Answering 15-Mark Questions (AQA A Level Business): Revision Note

Syllabus Edition

First teaching 2026

First exams 2028

Exam code: 7132

Lisa Eades

Written by: Lisa Eades

Reviewed by: Bridgette Barrett

Updated on

How do I answer an AQA A Level Business 15-mark question?

  • Fifteen-mark questions appear in all three exam papers

    • Each paper has two 15-mark questions: the final question after each case study

    • That makes them worth 30 of the 90 marks on each paper

  • The command word is always Evaluate

  • Three marks are available for knowledge (AO1), three for application (AO2), four for analysis (AO3) and five for evaluation (AO4)

    • Evaluation is worth a third of the marks, so a strong answer must reach a well-supported judgement

  • Every 15-mark question asks you to evaluate two courses of action and recommend one

  • There are two types:

Type

What the question gives you

Example question wording

Decision making

  • Two options, named in the question or the case study

Evaluate both suppliers and recommend which one would be the better choice…

Problem solving

  • A problem or aim

  • You choose the two options yourself

Evaluate two ways the business could reduce the risks it faces and recommend which one it should implement first.

  • Some 15-mark questions also ask you to carry out a calculation and use it in your answer

  • Aim to spend about 18 minutes on a 15-mark question, writing roughly 330–460 words

How 15-mark questions are marked

  • Fifteen-mark questions are marked using five levels

Level

Marks

What the examiner is looking for

5

13–15

  • Application throughout, well-developed analysis of both options

  • Well-supported evaluation that weighs up both options and reaches a coherent overarching judgement

4

10–12

  • Application throughout

  • Developed analysis of both options

  • A supported judgement with some balance

3

7–9

  • Some developed analysis

  • The evaluation may lack balance or not fully focus on the question

2

4–6

  • Some basic analysis and evaluation with limited support

1

1–3

  • Knowledge and basic application

  • Little analysis and a judgement that is just asserted

0

0

  • Nothing creditworthy

  • There are three mark caps to be aware of:

    • An answer that shows only knowledge can score a maximum of 3 marks

    • An answer with knowledge and analysis but no use of the case study and no evaluation can score a maximum of 7 marks

    • An answer with no evaluation can score a maximum of 10 marks

  • The mark scheme states that there must be an overarching judgement to the question, supported by evaluation

    • If your judgement ignores one of the options, or ignores a counterargument you raised earlier, it is unlikely to reach the top level

Suggested structure

  • AQA does not require a set structure

    • You could evaluate each option in turn and then conclude, or make your recommendation clear from the start and then justify it

  • The structure below is a reliable approach for both question types

Example question

Case Study

Brightling Brewery Ltd is an independent brewer of alcohol-free craft beers in Kent. Most of its £2.4m annual revenue comes from selling to local cafés, restaurants and farm shops. It is currently operating at 92% capacity utilisation. The directors want to increase sales and are considering two options.

Option 1 is to supply a national supermarket chain, which would stock its alcohol-free beers in 300 stores. The supermarket would pay a wholesale price 25% lower than its local customers pay.

Option 2 is to open a taproom at the brewery and expand its online shop, at a cost of £180,000. Online sales grew by 40% last year.

Evaluate both options and recommend which one Brightling Brewery Ltd should choose.

[15 marks]

  • Key business skills are highlighted

Four coloured, hand-drawn labels show the assessment skills: “Knowledge”, “Application”, “Analysis” and “Evaluation”, each on a separate yellow, blue, pink or green shape.

Step 1

  • Start off with a brief introduction that shows knowledge of the key concept behind the two options

    • This secures some knowledge (AO1) marks and helps you focus on what the options have in common and how they differ

  • One or two sentences is enough

Highlighted handwritten introduction: “Both options change how Brightling Brewery Ltd distributes its products. Option 1 is an indirect channel through a retailer, while Option 2 is a direct channel that sells straight to consumers.” Uses distribution channels.

Step 2

Make a strong argument for the first option

  • Support it with context from the case study

  • Develop a chain of reasoning using the X→Y→Z approach, ending at what the business wants to achieve

Annotated handwritten argument for Option 1: supplying 300 stores would reach customers beyond Kent, increase sales volume and create purchasing economies of scale, lowering unit costs despite the lower price.

Step 3

  • Show balance by making a counterargument for the first option

    • A further chain of X→Y→Z reasoning with context is required

  • Finish the paragraph with a short judgement on this option

    • Top-level answers show evaluation throughout, not just at the end

  • Where relevant, use a sophisticated concept: a theory, model or framework that is not the main focus of the question but strengthens your analysis

Annotated counterargument for Option 1: a 25% lower supermarket price cuts margins; at 92% capacity, large orders need costly equipment; buyer power may push prices lower. Judgement: greatest sales growth but risk.

