Answering 9-Mark Questions (AQA A Level Business): Revision Note

Syllabus Edition

First teaching 2026

First exams 2028

Exam code: 7132

Lisa Eades

Written by: Lisa Eades

Reviewed by: Bridgette Barrett

Updated on

How do I answer an AQA A Level Business 9-mark question?

  • Nine-mark questions appear in all three exam papers

    • Each paper has four 9-mark questions: the third and fourth questions after each case study

    • That makes them worth 36 of the 90 marks on each paper, more than any other question type

  • The command word is always Assess, e.g.:

    • Assess whether increasing spending on X would lead to higher profits

    • Assess how important Y is likely to be…

  • Two marks are available for knowledge (AO1), two for application (AO2), two for analysis (AO3) and three for evaluation (AO4)

    • Evaluation is worth the most marks, so your judgement matters

  • The question asks you to weigh up the case for and against one issue and then reach a judgement

    • E.g. whether to raise a price, launch a product or spend more on something

    • You only need to make a decision on this issue

    • You do not need to suggest alternatives

  • Some nine-mark questions also ask you to carry out a calculation and use it in your answer

    • These are covered in the second part of this page

  • Aim to spend about 10 minutes on a 9-mark question, writing roughly 230–360 words

How 9-mark questions are marked

  • Nine-mark questions are marked using three levels

Level

Marks

What the examiner is looking for

3

7–9

Good application to the context, logical chains of reasoning, and evaluation that weighs up the arguments and reaches a convincing judgement that fully answers the question

2

4–6

Good application and basic chains of reasoning, with some supported evaluation, but the arguments may not be weighed up against each other

1

1–3

Some knowledge and an attempt to use the context, but little analysis and a judgement that is just asserted

0

0

Nothing creditworthy

  • There are three mark caps to be aware of:

    • An answer that shows only knowledge can score a maximum of 2 marks

    • An answer with knowledge and analysis but no use of the case study and no judgement can score a maximum of 4 marks

    • An answer with no evaluation can score a maximum of 6 marks

  • To reach Level 3, the mark scheme says there must be a clear answer to the question that weighs up an argument and a counterargument

Suggested structure

  • AQA does not require a set structure

    • You could argue for and against and then conclude, evaluate as you go, or even open with your judgement and then support it

  • The structure below is a reliable way to make sure you cover every assessment objective

Example question

Case Study

Kettle & Crumb Ltd

The business runs a busy bakery café in the centre of York. Around 40% of its customers are tourists. Most of the rest are local office workers who visit on weekdays, many of whom use a loyalty card. Over the past year, the cost of butter and flour has risen by 18%. A branch of a national coffee chain, 200 metres away, charges around 15% less for similar drinks and pastries. The owners are considering raising all prices by 10%.

Assess whether raising prices by 10% would increase profit for Kettle & Crumb Ltd.

[9 marks]

  • Key business skills are highlighted

Colour key: yellow represents Knowledge, blue represents Application, pink represents Analysis, and green represents Evaluation.

Step 1

  • Start off by defining the key term in the question, or the business concept that will drive your answer

    • This secures knowledge (AO1) marks and gives your answer a clear focus

  • Keep it brief - there are only 2 AO1 marks

Annotated Step 1 answer: “Profit is total revenue minus total costs. Whether a price rise increases profit depends largely on price elasticity of demand (PED), which measures customer sensitivity to price changes.” Yellow highlights knowledge.

Step 2

Make your first argument, supporting one side of the question

  • Support it with relevant context from the case study

  • Develop a chain of reasoning using the X→Y→Z approach

    • E.g. X leads to Y, which results in Z

  • Make sure your chain ends at the exact thing the question asks about (here, profit, not just sales or revenue)

Annotated Step 2 answer: 40% of customers are tourists, so demand is likely price inelastic; a 10% price rise raises revenue and profit, helping offset the 18% rise in ingredient costs. Highlights show application and analysis.

Step 3

Now show balance by making a counterargument

  • Make a logical, relevant counterpoint that also links to the question

  • Use a different piece of context from the case study

  • A further chain of X→Y→Z reasoning is required

Annotated Step 3 counterargument: local office workers are more price-sensitive; a nearby chain is 15% cheaper, so a 10% rise makes Kettle & Crumb almost 30% dearer. Regulars may switch, reducing revenue and profit, especially in quieter months.

Step 4

  • In your final paragraph, make a supported judgement

    • Give a clear answer to the question: yes, no, or yes in some circumstances

    • Weigh up your two arguments. Which is stronger for this business, and why?

    • Explain what your judgement depends on, using the case study

  • With 3 marks for evaluation, this should be the most developed part of your answer

  • A judgement that simply repeats your earlier points, or is not supported, is not creditworthy evaluation

Annotated model judgement: a price rise is likely to increase Kettle & Crumb Ltd’s short-term profit because its tourist base makes demand price inelastic and offsets rising costs. It depends on regulars’ reactions; a loyalty discount reduces risk.

Common mistakes

  • Leaving the judgement out

    • Without evaluation, the maximum is 6 marks

    • Always finish with a clear answer to the question

  • Sitting on the fence

    • "It depends" is only creditworthy if you explain what it depends on and still give an answer

  • Drifting into a different issue

    • A 9-mark question asks you to judge one issue

    • You do not need to suggest alternative strategies

Examiner Tips and Tricks

Decide your answer before you start writing. Jot "yes", "no" or "only if…" in your plan, next to the one fact from the case study that tips the balance. Each paragraph can then build towards that judgement instead of drifting.

