The Truman Doctrine & the Marshall Plan (Edexcel IGCSE History: Paper 1: Depth Studies): Revision Note

Exam code: 4HI1

Zoe Wade

Written by: Zoe Wade

Reviewed by: Bridgette Barrett

Updated on

Summary

  • By 1947, the Long Telegram had confirmed Truman's fear that the Soviet Union intended to spread communism

    • Truman decided that the USA needed to act

  • In March 1947, Truman announced that the USA would help any country resisting communism

    • This became known as the Truman Doctrine

    • It ended the USA's old policy of isolationism, which meant staying out of the affairs of other countries

  • In June 1947, the US Secretary of State, George Marshall, announced a huge package of economic aid to rebuild Europe

    • This became known as the Marshall Plan

  • Stalin refused to let the satellite states accept Marshall Aid

    • He accused the USA of using money to build an economic empire

      • The Soviets called this "dollar imperialism"

  • The Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan divided Europe into two economic and political camps

    • Together they marked the point at which any remaining hope of maintaining the Grand Alliance disappeared

The Truman Doctrine

Why Truman acted in 1947

  • Kennan's Long Telegram

    • It confirmed Truman's worst fears, that the Soviet Union intended to spread communism throughout Europe

  • The destruction after the Second World War

    • Many European countries were in ruins after the war

      • Homes, factories and infrastructure, such as roads and railways, had been destroyed

    • In these conditions, communism looked attractive to poorer people

      • A Communist state promised to take the wealth of the richest people and share it among everyone

  • The Greek Civil War

    • In 1947, the British government announced that it could no longer support the Greek government, which was fighting Communist guerrillas, in the Greek Civil War

    • Truman decided it was time for the USA to take action

Examiner Tips and Tricks

You do not need detailed knowledge of the Greek Civil War, but know that it pushed Truman to act against communism.

Truman's speech to Congress, March 1947

  • On 12 March 1947, Truman delivered a speech to the US Congress

    • It announced a package of economic and military aid to Greece and Türkiye (Turkey)

  • Truman announced that the USA would:

    • provide $400 million in aid to Greece and Türkiye

    • send American civilian and military representatives to the region

What did the Truman Doctrine promise to Europe?

  • At the same time as announcing his support for Türkiye and Greece, Truman also spoke about how nations have two alternative ways of life:

A diagram explaining the Truman Doctrine by contrasting two ideological paths. In the center is a yellow box labeled 'The Truman Doctrine.' To the left, under 'The First Way' and labeled 'Capitalism,' a blue box lists: 'Free institutions, Free elections, Freedom of speech, Freedom of religion.' To the right, under 'The Second Way' and labeled 'Communism,' a gray box lists: 'Terror and oppression, Fixed elections, Controlled press and radio, Suppression of freedoms.'
A diagram showing the Truman Doctrine

Impact of the Truman Doctrine

  • The Truman Doctrine marked a new approach of the USA towards other countries:

    • Before the Second World War, the USA had followed a policy of isolationism by not getting involved in the affairs of other countries

    • With the spread of communism in Europe, isolationism was replaced by the policy of containment

  • US aid helped the Greek government defeat the Communists by 1949

    • Türkiye stayed out of Soviet control

  • It helped divide Europe into two rival groups, linking Western countries to the USA

The Marshall Plan

  • After a visit to Europe, General George Marshall told Truman that every country in Europe was at risk of turning to communism because of how poor they were

  • He recommended that the USA provide these countries with economic aid to turn them away from communism

  • The US Congress passed the Marshall Plan after Czechoslovakia became Communist in 1948

The economic impact of the Marshall Plan

  • Before the plan was passed, $12.7 billion had already been given to other countries

  • The Marshall Plan gave away $13 billion to 16 European countries in Western Europe

How was Marshall Aid divided between different European countries?