Step 4

  • Now move on to the second option, making a strong argument in its favour with context and an X→Y→Z chain

Annotated model paragraph supporting Option 2: as a direct channel, Brightling keeps the full selling price; 40% online growth shows demand, while a taproom builds loyalty and enables premium prices and higher margins.

Step 5

  • Show balance with a counterargument for the second option, again ending with a short judgement

Annotated handwritten counterargument for Option 2: the £180,000 investment may limit growth to visitors and online shoppers, while 40% online growth may not continue. Judgement: lower risk but smaller, slower gains.

Step 6

Finish with an overarching judgement. This should be the most developed section of your answer

  • Make a clear recommendation

  • Compare the options directly. Explain why your chosen option is better for this business and why the other one has been rejected

  • Explain what your recommendation depends on

  • Make sure your judgement deals with the counterarguments you raised earlier

Highlighted handwritten model conclusion recommends Option 2 because Brightling’s 92% capacity makes Option 1’s supermarket order require costly expansion; Option 2 protects margins. It depends on financing £180,000; Option 1 may suit later.

Making your judgement stronger

  • Use the following checklist when planning your final paragraph:

    • Priorities: which option best meets the business's main objective or solves its most urgent problem?

    • Time: would your answer be different in the short term and the long term?

    • Depends on: what key factor would change your recommendation?

    • Challenge the data: is any of the information in the case study unreliable, out of date or based on a forecast?

    • Risk: which option is riskier, and can the business afford that risk?

Common mistakes

  • Analysing only one option in depth

    • Level 4 and Level 5 both require developed analysis of both options

  • Not making a recommendation

    • The question tells you to recommend one

      • With no evaluation at all, the maximum is 10 marks

  • A one-sided judgement

    • Explain why you rejected the other option, not just why you chose yours

  • Repeating earlier points in the conclusion

    • Your judgement should add something: a direct comparison, what it depends on, or the short-term and long-term view

  • Choosing options that do not fit the case study

    • In problem-solving questions, the relevance of your options to the business is part of what is assessed

How do I choose my own two options?

  • In a problem-solving 15-mark question, you choose the two options yourself

    • E.g. Evaluate two sources of external finance that the business could use and recommend which one it should choose

  • The examiner will consider how relevant your options are to the context, so choose carefully

  • Spend a minute planning before you write:

    • Pick options that clearly solve the problem in the question

    • Pick two options that are clearly different

      • Two very similar options make the comparison weak

    • Pick options that the case study gives you evidence for, both for and against

    • Pick options you can analyse confidently

      • A familiar option you can develop fully is better than an ambitious one you cannot explain

Example plan

Case Study

Brightling Brewery Ltd

Brightling Brewery Ltd, an alcohol-free craft brewer, is operating at 92% capacity utilisation

Evaluate two ways Brightling Brewery Ltd could increase its capacity and recommend which one it should implement first. [15 marks]

Option

Why it fits the context

Arguments for

Arguments against

Add an evening shift

Demand peaks in summer, so extra capacity may only be needed for part of the year

Quick to introduce

Uses existing equipment

No large investment

Higher labour costs (overtime or new staff)

Harder to supervise quality

Staff may resist unsocial hours

Buy new fermentation tanks

A permanent increase in capacity supports long-term growth

Lowers unit costs over time

Allows future growth, e.g. supplying new customers

Large upfront cost

Takes time to install

Capacity may sit idle in winter

  • These options work well because they are clearly different: one is short-term and flexible, the other long-term and costly

    • This makes it easier to write a strong judgement about which to implement first

How do I answer a 15-mark question with a calculation?

  • The question still uses Evaluate and tells you which calculation to carry out

    • E.g. Evaluate whether the business should launch in Region A or Region B. Calculate the return on investment in Region B to support your answer.

  • 6 of the 15 marks are for quantitative skills, split in the same way as a 9-mark calculation question:

Skill

What you need to do

Marks

AO1 Knowledge

Show the correct formula and select the right figures

2

AO2 Application

Carry out the calculation correctly

2

AO3 Analysis

Interpret the result and use it in an argument

1

AO4 Evaluation

Use the result to support your judgement

1

  • The other 9 marks (AO1 1, AO2 1, AO3 3, AO4 4) are for wider analysis and evaluation of both options

  • Three rules from the mark scheme are worth knowing:

    • A correct calculation with no analysis or evaluation scores 4 marks

    • An answer that does not use the calculation can score a maximum of 9 marks

  • The Own Figure Rule always applies

    • If you make a mistake in the calculation but interpret your answer correctly, you can still earn analysis and evaluation marks

    • However, if you select the wrong figures, the calculation itself earns no credit

  • Follow the same six steps as above, but build the calculation into the option it relates to, then use it again in your final judgement

Example question

Case Study

Brightling Brewery Ltd

The business is an independent brewer of alcohol-free craft beers in Kent. Most of its £2.4m annual revenue comes from selling to local cafés, restaurants and farm shops. It is currently operating at 92% capacity utilisation. The directors want to increase sales and are considering two options.