How do I answer a 9-mark question with a calculation?

  • Every paper includes questions with a quantitative focus, where you must carry out a calculation and use the result in your answer

    • Papers 1 and 2 have two of these, and Paper 3 has one

    • Each is worth either 9 or 15 marks

  • The question still uses the command word Assess, and it tells you which calculation to carry out

  • The calculation is not a separate task

    • It is the evidence for your argument and your judgement

How the marks are split

  • Six of the 9 marks are for quantitative skills:

Skill

What you need to do

Marks

AO1 Knowledge

Show the correct formula and select the right figures

2

AO2 Application

Carry out the calculation correctly

2

AO3 Analysis

Interpret the result and use it in an argument

1

AO4 Evaluation

Use the result to support your judgement

1

  • The other 3 marks (AO3 1, AO4 2) are for wider analysis and evaluation linked to the calculation

    • E.g. comparing your result with other information in the case study, or considering the limitations of the data

  • Three rules from the mark scheme are worth knowing:

    • A correct calculation on its own, with no analysis or evaluation, scores 4 marks

    • An answer based only on the calculation, without using other information from the case study, can score a maximum of 6 marks

    • The Own Figure Rule always applies

      • If you make a mistake in the calculation but interpret your wrong answer correctly, you can still earn analysis and evaluation marks

Suggested structure

Example question

Case Study

Rowan Vets Ltd

The business operates nine veterinary practices in Shropshire. In 2026 it opened its ninth practice and increased its workforce from 170 staff on 1 January to 190 staff on 31 December. During 2026, 43 staff left the business. Of these, 18 left within six months of joining. The employee turnover for veterinary practices across the sector is 15%. Rowan Vets Ltd's employee turnover in 2025 was 31.0%. Two of its practices are currently short of vets, and it costs around £8,000 to recruit each new vet.

Assess whether Rowan Vets Ltd has a serious problem with staff retention.

Calculate the employee turnover for Rowan Vets Ltd in 2026 to support your answer. Give your answer to one decimal place.

[9 marks]

  • Key business skills are highlighted

Colour key: yellow represents Knowledge, blue represents Application, pink represents Analysis, and green represents Evaluation.

Step 1

  • Write out the formula and show which figures you are using

    • This earns AO1 marks even if you later make an arithmetic error

  • Check carefully that you have picked the right figures. Wrong figures mean no credit for the calculation

Annotated calculation showing the employee turnover formula: number of staff leaving ÷ number of staff employed by the business × 100. It calculates the average number of staff as (170 + 190) ÷ 2 = 180 and notes the correct figures are selected.

Step 2

Carry out the calculation, showing your working

  • Give your answer to the number of decimal places the question asks for

  • Include the correct units (e.g. %, £, times). An answer with the wrong units is treated as inaccurate

Completed employee turnover calculation: 43 divided by 180, multiplied by 100, equals 23.9%. It is correctly rounded to one decimal place and includes the percentage unit.

Step 3

Interpret your result and use it in an argument

  • Say what the figure means, then compare it with a benchmark in the case study, such as an industry average, a previous year or a target

  • Develop an X→Y→Z chain that links the figure to the question

Annotated Step 3 answer: 23.9% turnover means almost one in four staff left Rowan Vets Ltd, above the 15% sector average. Recruitment costs £8,000 per vet, causing shortages and pressure that could lead to further leavers.

Step 4

Now show balance by using other information in the case study to challenge or add to what the figure suggests

  • Is the trend improving or getting worse?

  • Is there a one-off reason for the result?

  • Does the figure hide anything? Considering the limitations of the data is a strong form of evaluation

Annotated Step 4 answer: turnover fell from 31.0% in 2025, but 18 of 43 leavers left within six months, possibly due to rapid recruitment for the ninth practice. Excluding them gives 13.9%, below the sector average.

Step 5

Make a supported judgement that uses your calculated figure

  • Give a clear answer to the question

  • Weigh up what the calculation shows against the wider information

  • Explain what your judgement depends on

Annotated model judgement: Rowan Vets Ltd still has a serious retention problem: turnover is 23.9%, above average and causing shortages, but improving after expansion; it depends on retaining recruits beyond six months.

Common mistakes

  • Calculating and then moving on

    • In a calculation question, a correct answer alone is worth 4 marks

    • The rest of the marks come from using the figure

  • Not showing working

    • If your final answer is wrong, the examiner can only credit your formula and figure selection if they can see them

  • Rounding too early

    • Keep full figures in your calculator and only round your final answer to the number of decimal places asked for

Examiner Tips and Tricks

In calculation questions, compare your figure with something else in the case study. A figure on its own, such as 23.9%, tells the examiner very little until you show whether it is high or low for this business.

Unlock more, it's free!

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Lisa Eades

Author: Lisa Eades

Expertise: Curriculum Expert

Lisa has taught A Level, GCSE, BTEC and IBDP Business for over 20 years and is a senior Examiner for Edexcel. Lisa has been a successful Head of Department in Kent and has offered private Business tuition to students across the UK. Lisa loves to create imaginative and accessible resources which engage learners and build their passion for the subject.

Bridgette Barrett

Reviewer: Bridgette Barrett

Expertise: Development Editor

After graduating with a degree in Geography, Bridgette completed a PGCE over 30 years ago. She later gained an MA Learning, Technology and Education from the University of Nottingham focussing on online learning. At a time when the study of geography has never been more important, Bridgette is passionate about creating content which supports students in achieving their potential in geography and builds their confidence.