How to Answer a 9 Mark Question (AQA GCSE Psychology): Revision Note

Exam code: 8182

Raj Bonsor

Written by: Raj Bonsor

Updated on

How do I answer an AQA GCSE Psychology 9-mark question?

  • 9-mark questions are the extended writing questions in Papers 1 and 2, and they assess your ability to:

    • demonstrate knowledge and understanding of psychological ideas, processes and procedures (assessment objective 1, or AO1)

    • analyse and evaluate psychological information, ideas, processes and procedures to make judgements and draw conclusions (AO3)

  • There are two 9-mark questions on each paper, and one of them is the synoptic question

    • A synoptic question asks you to draw together knowledge from more than one topic

  • The marks available in this question are as follows:

    • AO1 = 4 marks

    • AO3 = 5 marks

  • Be clear about which type of 9-mark question you are answering, as questions that tell you to refer to a conversation or a piece of information are marked differently:

Feature

9-mark question

9-mark application question

Stem to refer to

No

Yes, e.g. a conversation

Marks for AO1, AO2 and AO3

4, 0 and 5

3, 3 and 3

What you need to do

Describe and evaluate

Describe, apply and evaluate

Share of your answer

A little more than half on evaluation

Around a third for each AO

Maximum mark with no evaluation

4

6

What types of 9-mark question are there?

Type of question

Example

Describe and evaluate a theory

Describe and evaluate Willingham's learning theory

Describe and evaluate a study

Describe and evaluate Piliavin's subway study

Describe a study and evaluate its research method

Describe Penfield's case study of the interpretive cortex. Evaluate the research method used in this study

Describe two things and discuss the link between them

Briefly describe both Yuki's study of emoticons and Gregory's constructivist theory of perception. Discuss whether or not the results of Yuki's study support Gregory's theory

Outline and discuss research methods

Outline what is meant by independent groups and repeated measures. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of both of these types of experimental design

  • Read the question carefully and address every part of it

    • Check whether the second part of the question asks about something different from the first, e.g. describing a study and then evaluating its research method

  • Shape your answer to the question you have been asked, and do not write out a pre-prepared answer on the topic

How is a 9-mark question marked?

  • 9-mark questions are not point marked, so examiners decide which level your whole answer fits best:

Level

Marks

What the answer looks like

3 Detailed

7–9

Knowledge is accurate with detail
Evaluation is effective
Relevant terminology is used consistently throughout

2 Clear

4–6

Knowledge has occasional inaccuracies or omissions
There may be some effective evaluation
Relevant terminology is usually used

1 Basic

1–3

Knowledge is limited
Evaluation is of limited effectiveness or may be absent

  • You cannot make up for a weak evaluation by writing a longer description

    • An answer with no evaluation can earn a maximum of 4 marks

    • An answer with no description can earn a maximum of 5 marks

How do I describe a theory or study?

  • You only have 4 marks for AO1, so state the key information succinctly

  • When you describe a study, cover its:

    • aim

    • method

    • results

    • conclusion

  • It can help to write the letters AMRC in the margin of your exam paper to remind you

  • If the question asks only how a study 'was carried out', describe the method and leave out the results

  • When you describe a theory, set out its main ideas using the correct key terms

  • When a question says 'briefly describe' or 'briefly outline', keep to it

How do I evaluate effectively?

  • AQA does not ask for a set number of evaluation points

    • Think quality over quantity, as two or three points that are fully explained are better than a list of brief ones

  • An effective evaluation point is:

    • specific to the theory or study in the question

    • elaborated, so that it explains why the point is a strength or a weakness

    • finished with a conclusion, which says what the point means for the theory or study

  • For example, in an evaluation of Asch's study of conformity:

    • 'The experiment lacked ecological validity' is a generic point that shows little understanding

    • 'The experiment lacked ecological validity because judging lines in a laboratory is not a natural situation and as a result it may not reflect everyday conformity behaviour' is an elaborated point

  • It is helpful to use lead-in phrases to signpost the different elements of your evaluation, such as:

    • One strength of... is that...

    • This is because...

    • This means that...

    • However, a weakness is that...

  • When you use research evidence to evaluate a theory, do not describe the research

    • State what was found and explain why this supports or challenges the theory

What does 'evaluate the research method used in this study' mean?

  • The research method is the type of study that was carried out, for example:

  • Your evaluation must be about the strengths and weaknesses of that method

    • Evaluating the study in general earns a maximum of 1 mark for AO3

  • Do not confuse the research method with the experimental design or the sampling method, as points about these are not creditworthy

How do I answer a 'discuss whether or not' question?

  • Synoptic questions often ask you to describe two things from different topics and then discuss whether one supports the other

  • Describe both things briefly and accurately, as this is worth 4 marks

  • The discussion is the harder part, so plan it before you write

    • Every discussion point must be linked to the idea in the question

    • A detailed critique of a study earns little credit if you do not say what it means for the theory you have been asked about

  • You do not have to argue both sides, as one fully elaborated argument can be enough

How much should I write in a 9-mark answer?

  • Spend around 9 minutes on a 9-mark question, including planning

  • Aim to write around 200–230 words, with a little more than half on evaluation

  • You do not need an introduction or a separate concluding paragraph, as long as each evaluation point ends by stating what it shows

Worked Example

Here is an example of a 9-mark question:

Q. Describe and evaluate Murdock's serial position curve study.

[9 marks]

Model answer:

Murdock aimed to find out whether the position of a word in a list affects how likely it is to be recalled. Psychology students heard lists of between 10 and 40 unrelated words read out one at a time, then recalled as many as they could in any order. Words at the start of the list (the primacy effect) and at the end (the recency effect) were recalled better than words in the middle, producing a U-shaped serial position curve. Murdock concluded that early words had been rehearsed into long-term memory and the last words were still in short-term memory.

One strength is that this was a laboratory experiment, so extraneous variables such as noise were controlled. This means we can be more confident that serial position, rather than another factor, caused the differences in recall. However, listening to lists of unrelated words is an artificial task that people rarely do in everyday life. This means the study may lack ecological validity, so it may not explain how serial position affects memory for real events. Also, all of the participants were psychology students of a similar age, who may have been more practised at memory tasks than most people. This means the findings may not generalise to older people or to people who are not students.

Word count: 216

Level 3 response: 9 marks

Marking commentary:

This response is in the top level because the description is accurate and detailed, and the evaluation is effective. The first paragraph covers the aim, method, results and conclusion in 100 words, which leaves more than half of the answer for evaluation. Each of the three evaluation points refers to something specific in Murdock's study and ends with a 'This means...' sentence that states what the point shows.

Step-by-step structure:

  • Paragraph 1: The aim, method, results and conclusion of the study are described using key terms (AO1)

  • Paragraph 2: A strength of the method, a weakness of the task and a weakness of the sample are each stated, explained and linked to what they mean for the findings (AO3)

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Raj Bonsor

Author: Raj Bonsor

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Raj joined Save My Exams in 2024 as a Senior Curriculum Expert for Psychology & Sociology. Prior to this, she spent 15 years in the classroom, teaching hundreds of GCSE and A Level students. She has experience as Subject Leader for Psychology and Sociology, and her favourite topics to teach are research methods (especially inferential statistics!) and attachment. She has also successfully taught a number of Level 3 subjects, including criminology, health & social care, and citizenship.