Ideology & the Breakdown of the Grand Alliance (Edexcel IGCSE History: Paper 1: Depth Studies): Revision Note

Exam code: 4HI1

Zoe Wade

Written by: Zoe Wade

Reviewed by: Bridgette Barrett

Updated on

Summary

  • The Cold War was a struggle between the USA and the Soviet Union after 1945

    • It was a war of ideas, not a war of direct fighting

  • The two most powerful countries in the world were the USA and the Soviet Union

    • These two countries were known as the superpowers

  • The two sides believed in different ideologies

    • An ideology is a set of beliefs about how a country should be run

      • The USA and Britain were Capitalist

      • The Soviet Union was Communist

  • The two sides had distrusted each other since the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917, when the Communists took power in Russia

    • This distrust grew during the 1930s

  • During the Second World War, Britain, the USA and the Soviet Union fought on the same side

    • This union became known as the Grand Alliance

    • Only a common enemy, Hitler, held the alliance together

  • Tensions built up during the war over:

    • the second front

    • the future of Eastern Europe

    • the atomic bomb

  • After Roosevelt died in April 1945, the new American president, Truman, was tougher with Stalin

  • By the end of 1945, the alliance was badly damaged, but open hostility had not yet begun

Ideological differences between Capitalism and Communism

What is Capitalism?

  • Capitalism is an ideology where everyone is free to own property and businesses with the aim of making money

  • By 1941, the main Capitalist countries were the USA and Britain

An infographic titled 'What is Capitalism?' in a blue central box. Surrounding it are four labeled categories: 'Economics' at the top, 'Society' on the right, 'Politics' at the bottom, and 'Rights' on the left, each in beige boxes. Connected to these categories are explanatory statements in gray boxes: 'Land and businesses can be owned by people, not just the state' (Economics), 'Some people have more money and wealth than others' (Society), 'Elections are held where people have a choice of different political parties' (Politics), and 'Individuals have the freedom to live their own lives, but impacted by what the majority decide' (Rights)
A concept map showing the key features of Capitalism

What is Communism?

  • Communism is an ideology where all property is owned by the state to ensure that everyone has a fair share

  • By 1941, the main Communist country was the Soviet Union

An infographic titled 'What is Communism?' in a blue central box. Surrounding it are four labeled categories: 'Economics' at the top, 'Society' on the right, 'Politics' at the bottom, and 'Rights' on the left, each in beige boxes. Connected to these categories are explanatory statements in gray boxes: 'All land and businesses owned by the state' (Economics), 'There are no social classes, and everyone is considered equal' (Society), 'Elections are held where people have a choice of different candidates from the same party' (Politics), and 'Rights of workers seen as more important than the individual' (Rights).
A concept map showing the key features of Communism

How did these ideological differences cause mistrust?

  • The Soviet Union was afraid that the West wanted to force its ideas on the Soviet people

    • Stalin believed the West delayed the second front because it was anti-Communist

  • The West was afraid that the Soviet Union wanted to spread communism across the world

    • The West saw Stalin's demand for a 'friendly' Communist government in Poland as proof that he wanted to spread communism

  • Each side therefore saw the other's system as a danger to its own survival

    • This is why the Cold War was a struggle over ideas as well as land

  • The disagreement mattered most when it became clear that Nazi Germany would be beaten

    • At that point, the Allies had to decide how Europe would be run after the war

    • Each side wanted a Europe that matched its own beliefs

Examiner Tips and Tricks

How did these ideological differences cause mistrust?

Examiners report that many answers describe the differences between capitalism and communism without linking them to events.

If a question asks about the effects of ideological differences on relations in 1943–49, tie each difference to a specific event, such as the second front or Poland, and explain how it made relations worse.