A pie chart showing the distribution of aid received by countries, with values in billions. The segments are labeled: United Kingdom (3.3), Other Nations (3.2), France (2.3), West Germany (1.4), Italy (1.2), and Netherlands (1.1). Each country is represented by a different color, with the United Kingdom and Other Nations having the largest shares
A pie chart showing the amount of money given to each country ($ billion)
  • Money was distributed based on the population and pre-war economy of each country

  • It was described as a "lifeline to sinking men" by the British foreign secretary, Ernest Bevin

  • The Marshall Plan was offered to the satellite states of Eastern Europe but Truman knew that Stalin would not allow them to accept the money

Dollar imperialism

  • Stalin called the Marshall Plan "dollar imperialism" because of how the USA was trying to expand its ‘empire’ using money

  • The Marshall Plan had divided the West from the East:

    • The satellite states, controlled by Moscow, stayed in the Soviet camp

    • Recipients of the Marshall Plan supported the USA

Examiner Tips and Tricks

A strong 16-mark answer would consider both perspectives of the Marshall Plan.

From an American perspective, the Marshall Plan helped Europe recover from the impact of the Second World War.

From a Soviet perspective, the Marshall Plan spread American influence across Europe and made more countries dependent on the USA, and capitalism, for their survival.

How far did the Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan increase Cold War tensions?

Evidence that they increased tensions

  • The Truman Doctrine ended any remaining hope of cooperation between the USA and the Soviet Union

    • The USA had now set itself up in direct opposition to the Communist Soviet Union and invited other nations to join it

  • Stalin's suspicions of the West were strengthened

    • He believed he now had clear evidence that the USA was trying to destroy communism and weaken the Soviet Union

  • The Marshall Plan successfully tied Western European countries closely to the USA

    • As Stalin rejected it for the satellite states, Europe became divided into two separate economic and political camps

  • Stalin's accusation of 'dollar imperialism' shows his anger toward the USA

    • He believed that the USA was undermining the role of the United Nations, which should be the group providing money to other countries

Evidence that other factors mattered too

  • The Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan were responses to a situation that already existed, such as:

    • Soviet expansion in Eastern Europe

    • Churchill's 'iron curtain' speech

  • The Marshall Plan had a genuine economic aim as well as a political one

    • It really did help rebuild the shattered economies of Western Europe, which reduced poverty and suffering

  • Stalin's own decision to refuse Marshall Aid to the satellite states, and to create Cominform and Comecon in response, deepened the division of Europe

    • Some historians argue that Stalin's response did as much damage to relations between the USA and the Soviet Union as the American policies did

Conclusions

  • The Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan were a major turning point in the Cold War

    • The USA committed itself to opposing communism everywhere

  • However, they did not create the mistrust from nothing

    • They were the USA's answer to a danger it already believed was real, because of the Long Telegram and Soviet expansion in Eastern Europe

Worked Example

Explain two effects of the Truman Doctrine.

(8)

Partial answer:

One effect of the Truman Doctrine was that it ended the USA's old policy of isolationism for good, and committed the USA to a new policy of containment. Before 1947, many Americans had hoped that the USA could go back to isolationism once the Second World War was over. In his speech to Congress in March 1947, Truman promised that the USA would give economic and military aid to any country trying to resist communism, not only Greece and Türkiye. This was a much bigger promise than simply helping two countries in trouble. As a result, the USA committed itself to a permanent policy of limiting the spread of communism, known as containment, wherever in the world it threatened to spread. This was a lasting change in how the USA saw its role in the world.

Examiner Tips and Tricks

To reach the top level, follow each effect through to a developed result, as the model answer does with the shift from isolationism to a permanent policy of containment.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Zoe Wade

Author: Zoe Wade

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Zoe has worked in education for 10 years as a teaching assistant and a teacher. This has given her an in-depth perspective on how to support all learners to achieve to the best of their ability. She has been the Lead of Key Stage 4 History, showing her expertise in the Edexcel GCSE syllabus and how best to revise. Ever since she was a child, Zoe has been passionate about history. She believes now, more than ever, the study of history is vital to explaining the ever-changing world around us. Zoe’s focus is to create accessible content that breaks down key historical concepts and themes to achieve GCSE success.

Bridgette Barrett

Reviewer: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.