The Hungarian Uprising, 1956 (Edexcel IGCSE History: Paper 1: Depth Studies): Revision Note

Exam code: 4HI1

Zoe Wade

Written by: Zoe Wade

Reviewed by: Bridgette Barrett

Updated on

Timeline & summary

A timeline chart showing key events during the Hungarian Uprising of 1956. The timeline spans from October to December. Key events include: on 24th October, Khrushchev allows Imre Nagy to become President of Hungary after riots in Budapest; on 28th October, Soviet troops leave Budapest and Nagy’s government promises freedoms of speech and voting; on 3rd November, Nagy announces Hungary will leave the Warsaw Pact; and on 4th November, Khrushchev orders Soviet troops to return to Hungary, resulting in street fighting and the Soviet Union regaining control.
  • Nagy's proposals to leave the Warsaw Pact and share power with non-Communists went far beyond what Khrushchev was prepared to accept

  • On 4 November 1956, Soviet tanks invaded Hungary

    • They crushed the uprising

    • The Soviet Union installed a new pro-Soviet government under Janos Kadar

  • Many Hungarians had expected help from the West

    • The USA offered sympathy but no military support

  • The uprising:

    • strengthened Khrushchev's authority over the Warsaw Pact

    • confirmed the limits of what the USA was prepared to do to help a satellite state

Reasons for the Soviet invasion of Hungary

  • Khrushchev could not accept Nagy's attempt to withdraw Hungary from the Warsaw Pact

    • The Soviet Union needed Hungary to remain in the Warsaw Pact

      • Khrushchev may have needed Hungarian troops to suppress future uprisings in other satellite states

      • Hungary's withdrawal may have prompted other satellite states to do the same

      • The Soviet Union relied upon the 'collective security' of pro-Communist states as stated in the Warsaw Pact

  • Khrushchev did not want any more independent Communist states in Eastern Europe

    • Yugoslavia, under the leadership of Tito, broke away from the Soviet Union's influence in 1948

    • Yugoslavia became closer to the West by accepting military aid from the USA

  • Khrushchev did not want other satellite states to form alliances with Yugoslavia

How did Khrushchev stop the Hungarian Uprising?

A vertical flowchart detailing the events following the Soviet invasion of Hungary on 4th November 1956:

At the top, a turquoise box reads: "Khrushchev sent an invasion force of 1,000 tanks to Hungary on 4th November 1956."

The next box states: "Nagy and his supporters fought the invasion force. This is called the Hungarian Uprising. Nagy contacted the West, begging them to send military assistance to Hungary."

Below that, another box explains: "The Soviet invasion force brutally attacked the Hungarians. Historians estimate that the invasion force killed 20,000 Hungarians. This ended the uprising."

The next step reads: "Khrushchev established a stronger communist government in Hungary under the leadership of Janos Kadar."

Following that: "Nagy and members of his government sought refuge in the Yugoslav Embassy. Kadar promised Nagy’s safety. When Nagy left the embassy, Soviet spies kidnapped him."

At the bottom, the final box states: "In July 1958, the Soviet government announced that Nagy had been executed."
A flow diagram explaining Khrushchev's reaction and punishment of the Hungarian Uprising

The effects of the Soviet invasion of Hungary

Hungary after the invasion

  • A new pro-Soviet government was set up in Hungary under Janos Kadar

  • Nagy was arrested, and he was executed in 1958

Effects on the Warsaw Pact

  • The Hungarian Uprising made Khrushchev's authority within the Warsaw Pact much stronger

    • Members of the Warsaw Pact now understood that they had to do as they were told

    • If they rebelled, as Hungary had done, they could not expect military support from the USA

      • Rebellion carried too much risk and no realistic hope of outside help

  • Khrushchev also became more confident in dealing with the USA

    • He now knew that the Americans were very unlikely to risk direct military action to defend a satellite state

International reaction to the invasion of Hungary

  • When the Soviet invasion force entered Hungary, Nagy believed that the West would support his government

    • Radio Free Europe was a US-funded radio channel that transmitted across Eastern Europe

      • The station encouraged Eastern Europeans to rise up against the Soviet Union

      • Broadcasts led many Hungarians to expect Western help

  • Khrushchev's suppression of the Hungarian Uprising shocked many Western nations

    • Khrushchev's actions did not match his previous policies of de-Stalinisation

  • The United Nations (UN) condemned the invasion and set up an enquiry, but the Soviet Union ignored it

  • Spain, the Netherlands and Switzerland boycotted the 1956 Melbourne Olympics in protest

  • Thousands of Communists in Western Europe left their parties in protest

  • About 200,000 Hungarians fled abroad as refugees, many to Austria and then the USA

Should the USA intervene in the Hungarian Uprising?