Option 1 is to supply a national supermarket chain, which would stock its alcohol-free beers in 300 stores. The supermarket would pay a wholesale price 25% lower than its local customers pay.

Option 2 is to open a taproom at the brewery and expand its online shop, at a cost of £180,000. Online sales grew by 40% last year.

The taproom would have annual fixed costs of £96,000. The average visitor would spend £14, and the variable cost per visitor would be £6. The directors forecast 15,000 visitors in the first year.

Evaluate both options and recommend which one Brightling Brewery Ltd should choose.

Calculate the break-even number of visitors per year for the taproom to support your answer.

[15 marks]

  • Key business skills are highlighted

Four coloured, hand-drawn labels show the assessment skills: “Knowledge”, “Application”, “Analysis” and “Evaluation”, each on a separate yellow, blue, pink or green shape.

Step 1

  • Start off with a brief introduction that shows knowledge of the key concept behind the two options

    • This secures some knowledge (AO1) marks and helps you focus on what the options have in common and how they differ

  • One or two sentences is enough

Highlighted handwritten introduction: “Both options change how Brightling Brewery Ltd distributes its products. Option 1 is an indirect channel through a retailer, while Option 2 is a direct channel that sells straight to consumers.” Uses distribution channels.

Step 2

Make a strong argument for the first option

  • Support it with context from the case study

  • Develop a chain of reasoning using the X→Y→Z approach, ending at what the business wants to achieve

Annotated handwritten argument for Option 1: supplying 300 stores would reach customers beyond Kent, increase sales volume and create purchasing economies of scale, lowering unit costs despite the lower price.

Step 3

  • Show balance by making a counterargument for the first option

    • A further chain of X→Y→Z reasoning with context is required

  • Finish the paragraph with a short judgement on this option

    • Top-level answers show evaluation throughout, not just at the end

  • Where relevant, use a sophisticated concept: a theory, model or framework that is not the main focus of the question but strengthens your analysis

Annotated counterargument for Option 1: a 25% lower supermarket price cuts margins; at 92% capacity, large orders need costly equipment; buyer power may push prices lower. Judgement: greatest sales growth but risk.

Step 4

Move on to the second option and build the calculation into it

  • Write out the formula and show which figures you are using

  • Carry out the calculation, giving your answer with the correct units

  • Interpret the result straight away: what does it tell you about this option?

Completed taproom calculation: £14 − £6 gives £8 contribution per visitor; £96,000 ÷ £8 = 12,000 visitors to break even. A 15,000 forecast gives a 3,000-visitor (20%) margin of safety and £24,000 profit.

Step 5

  • Show balance with a counterargument for the second option

    • Where you can, challenge the figure you calculated. Is it based on a forecast or an assumption?

  • End the paragraph with a short judgement on this option

Annotated counterargument for Option 2: Option 2 costs £180,000; if the taproom's £24,000 annual profit had to cover this alone, it would take about 7.5 years to recover the investment, and only if the forecast is met. If visitor numbers fall by over 20%, it makes a loss. Lower risk, but smaller, slower gains.

Step 6

Finish with an overarching judgement that uses your calculated figure as evidence

  • Make a clear recommendation and compare the options directly

  • Explain why the other option has been rejected

  • Explain what your recommendation depends on

Highlighted handwritten conclusion recommends Option 2: 12,000 break-even visitors from a 15,000 forecast gives 20% margin of safety; Option 1 needs costly expansion. Depends on realistic demand and £180,000 funding.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring the calculation in the judgement

    • In calculation questions, an answer that does not use the result cannot score more than 9

Examiner Tips and Tricks

With 5 evaluation marks, the 15-mark question rewards judgement more than any other question type. Show evaluation throughout your answer by ending each option with a short judgement, then bring them together in your final paragraph.

A strong recommendation usually sounds like this: "[Business] should choose Option X, because [main reason linked to the context], whereas Option Y [main weakness]. However, this depends on [key factor]."

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Lisa Eades

Author: Lisa Eades

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Lisa has taught A Level, GCSE, BTEC and IBDP Business for over 20 years and is a senior Examiner for Edexcel. Lisa has been a successful Head of Department in Kent and has offered private Business tuition to students across the UK. Lisa loves to create imaginative and accessible resources which engage learners and build their passion for the subject.

Bridgette Barrett

Reviewer: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.