis

Expertise: Maths Content Creator

Mark graduated twice from the University of Oxford: once in 2009 with a First in Mathematics, then again in 2013 with a PhD (DPhil) in Mathematics. He has had nine successful years as a secondary school teacher, specialising in A-Level Further Maths and running extension classes for Oxbridge Maths applicants. Alongside his teaching, he has written five internal textbooks, introduced new spiralling school curriculums and trained other Maths teachers through outreach programmes.