Reasons for US intervention

  • Khrushchev's repression went against the UN stance on human rights

  • Nagy's government wanted to increase Hungary's individual freedoms

    • This matches the democratic values of the USA

  • If the USA could free Hungary from the Eastern Bloc, it could use Hungary's geographical position to intimidate the Soviet Union

    • It could make an alliance with Hungary or station weapons on its border with the Soviet Union

Reasons against US intervention

  • The USA had a foreign policy of Containment

    • This meant that the USA did not intervene in countries that were already communist

  • Any military intervention in the Eastern Bloc could cause a nuclear war between the USA and the Soviet Union

  • The US government and population still distrusted Communist countries

The USA's decision about the Hungarian Uprising

  • Ultimately, Eisenhower decided not to give military support to Nagy

    • He did not believe the cause was worth risking a nuclear war for

  • Hungary did receive some support from the West

    • European members of NATO accepted Hungarian refugees

Examiner Tips and Tricks

An exam question could ask you how far you agree that the Hungarian Uprising was the most important reason why Cold War tensions increased in the 1950s.

To achieve Levels 3 and 4 (9–16 marks) you must discuss the stated reason in the question. For this example, you would have to discuss the Hungarian Uprising.

How far did the Hungarian Uprising damage superpower relations?

Evidence of serious damage

  • The friendlier relations suggested by the Geneva Summit of 1955 proved to be short-lived

  • Even though the USA did not take military action, it strongly opposed the Soviet invasion

    • Khrushchev's tough response damaged relations between the two superpowers once again

  • The brutality of the invasion, and the execution of Nagy, gave the West clear propaganda evidence of the harshness of Soviet rule

Evidence that the damage was limited

  • In some ways, the failure of the uprising reflected just as badly on the West as on the Soviet Union

    • The USA and its allies were not prepared to back up their words with military support

  • The USA's underlying policy of Containment did not actually change

    • The crisis confirmed existing limits to the willingness of the USA to interfere in already-Communist countries

  • Neither superpower seriously considered direct war with the other over Hungary

Conclusions

  • The Hungarian Uprising damaged superpower relations

  • The uprising confirmed, for both sides, exactly what each already suspected:

    • that the Soviet Union would use force to keep its satellite states in line

    • that the USA would not risk a wider war to stop it

  • Relations worsened again in 1958, when Khrushchev demanded that Western troops leave West Berlin

Worked Example

Study Extract F.

Extract F: From a history of the Soviet Union, published in 2014

"There was a real danger of Hungary becoming a neutral state with a multi-party parliamentary democracy. On 4 November Soviet tanks rolled in again. In the week it took the Soviet military to crush the uprising 2,500 civilians were killed and 20,000 wounded. Denounced by Moscow as a 'counter-revolutionary', Nagy was arrested, and later executed 'as a lesson to all the other leaders in socialist countries'.

Distracted by the Suez Crisis, the West's reaction was subdued. But the Soviet action brought about a crisis in the movement internationally with many Communists resigning from the party in protest."

What impression does the author give about the Soviet Union's response to the Hungarian Uprising?

You must use Extract F to explain your answer.

(6)

Partial answer:

The author also creates this impression by choosing not to explain the "danger" the extract opens with. The first sentence states that there was "a real danger of Hungary becoming a neutral state with a multi-party parliamentary democracy." However, the author never explains why that would have been so threatening to the Soviet Union. The reader is told that a danger existed, but not what made it dangerous: for example, that Hungary leaving the Warsaw Pact would have weakened the Soviet Union's western border. By leaving out Nagy's justification for his reforms and the way this threatened the Soviet Union, the author makes the invasion seem inevitable. Therefore, the reader is left having to accept the invasion was justified rather than question Khrushchev's motives.

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Keep your answer focused on the extract, because this question is only about the interpretation in front of you.

You should avoid stating if you agree or disagree with the extract as this is not what the question requires. You simply need to show the author's opinion through the words that they use and the evidence they select. When you point out what the author leaves out, only use evidence relevant to the topic in the question.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Zoe Wade

Author: Zoe Wade

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Zoe has worked in education for 10 years as a teaching assistant and a teacher. This has given her an in-depth perspective on how to support all learners to achieve to the best of their ability. She has been the Lead of Key Stage 4 History, showing her expertise in the Edexcel GCSE syllabus and how best to revise. Ever since she was a child, Zoe has been passionate about history. She believes now, more than ever, the study of history is vital to explaining the ever-changing world around us. Zoe’s focus is to create accessible content that breaks down key historical concepts and themes to achieve GCSE success.

Bridgette Barrett

Reviewer: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.