Closest Approach Estimate (AQA A Level Physics): Revision Note

Exam code: 7408

Katie M

Written by: Katie M

Reviewed by: Caroline Carroll

Updated on

Closest Approach Estimate

  • The Coulomb equation for electric potential energy can be used to estimate the radii of nuclei other than gold

  • Initially, the alpha particles have kinetic energy equal to:

Ek = eV = 12mv2

  • The electric potential energy between the two charges is equal to:

Ep = Qq4πε0r

  • This can be expressed as the potential energy at the point of repulsion:

Ep = (2e)(Ze)4πε0r = 2Ze24πε0r

  • Where:

    • Charge of an alpha particle, Q = 2e

    • Charge of the target nucleus, q = Ze

    • Z= proton number of the target nucleus

    • e = elementary charge (C)

    • r = the distance of closest approach (m)

    • ε0 = permittivity of free space

  • When the alpha particle reaches the distance of closest approach (to the target nucleus), all of its kinetic energy Ek has been transformed into electric potential energy Ep

Ek = Ep = 12mv2 = 2Ze24πε0r

  • Rearranging for the distance of closest approach r:

r = 2Ze24πε0Ek = Ze2πε0mv2

  • This gives an upper limit for the radius of the nucleus, assuming the alpha particle is fired at a high energy

Worked Example

The first artificially produced isotope, phosphorus-30 (P15) was formed by bombarding an aluminium-27 isotope (Al13) with an α-particle.

For the reaction to take place, the α-particle must come within a distance r from the centre of the aluminium nucleus.

Calculate the distance r for an α-particle accelerated to a speed of 2.55 × 107 m s–1.

Answer:

Step 1: List the known quantities

  • Mass of α-particle, m = 4u = 4(1.66×1027) kg

  • Speed of the α-particle, v = 2.55×107 m s1

  • Charge of an α-particle, q = 2e = 2(1.6×1019) C

  • Proton number of aluminium, Z = 13

  • Charge of an aluminium nucleus, Q = 13e = 13(1.6×1019) C

  • Permittivity of free space, ε0 = 8.85×1012 F m1

Step 2: Write down the equations for kinetic energy and electric potential energy

Ek = Ep = 12mv2 = Qq4πε0r

12mv2 = 2Ze24πε0r

Step 3: Rearrange for distance, r

r = Ze2πε0mv2

Step 4: Calculate the distance, r

r = 13(1.6×1019)2π(8.85×1012)(4)(1.66×1027)(2.55×107)2

r = 2.77×1015 m

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Make sure you're comfortable with the calculations involved with the alpha particle closest approach method, as this is a common exam question. You will be expected to remember that the charge of an α-particle is the charge of 2 protons (2 × the charge of an electron)

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Build on this topic

Katie M

Author: Katie M

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Katie has always been passionate about the sciences, and completed a degree in Astrophysics at Sheffield University. She decided that she wanted to inspire other young people, so moved to Bristol to complete a PGCE in Secondary Science. She particularly loves creating fun and absorbing materials to help students achieve their exam potential.

Caroline Carroll

Reviewer: Caroline Carroll

Expertise: Head of Content Delivery

Caroline graduated from the University of Nottingham with a degree in Chemistry and Molecular Physics. She spent several years working as an Industrial Chemist in the automotive industry before retraining to teach. Caroline has over 12 years of experience teaching GCSE and A-level chemistry and physics. She is passionate about delivering high-quality resources to help students achieve their full potential.