How to Answer 5 & 6 Mark Evaluate Questions (AQA GCSE Psychology): Revision Note

Exam code: 8182

Raj Bonsor

Written by: Raj Bonsor

Updated on

How do I answer AQA GCSE Psychology 5-mark and 6-mark evaluate questions?

  • 'Evaluate' questions appear in Papers 1 and 2, and they assess your ability to:

    • analyse and evaluate psychological information, ideas, processes and procedures to make judgements and draw conclusions (assessment objective 3, or AO3)

  • There are two main types of question:

Type of question

Example

AO1

AO3

'Evaluate...'

Evaluate Gibson's direct theory of perception [5 marks]

0

5

'Describe and evaluate...'

Describe and evaluate the 'policeman doll study' carried out by Hughes [6 marks]

3

3

  • You can be asked to evaluate a theory, a study or a research method

  • Both types are marked using levels, so your answer is judged on its overall quality and not on the number of points you make

  • An 'Evaluate...' question has no marks for description

    • An answer that only describes the theory or study receives no marks

  • A 'Describe and evaluate...' question has half of its marks for each skill

    • A more detailed description does not make up for a limited evaluation

How do I write an effective evaluation point?

  • AQA does not ask for a set number of points

    • Think quality over quantity, as a point that is developed in depth gains more marks than a brief one

  • An effective point has three parts:

    • state the strength or weakness

    • explain it using a specific detail of the theory or study

    • conclude by saying what it means, e.g. 'This means that...'

  • Avoid generic points that could be made about any study

    • 'The study lacks ecological validity' is a brief generic point that will not earn any marks

    • A point becomes specific when it refers to what the participants in that study were asked to do

  • Explain evaluative terms

    • E.g. if you write that the findings 'lack generalisability', say who they cannot be generalised to and why this matters

How do I evaluate a theory, a study or a research method?

  • Read the question carefully to check what you are being asked to evaluate

    • A question on a theory needs an evaluation of the theory, not of the study that is linked to it

  • To evaluate a theory, consider:

    • research that supports or challenges it

    • what it can and cannot explain

    • how it has been used in the real world, e.g. in education or therapy

  • When you use a study as evidence, do not describe it

    • Name the researchers, use the findings and explain why they support or challenge the theory

  • Evaluating a study with no link to the theory keeps your answer in the lowest level

  • To evaluate a study, consider the task, the sample, the control of variables, ethical issues and real-world applications

    • Use a range of points, as an evaluation that focuses too heavily on ethics leaves out other relevant material

  • To evaluate a research method, explain why each strength or weakness matters to a researcher

    • A list of brief points with no explanation limits your marks

How much should I write?

  • Spend around 5 minutes on a 5-mark question and 6 minutes on a 6-mark question

  • Aim to write around 110–130 words for a 5-mark answer and around 130–150 words for a 6-mark answer

  • Two or three well-developed points are enough

Worked Example

Here is an example of a 5-mark 'evaluate' question:

Q. Evaluate Gibson's direct theory of perception.

[5 marks]

Model answer:

One strength of Gibson's theory is that it explains how we usually perceive the world quickly and accurately. For example, a pilot can land a plane using the information in the optic array, which is the pattern of light reaching the eye. Gibson developed his theory from real-life settings like this rather than laboratory experiments, which increases its validity. There is also research support: Gibson and Walk found that very young infants avoided a visual cliff, suggesting that depth perception is innate.

However, the theory cannot explain why perception is sometimes inaccurate, such as when we are tricked by visual illusions. Research also shows that expectation and culture affect perception, which suggests that nurture and past experience play a role too, so Gibson's theory may be incomplete.

Word count: 127

Level 3 response: 5 marks

Marking commentary:

This response is in the top level because the evaluation is effective. There is no description of the theory at the start. The research evidence is used and not described: one sentence gives the finding of the visual cliff study and says what it suggests. The final sentence states what the weaknesses mean for the theory.

Worked Example

Here is an example of a 6-mark 'describe and evaluate' question:

Q. Describe and evaluate the 'policeman doll study' carried out by Hughes.

[6 marks]

Model answer:

Hughes tested 30 children aged 3.5 to 5 years in a laboratory, using a model of two intersecting walls, a boy doll and two policeman dolls. Each child had to hide the boy doll so that neither policeman could see him. Hughes found that 90% of the children did this correctly and concluded that most children of this age can see things from another person's point of view and are not egocentric.

One strength is that hiding from a policeman is a familiar and meaningful game, so children were better able to show their real cognitive ability. This challenged Piaget's claim that children are egocentric until about seven. However, all the children came from Edinburgh, so the findings may not generalise to children from other cultures. The researcher may have given hidden cues, such as looking at where the doll could go, so the results may overestimate the children's ability.

Word count: 150

Level 3 response: 6 marks

Marking commentary:

This response is in the top level because the description is accurate and detailed and the evaluation is effective. The two paragraphs are of similar length, which matches the 3 marks available for each skill. Each evaluation point is specific to this study and explains what it means for the findings.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Raj Bonsor

Author: Raj Bonsor

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Raj joined Save My Exams in 2024 as a Senior Curriculum Expert for Psychology & Sociology. Prior to this, she spent 15 years in the classroom, teaching hundreds of GCSE and A Level students. She has experience as Subject Leader for Psychology and Sociology, and her favourite topics to teach are research methods (especially inferential statistics!) and attachment. She has also successfully taught a number of Level 3 subjects, including criminology, health & social care, and citizenship.