Long-term rivalry between the Soviet Union and the West

Distrust before the Second World War

  • The Soviet Union and the West distrusted each other long before the Cold War began

1917–22: the Russian Revolution and Western intervention

  • In October 1917 the Bolsheviks, a group of Communist revolutionaries, took power in Russia

  • Britain, France and the USA disliked the Bolsheviks' beliefs

    • They were angry that Russia had left the First World War

    • They sent troops to help the Bolsheviks' opponents in the Russian Civil War

      • The intervention failed

      • It convinced the Bolsheviks that the West wanted to get rid of them

  • In 1922, Russia became the centre of a new Communist state, the Soviet Union

    • The West feared that communism would spread from there to other countries

1938–39: relations got worse

  • In the Munich Agreement (1938), Britain and France let Hitler take part of Czechoslovakia without asking the Soviet Union

    • Stalin decided that the West would be happy to see Nazi Germany attack the Soviet Union

  • In the Nazi–Soviet Pact (August 1939), Hitler and Stalin agreed to divide Poland between them

    • Britain and France felt betrayed

The Grand Alliance in the Second World War

The Grand Alliance and the 'Big Three'

  • The Grand Alliance was formed between the USA, the Soviet Union and Britain to defeat the Axis powers of Germany and Japan during the Second World War

An infographic comparing key world leaders before and after 1945. The top section displays three leaders with their respective national flags: Franklin D. Roosevelt (USA), Winston Churchill (UK), and Joseph Stalin (Soviet Union). Below each leader is a description of their stance: Roosevelt wanted to accept the Soviet Union as a superpower to ensure world peace; Churchill, due to his belief in the British Empire, was suspicious of Stalin and communism; and Stalin aimed to strengthen one-party rule in the Soviet Union and believed the West sought to destroy communism. A blue arrow labeled 'After 1945' leads to two new leaders: Harry S. Truman (USA) and Clement Attlee (UK). Truman is described as having a 'get tough' approach toward the Soviet Union, in contrast to Roosevelt’s friendlier stance. Attlee, as the newly elected British Prime Minister, prioritized domestic changes in Britain over foreign affairs
An illustration showing the members of the Grand Alliance, 1941-45

Issues amongst the 'Big Three' in the Second World War

The second front

  • Germany broke the Nazi-Soviet Pact and invaded the Soviet Union in 1941

    • The Soviet Union then fought the Germans almost alone in the east and suffered terrible losses

    • Over 20 million Soviet people died in what Stalin called the "Great Patriotic War"

  • Stalin repeatedly asked Britain and the USA to open a second front

    • This meant a new attack on Germany in the West, which would force Germany to move troops away from the Soviet Union

  • Britain and the USA did not land in France until June 1944

    • Stalin believed that the delay was deliberate

      • He thought the West wanted the Soviet Union and Germany to wear each other out, so that the Soviet Union would be weak after the war

Fears about Eastern Europe

  • In 1945, Churchill and Roosevelt feared that Stalin wanted to bring communism to the Eastern European countries

    • Germany had conquered these countries and the Red Army was freeing them at a rapid pace

  • Stalin wanted a buffer zone

    • This is a belt of friendly countries between the Soviet Union and Germany that would protect the Soviet Union from another attack

      • Germany had invaded Russia twice in thirty years, in 1914 and in 1941

  • To Stalin, the buffer zone was defence

    • To the West, it looked like the spread of Communism

Tension between Britain and the USA

  • The 'Big Three' was not a united force against Stalin

    • Roosevelt believed that colonies should be allowed to rule themselves

      • Britain still had a large empire

  • At times, Roosevelt seemed to think that British colonialism was a bigger threat to peace than the Soviet Union

    • This meant that Churchill sometimes felt Roosevelt was taking Stalin's side against him

The race to Berlin

  • By April 1945, British, American and Soviet forces were closing in on Germany from all sides

    • On 25 April, American and Soviet soldiers met at the River Elbe

  • Stalin was determined that Soviet forces should enter Berlin before the Americans

    • Tens of thousands of Soviet soldiers died in the attack

  • The Red Army reached Berlin first

    • Soviet troops fought their way into the city, and the German forces in Berlin surrendered on 2 May 1945

  • By May, the Red Army held Berlin as well as most of Central and Eastern Europe

    • The West feared that Soviet troops would not leave

The atomic bomb

  • The USA developed the atomic bomb in secret

    • Truman only told Stalin about a "new weapon" at Potsdam, in July 1945

    • Stalin's spies had already told him about it

  • The USA dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima (6 August 1945) and Nagasaki (9 August 1945) without asking the Soviet Union

  • Stalin worried that the Americans might one day use such bombs against the Soviet Union

