Early Steps Towards the Thaw (Edexcel IGCSE History: Paper 1: Depth Studies): Revision Note

Exam code: 4HI1

Zoe Wade

Written by: Zoe Wade

Reviewed by: Bridgette Barrett

Updated on

Summary

  • After the Cuban Missile Crisis, both the USA and the Soviet Union wanted to reduce the danger of nuclear war

  • In 1963, they set up a 'hotline' so the two leaders could talk directly in a crisis

    • They also signed the Limited Test Ban Treaty

  • In 1967, the Outer Space Treaty stopped nuclear weapons being placed in space

  • In 1968, the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty tried to stop nuclear weapons spreading to more countries

  • These agreements made nuclear war less likely

    • However, they did not limit the number of weapons or end the rivalry

  • Relations stayed poor, as shown when the USA cancelled a meeting after the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968

The 'hotline'

What motivated the USA and the Soviet Union to act?

  • The 'thaw' is the easing of tension between the USA and the Soviet Union from 1963, after the Cuban Missile Crisis

    • Historians usually use 'détente' for the more lasting improvement from 1969 to 1972

  • After the Second World War, the USA and the Soviet Union entered an arms race

    • Soon both could destroy the other several times over

  • Many people believed this would keep the peace

    • This idea is known as 'Mutually Assured Destruction' (MAD), because nobody would risk a war that was certain to destroy their own country too

  • However, the Cuban Missile Crisis showed that the leaders could lose control of events

    • A devastating war could break out almost by accident

  • After the crisis, both countries began to look for ways to reduce the threat from nuclear war

  • Some moves had started earlier

    • Khrushchev had called for a halt to nuclear testing in 1958

      • The West had proposed a test ban in 1961, which the Soviets rejected

    • The growing split between the Soviet Union and China also made the USA less afraid of a united Communist bloc

What was the 'hotline'?

  • The USA and the Soviet Union agreed to set up a system of direct communication between the White House in Washington and the Kremlin in Moscow

    • The two countries agreed it at Geneva on 20 June 1963

  • Its purpose was to prevent misunderstandings between the two countries by allowing the leaders to talk quickly in times of crisis

  • It was not a red telephone on each leader's desk, as many people imagine

    • Written messages were used so that nothing was lost or misunderstood in spoken translation

    • Messages were sent by wire telegraph along a 16,000-kilometre cable from Washington to London, Copenhagen, Stockholm, Helsinki and finally Moscow

  • It was not used very often

    • However, Nixon and Brezhnev did use it in 1971, when there was a war between India and Pakistan

Map of the 1963 hotline cable route from Washington in the USA to Moscow in the Soviet Union, via London, Copenhagen, Stockholm and Helsinki. Black dots mark cities and connection points; the line marks the cable route.
A map showing the 'hotline' connecting Washington to Moscow

Why did the 'hotline' matter?

  • It was a practical step

    • It could not stop the arms race, but it made an accidental war less likely

  • By agreeing to talk directly, both sides showed they accepted that the danger of nuclear war was too great to leave to chance

The Test Ban Treaty and the Outer Space Treaty

The Limited Test Ban Treaty, 1963

Why was it signed?

  • Since developing atomic weapons, both the USA and the Soviet Union had tested them in the atmosphere

  • Scientists now understood the dangers of radioactive fallout

    • The two governments became worried about contaminating the environment

  • A warning came in 1954, when the USA exploded a hydrogen bomb at Bikini Atoll in the Pacific Ocean

    • Fallout spread outside the area the Americans had marked as unsafe and reached a Japanese fishing boat, the Lucky Dragon

    • The crew became ill, and one man died

What did it agree to?

  • In August 1963, the USA, the Soviet Union and Britain signed the Limited Test Ban Treaty (also called the Partial Test Ban Treaty)

    • They agreed not to carry out nuclear test explosions in the atmosphere, under water or in outer space

    • They also agreed not to carry out any explosion that would send radioactive debris outside their own borders

    • After 1963, a further 113 countries signed the treaty

  • It was called 'limited' because it did not ban every test

    • Tests deep underground, where the fallout stays inside the ground, were still allowed

The Outer Space Treaty, 1967

Why was it signed?

  • By the 1960s, both superpowers were launching satellites and planning to reach the Moon

  • Both feared the other might place nuclear weapons in orbit, which would spread the arms race into space

What did it agree to?

  • Its main terms were based on a 1963 United Nations resolution

    • Outer space should be explored and used for the benefit of all countries

    • Countries should not place nuclear weapons or other weapons of mass destruction in orbit or on other planets and moons

    • The Moon and other planets and moons should be used only for peaceful purposes

  • The USA, the Soviet Union and Britain drew up the treaty, and other countries signed it later

Why did these treaties matter?

