Limitations of Lewis Structures (College Board AP® Chemistry): Study Guide

Martín

Written by: Martín

Reviewed by: Stewart Hird

Updated on

Limitations of Lewis structures

  • There are some chemical compounds that cannot be represented with Lewis diagrams accurately

  • This occurs because the elements involved do not follow the octet rule

Molecules with an odd number of electrons

  • The most common case is a species with an odd number of valence electrons

  • Species with an odd number of valence electrons must have at least one unpaired electron, so at least one atom cannot have an octet

  • Many are very reactive, although some, like NO and NO2, are stable gases

  • These odd electron species are called free radicals

Examples of odd-electron species

Lewis diagrams of three odd-electron species: nitrogen dioxide, 17 valence electrons, with one unpaired electron on nitrogen; methyl radical, 7 valence electrons, with one unpaired electron on carbon; nitrogen monoxide, 11 valence electrons, N=O with one unpaired electron on nitrogen.

Molecules with an odd number of electrons

Molecules with incomplete octets

  • Some atoms are stable with fewer than eight electrons, such as:

    • Boron in BF3 (6 electrons)

    • Aluminum in AlCl3 (6 electrons)

  • Formal charge, not the octet alone, decides which Lewis diagram is the best model

Molecules with expanded valence shells

  • There are some molecules that exceed the eight electrons in their valence shell

  • An atom with an expanded octet can hold up to ten electrons, or even twelve

  • Atoms of elements in period 3 and below (such as P and S) can have more than eight electrons around them

    • Atoms in period 2 (C, N, O, F) never can

  • Expanded octets occur when a nonmetal central atom from period 3 or below is bonded to highly electronegative terminal atoms such as F, O or Cl

  • The most common atoms that form expanded octets are: S and P

The PCl5 molecule

Lewis structure of PCl5 showing an expanded octet: phosphorus has 10 electrons in five bonding pairs

The octet of the central phosphorus atom has been expanded to hold 10 electrons

The SF6 molecule

Lewis structure of SF6 showing an expanded octet for sulfur containing 12 electrons

The octet of the central sulfur atom has been expanded to hold 12 electrons

Examiner Tips and Tricks

A single unpaired electron on a central atom still counts as an electron domain, so it affects the bond angle (for example, NO2 is bent), although it repels bonding pairs less than a lone pair does.

Never give a period 2 atom (C, N, O or F) more than eight electrons.

Only atoms in period 3 or below can have an expanded octet. For these you only need to give the shape, not an orbital explanation.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Build on this topic

Martín

Author: Martín

Expertise: Chemistry Content Creator

Martín, a dedicated chemistry teacher and tutor, excels in guiding students through IB, AP, and IGCSE Chemistry. As an IB Chemistry student, he came from hands-on preparation, focusing on practical exam techniques and rigorous practice. While at Universidad San Francisco de Quito, his academic journey sparked a passion for computational and physical chemistry. Martín specializes in chemistry, and he knows that SaveMyExams is the right place if he wants to have a positive impact all around the world.

Stewart Hird

Reviewer: Stewart Hird

Expertise: Chemistry Content Creator

Stewart has been an enthusiastic GCSE, IGCSE, A Level and IB teacher for more than 30 years in the UK as well as overseas, and has also been an examiner for IB and A Level. As a long-standing Head of Science, Stewart brings a wealth of experience to creating Topic Questions and revision materials for Save My Exams. Stewart specialises in Chemistry, but has also taught Physics and Environmental Systems and Societies.