The U2 Incident & the Paris Summit, 1960 (Edexcel IGCSE History: Paper 1: Depth Studies): Revision Note
Exam code: 4HI1
Summary
By 1960, the USA and the Soviet Union were holding talks to try to solve the problem of Berlin without going to war, after Khrushchev's 1958 demand that Western troops leave the city
On 1 May 1960, the Soviet Union shot down an American U2 spy plane over Soviet territory
The pilot, Gary Powers, admitted he was spying
The USA first lied about the plane and then refused to apologise
Khrushchev walked out of the Paris Summit in mid-May 1960
The Paris Summit ended with no decisions
The Berlin problem stayed unsolved
The incident badly damaged trust between the two superpowers in the short term
However, it was less damaging in the long term than later crises such as the Berlin Wall and the Cuban Missile Crisis
The U2 incident, 1960
On 1 May 1960, the Soviet Union shot down a U2 spy plane
The US Air Force and the CIA used U2 planes to take photos of enemy countries and perform espionage operations
Eisenhower initially denied that the plane that the Soviet Union shot down was a spy plane
He made a statement claiming that it was a weather plane that had drifted off course
The Soviet Union questioned the plane's pilot, Gary Powers
Powers admitted that he worked for the CIA and that he used the plane to gain intelligence on the Soviet Union
He received a ten-year prison sentence
The Soviet Union returned Powers to the USA in February 1962 as part of a prisoner exchange

Examiner Tips and Tricks
The U2 incident was not just about one spying incident. It showed how the superpowers used spying instead of open communication.
Examiners want to see how the crisis fits into the bigger picture of Cold War tensions, especially for 16-mark questions.
The effects of the U2 incident on the Paris Summit
In May 1960, the leaders of the USA, Soviet Union, Britain, and France planned to meet at the Paris Summit
Key issues to be discussed in Paris included:
the future of Berlin, which remained a major source of tension
possible disarmament agreements, including reducing nuclear weapons
improving East–West relations and promoting 'peaceful coexistence'
At the summit, Khrushchev demanded an official apology from the USA and an end to spying on the USSR
President Eisenhower refused to apologise
On 11 May 1960, Eisenhower acknowledged that the Soviets had shot down a spy plane
He stated the importance of US espionage missions for the country's safety
What were the outcomes of the Paris Summit?
The summit broke down completely
Khrushchev walked out of the meeting in protest
Khrushchev withdrew his invitation for Eisenhower to visit the Soviet Union
No agreements were made on Berlin, disarmament, or cooperation
The U2 incident damaged US–Soviet relations, increasing mistrust between the superpowers
It set back peaceful coexistence and encouraged both sides to expand spying and the arms race
It also damaged Eisenhower’s reputation, especially as he was about to leave office
It left relations in a worse state for his successor, John F. Kennedy
How damaging was the U2 incident to superpower relations?
Evidence that it was very damaging
The Paris Summit collapsed, which was the best chance to solve the Berlin crisis
Trust between Eisenhower and Khrushchev, built up at Camp David, was destroyed
The USA was exposed as having lied in public
This gave the Soviet Union a propaganda victory
The Berlin problem worsened the following year
Evidence that it was less damaging than it seemed
Relations were already poor before the U2 incident
Berlin had caused tension since 1958
Camp David had produced no agreement on it
Therefore, the incident ended hopes rather than starting a new crisis
Neither side wanted war
The Soviet Union shot down the plane but did not attack any American bases
The USA did not respond with force
The incident stayed a diplomatic row rather than a military crisis
Talks did not stop for ever
Kennedy and Khrushchev met in Vienna in 1961
Later events brought the superpowers far closer to war, including the Berlin Wall and the Cuban Missile Crisis
Conclusions
In the short term, the incident was very damaging
It destroyed the summit and the trust between the leaders
In the long term, it was only moderately damaging
It ended hopes of an agreement but did not lead directly to a military crisis
Worked Example
Explain two effects of the U2 incident on the Cold War in the 1960s.
(8)
Partial answer:
One effect of the U2 incident was that trust between Eisenhower and Khrushchev, built up when they met at Camp David in September 1959, was destroyed. The U2 incident showed Khrushchev that the USA was spying on him while talking about peace at the Paris Summit. This made the Soviet Union less willing to compromise on key Cold War issues such as Berlin. As a result, tension carried on increasing between the two superpowers.
Examiner Tips and Tricks
Ensure that you carefully select your own knowledge. The example above selects the peace summits of Camp David and Paris to explain the impact of the incident on diplomacy.
Unlock more, it's free!
Was this revision note helpful?