  • Both treaties dealt with places where the superpowers did not yet have weapons or where testing harmed everyone

    • They were easier to agree than treaties that cut existing weapons

  • They showed that the superpowers could agree on some things even while they were rivals

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Keep what each treaty banned separate, because mixing them up is an easy way to limit your marks for own knowledge.

The Limited Test Ban Treaty (1963) banned nuclear tests in the atmosphere, under water and in space, but not underground. The Outer Space Treaty (1967) banned nuclear weapons in orbit and on the Moon and other planets.

The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty

Why was it signed?

  • 'Non-proliferation' means stopping the spread of something

  • The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) was signed in 1968

    • The USA, the Soviet Union, Britain and 59 other states signed it

  • It was a further step by the major powers to stop nuclear weapons spreading to more countries

    • One concern was China, which had exploded its first atomic bomb in 1964

What did it agree to?

  • The treaty split countries into two groups

    • Nuclear weapon states (NWS): the USA, the Soviet Union, China, France and Britain, which already had nuclear weapons

    • Non-nuclear weapon states (NNWS): all the other countries

  • The nuclear weapon states promised to work towards disarmament and not to help other countries develop nuclear weapons

  • The non-nuclear weapon states promised not to get involved in developing nuclear weapons

Why did countries accept it?

  • When it was signed, few non-nuclear countries had the technology, the money or the wish to build nuclear weapons

  • Many countries also felt safer if fewer of their neighbours could get nuclear weapons

Limits of the treaty

  • Some countries, including Israel, Pakistan and India, either never signed the treaty or developed nuclear weapons anyway

  • The treaty did not make the superpowers give up their own weapons

Examiner Tips and Tricks

In a question about the effects of a treaty, do not just list its terms. Say how it made things different. For example, it made it less likely that more countries would get nuclear weapons, which lowered the risk of war.

How significant were agreements after 1962 towards a thaw?

Evidence that the agreements were significant

  • The 'hotline' made an accidental war less likely by allowing the leaders to talk directly in a crisis

  • The Limited Test Ban Treaty reduced the radioactive fallout that was damaging the environment

    • Many other countries signed it

  • The Outer Space Treaty stopped the arms race spreading into space

  • The Non-Proliferation Treaty was a clear step towards stopping nuclear weapons spreading to more countries

  • Together, they showed that the superpowers could co-operate

Evidence that their significance was limited

  • None of the agreements cut the number of nuclear weapons

    • Both countries still had enough weapons to destroy each other many times over

  • Underground nuclear testing was still allowed under the Test Ban Treaty

  • The 'hotline' was not used very often

    • It did little to improve everyday relations

  • The treaties dealt with the dangers that both sides most wanted to avoid

    • They did not solve the causes of the Cold War, such as the rivalry between communism and capitalism

  • Relations in the 1960s remained very poor

    • In 1968, the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia led the US president, Lyndon B. Johnson, to cancel a meeting with the Soviet Union

Conclusions

  • The agreements were significant in the short term, because they reduced the risk of an accidental war and showed that co-operation was possible

  • They were less significant for improving relations in the long term

    • They did not limit the weapons already built

    • The two sides were still rivals

Worked Example

Study Extract F.

Extract F: From a history website, published in 2026

"On July 25, 1963, after only 12 days of negotiations, the two nations agreed to ban testing in the atmosphere, in space, and underwater. The next day, in a television address announcing the agreement, Kennedy claimed that “a limited test ban is safer by far for the United States than an unlimited nuclear arms race.” Over the next two months, President Kennedy convinced a fearful public and a divided Senate to support the treaty."

What impression does the author give about the Limited Test Ban Treaty?

You must use Extract F to explain your answer.

(6)

Partial answer:

The author gives the impression that the treaty was a quick and sensible step that made the USA safer. Saying it was agreed "after only 12 days" suggests that both sides were keen and that agreement came easily, which makes it look like a sign of co-operation after the tension of the Cuban Missile Crisis. By quoting Kennedy saying the treaty was "safer by far" than an unlimited arms race, the author presents it as the safer choice for the USA, which shows it was about protecting America’s own security, not about friendship.

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Keep your answer focused on the extract, because this question is only about the interpretation in front of you.

You should avoid stating if you agree or disagree with the extract as this is not what the question requires. You simply need to show the author's opinion through the words that they use and the evidence they select.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Zoe Wade

Author: Zoe Wade

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Zoe has worked in education for 10 years as a teaching assistant and a teacher. This has given her an in-depth perspective on how to support all learners to achieve to the best of their ability. She has been the Lead of Key Stage 4 History, showing her expertise in the Edexcel GCSE syllabus and how best to revise. Ever since she was a child, Zoe has been passionate about history. She believes now, more than ever, the study of history is vital to explaining the ever-changing world around us. Zoe’s focus is to create accessible content that breaks down key historical concepts and themes to achieve GCSE success.

Bridgette Barrett

Reviewer: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.