How to Answer a 9 Mark Application Question (AQA GCSE Psychology): Revision Note

Exam code: 8182

Raj Bonsor

Written by: Raj Bonsor

Updated on

How do I answer an AQA GCSE Psychology 9-mark application question?

  • 9-mark application questions can appear in Papers 1 and 2, and they assess your ability to:

    • demonstrate knowledge and understanding of psychological ideas, processes and procedures (assessment objective 1, or AO1)

    • apply your knowledge and understanding to the information you are given (AO2)

    • analyse and evaluate psychological information, ideas, processes and procedures to make judgements and draw conclusions (AO3)

  • The question comes with a stem, such as a conversation or a short piece of information, and tells you to refer to it:

  • The marks available in this question are as follows:

    • AO1 = 3 marks

    • AO2 = 3 marks

    • AO3 = 3 marks

  • Either or both of the 9-mark questions on a paper can be application questions

How is a 9-mark application question marked?

  • Your answer is placed into one of three levels, based on its overall quality:

Level

Marks

What the answer looks like

3 Detailed

7–9

Knowledge is accurate with detail
Application to the stem is clear
Evaluation is effective

2 Clear

4–6

Knowledge has occasional inaccuracies or omissions
Application is reasonable
There may be some effective evaluation

1 Basic

1–3

Knowledge is limited
Application is limited
Evaluation is of limited effectiveness or may be absent

  • The question contains three AOs, and each one has its own 3 marks

    • Giving a lot of detail for one AO does not increase the marks available for it

  • Leaving out an AO limits your mark:

    • an answer that only describes can earn a maximum of 3 marks

    • an answer that describes and applies but does not evaluate can earn a maximum of 6 marks

How do I describe, apply and evaluate in 3 marks each?

  • Describe: select the main ideas and state them accurately using key terms

    • Choose the ideas that you will need for your application

  • Apply: use the names in the stem, pick out specific details and explain the link to the psychology

    • If the question says 'both', refer to both people or both groups

    • Copying a sentence from the stem is not application

  • Evaluate: make one or two points that are specific to the theory or study and say what each one means

    • If the question asks you to evaluate the research method used in a study, evaluate the method and not the study in general

  • Check where the question wants the application to go:

    • 'Refer to the conversation in your answer' lets you apply the stem anywhere in your answer

    • 'Refer to... to support your evaluation' means that the application should be part of your evaluation

  • Application can be a separate paragraph or woven into the rest of your answer, as both are equally acceptable

How much should I write?

  • Spend around 9 minutes on this question, including reading the stem and planning

  • Aim to write around 200–230 words, which is around 70–75 words for each of the three AOs

  • You do not need an introduction or a separate concluding paragraph

Worked Example

Here is an example of a 9-mark application question:

A survey of employees highlighted some differences between two restaurant businesses.

Zuppa is a business that focuses on employee performance and recruiting talented people. Risk taking is not encouraged and people who work at Zuppa often say they dislike challenges.

Bravas places a higher value on the hard work of employees and only recruits people who show willingness to develop new skills. It encourages risk taking, and employees who work in Bravas say they enjoy challenges.

Q. Describe and evaluate Dweck's mindset theory of learning.

In your answer, refer to the mindset encouraged by both restaurant businesses in this information.

[9 marks]

Model answer:

Dweck's mindset theory states that people hold beliefs about where their ability comes from. People with a fixed mindset believe ability is innate and cannot change, so they see failure as a lack of talent and avoid challenges. People with a growth mindset believe ability comes from hard work and perseverance, so they see failure as a chance to learn. Dweck argued that the type of praise we receive shapes our mindset.

Zuppa encourages a fixed mindset, because it focuses on performance and recruits people for their talent. Its employees dislike challenges because failing would suggest they lack talent. Bravas encourages a growth mindset, because it values hard work and recruits people willing to develop new skills. Its employees enjoy challenges because they know they can learn from them, even if they fail. Valuing effort in this way is like process praise, which Dweck says builds a growth mindset.

One strength of the theory is that mindsets can be changed, so it can be used to improve performance in schools, sport and workplaces such as Bravas. There is also research support: Dweck found that teaching children a growth mindset increased their motivation and grades, which supports the theory. However, the theory may be oversimplified, as it ignores other factors that affect success, such as the resources and support people have, so a growth mindset alone may not be enough.

Word count: 229

Level 3 response: 9 marks

Marking commentary:

This response is in the top level because it covers all three of the required elements, in three paragraphs of similar length. In the second paragraph, each business is named, linked to a mindset and given a reason that comes from the information. The evaluation is specific to mindset theory, and the final sentence states what the weakness means.

Step-by-step structure:

  • Paragraph 1: The fixed mindset and the growth mindset are described using key terms (AO1)

  • Paragraph 2: Each restaurant business is linked to a mindset, with reasons taken from the information (AO2)

  • Paragraph 3: A strength, research support and a weakness of the theory are explained (AO3)

How a fully developed application point is built:

  • Name the concept: Bravas encourages a growth mindset

  • Use a detail from the stem: This is because it values hard work and only recruits people who are willing to develop new skills

  • Explain the link: Its employees enjoy challenges because they believe that ability comes from effort, so they know they can learn from a challenge even if they fail

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Raj Bonsor

Author: Raj Bonsor

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Raj joined Save My Exams in 2024 as a Senior Curriculum Expert for Psychology & Sociology. Prior to this, she spent 15 years in the classroom, teaching hundreds of GCSE and A Level students. She has experience as Subject Leader for Psychology and Sociology, and her favourite topics to teach are research methods (especially inferential statistics!) and attachment. She has also successfully taught a number of Level 3 subjects, including criminology, health & social care, and citizenship.