Debates About Globalisation (DP IB Global Politics: HL): Revision Note

Jane Hirons

Written by: Jane Hirons

Reviewed by: Lisa Eades

Updated on

Perspectives of liberalism and realism

  • Globalisation is the process by which the world’s local, national, regional and global societies are economically, socially and culturally interconnected

Realism

  • Realism sees the world as a competitive arena in which states act primarily in their own self-interest to ensure their survival and security

  • Realism argues that the state must manage its own development and interdependence is risky

    • It is broadly sceptical of globalisation, arguing that states must prioritise national interest and self-sufficiency over international interdependence

    • Dependence on other states for trade, resources or investment creates strategic vulnerability that can be exploited by more powerful actors

    • From a realist perspective, globalisation tends to benefit the most powerful states disproportionately

      • International institutions serve the interests of those who dominate them rather than promoting genuine equality between states

Liberalism

  • Liberalism believes cooperation between states, international institutions and shared values can lead to peace and mutual benefit

  • Liberalism argues that interdependence is the best way to promote peace and global development

    • Liberalism views globalisation as a largely positive force

      • Economic interdependence makes conflict between states more costly and therefore less likely

    • Free trade, open markets and international institutions such as the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and United Nations (UN) create shared interests and incentives for cooperation, spreading prosperity and democratic norms

    • Liberals acknowledge that the benefits of globalisation are not automatically distributed equally

      • Effective international governance is needed to ensure that less economically developed states are not left behind

Impacts of globalisation on development

  • The relationship between globalisation and sustainable development is widely debated

    • Arguments vary across its economic, social, political and environmental dimensions

Type of development

Benefit of globalisation

Criticism of globalisation

Social Development

  • Increased interactions of citizens across the world leads to the sharing of ideas about human rights and justice

  • Western culture dominates global media and can erode traditional cultures and identity

Economic Development

  • Increased trade and specialisation increase GDP and promote economic growth

  • More economically powerful states benefit much more than less economically powerful states

Political Development

  • Increased interactions mean states cannot hide corruption easily and citizens can be inspired to demand change

  • National sovereignty may be eroded by intergovernmental organisations

Environmental Development

  • Environmental concerns impact all people on the planet and a united effort is needed to tackle them

  • Globalisation promotes mass consumption and consumerism

Critical theories and globalisation

  • Critical theories present a range of perspectives in global politics that challenge existing power structures and question whose interests are served by the way the world is organised

  • Critical theories present a different viewpoint from liberalism and realism

  • They include:

    • Feminism

    • Marxism

    • Post-colonialism

    • Environmentalism

    • Constructivism

  • Generalisations regarding their views about globalisation can be made

Critical theory

Core principles

Related to globalisation

Feminism

  • Gender inequality is built into global politics

  • Challenges male-dominated power structures

  • Focuses on women's experiences and rights

  • Globalisation can bring about positive changes for women through the sharing of global norms about the rights of women

  • However, feminism is suspicious that it mostly reinforces existing power structures which prioritise economic growth over human development

Marxism

  • Global politics is driven by conflict between rich and poor

  • Capitalism allows wealthy elites and states to exploit workers and poorer states

  • Economic inequality is the root cause of most global problems

  • Globalisation is essentially a capitalist system where wealthy states exploit less economically developed states and their workers

Post-colonialism

  • Colonial legacies continue to drive global inequality

  • Existing structures favour Western states and silence the Global South

  • Non-Western perspectives must be taken seriously

  • Globalisation is an extension of colonial power structures

  • Western states exploit less economically developed states and destroy diverse cultures and traditions

Environmentalism

  • The natural world must be central to global politics

  • Ecological sustainability must shape all political and economic decisions

    • Current patterns of production and consumption are unsustainable

  • Globalisation can be beneficial to the environment if it leads to global cooperation toward sustainable environmental practices

  • However, the emphasis on economic growth, production and consumption is destructive and unsustainable

Constructivism

  • Global politics is shaped by shared ideas, norms and identities

  • State behaviour is not fixed — it is shaped by collective values

  • Change is possible when dominant ideas shift

  • Globalisation is a socially constructed process shaped by shared ideas, norms and identities rather than material forces alone

  • It can spread progressive global norms around human rights and environmental cooperation, reshaping how states understand their interests and responsibilities

  • Constructivists recognise that the norms being promoted reflect the values and interests of dominant states, making globalisation an uneven and contested process

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Jane Hirons

Author: Jane Hirons

Expertise: Content Writer

Jane has been actively involved in all levels of educational endeavors including designing curriculum, teaching and assessment. She has extensive experience as an international classroom teacher and understands the challenges students face when it comes to revision.

Lisa Eades

Reviewer: Lisa Eades

Expertise: Business Content Creator

Lisa has taught A Level, GCSE, BTEC and IBDP Business for over 20 years and is a senior Examiner for Edexcel. Lisa has been a successful Head of Department in Kent and has offered private Business tuition to students across the UK. Lisa loves to create imaginative and accessible resources which engage learners and build their passion for the subject.