    • He ordered the Soviet atomic bomb programme to be speeded up

An infographic titled 'Why Did the USA Use Atomic Bombs?' in a blue central box. A vertical beige label on the left reads 'Official Reason.' Below the title, official reasons are listed: 'Atomic bombs would avoid an invasion of Japan by US troops, preventing millions from being killed (Reduce Deaths),' 'Atomic bombs would force Japan to surrender, which they had previously refused to do (Force Surrender),' and 'Atomic bombs would boost the morale of troops because they would no longer need to fight (Boost Morale)'. A pink vertical label on the left reading 'Unofficial Reason.' At the bottom, a grey box states, 'Atomic bombs would send a message to the Soviet Union of how technologically advanced and powerful the USA were.'
A concept map showing why the USA used atomic bombs

The attitudes of Truman and Stalin

  • Truman was strongly anti-Communist and distrusted Stalin

    • He believed Roosevelt had been too willing to compromise

    • Truman wanted to 'get tough' with the Soviet Union

    • The atomic bomb made him more confident

  • Stalin distrusted the West

    • He believed that they wanted to destroy Communism and saw the delayed second front as proof

    • Stalin wanted security above all, through a buffer zone of friendly governments in Eastern Europe

How far had the Grand Alliance broken down by 1945?

Evidence that the alliance had broken down

  • The alliance was never based on shared beliefs, only on a common enemy

    • When Germany was defeated in May 1945, the reason for the alliance disappeared

  • The leaders who had built the alliance were gone

    • Roosevelt died in April 1945

    • Churchill lost the July 1945 general election to Clement Attlee

  • The Allies disagreed about key issues regarding post-war Europe

    • This made existing tensions even worse

  • The alliance was based on already weak foundations

    • The leaders all distrusted each other

    • They had significant ideological differences

Evidence that the alliance had not broken down

  • The Allies worked well together on military plans

    • The second front was opened in 1944

    • Stalin kept his promise to declare war on Japan in August 1945

  • The leaders were still meeting and talking, and none of them wanted another war

    • Truman felt he could do little about Soviet control of Eastern Europe without risking a war

Judgement

  • By the end of 1945, the Grand Alliance had broken down as an effective partnership

    • Suspicions between the leaders grew to the point where it affected negotiations

    • The 'Big Three' agreed upon fewer things

  • However, this tension had not yet turned into open hostility

Examiner Tips and Tricks

If a question asks how far you agree that the Grand Alliance collapsed by 1945, say what you mean by "collapsed" before you answer.

Choose a test, for example, "no longer able to work together" or "in open hostility". Then weigh the evidence against it to decide how far you agree.

This turns a list of facts into a judgement, and a judgement based on a clear test is what Level 4 in Question (c) rewards.

Worked Example

Study Extract F.

Extract F: From a history of the Cold War, published in 1999

"The common concerns that had united the former allies (namely the fight against fascism and Nazi Germany) disappeared leaving only two radically different political, social, economic and ideological systems."

What impression does the author give about the Grand Alliance at the end of the Second World War?

You must use Extract F to explain your answer.

(6)

Partial answer:

The author gives the impression that the Grand Alliance was bound to break down once Germany was beaten, because it had only ever been held together by a shared enemy. The author says that the "common concerns that had united the former allies" simply "disappeared". The word "disappeared" makes the loss of the common enemy sound sudden and complete, and the phrase "former allies" shows that the alliance was already over when the war ended. Therefore, it makes the reader think that the Grand Alliance suddenly ended because there was no need for it to exist when Hitler was defeated.

Examiner Tips and Tricks

To reach the top level for this question, you must analyse the author's choices: comment on the effect of one or two emotive words, and explain what the author has chosen to stress. You can also point out what the author has left out, but only if you explain how the omission strengthens the impression.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Zoe Wade

Author: Zoe Wade

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Zoe has worked in education for 10 years as a teaching assistant and a teacher. This has given her an in-depth perspective on how to support all learners to achieve to the best of their ability. She has been the Lead of Key Stage 4 History, showing her expertise in the Edexcel GCSE syllabus and how best to revise. Ever since she was a child, Zoe has been passionate about history. She believes now, more than ever, the study of history is vital to explaining the ever-changing world around us. Zoe’s focus is to create accessible content that breaks down key historical concepts and themes to achieve GCSE success.

Bridgette Barrett

Reviewer: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.